greg4012 wrote:The fate of the 3 ball did a lot of work.
This is the big one that people don’t like to talk about enough. The reality is neither of those teams had any business reaching the finals, and fluke occurrences greatly aided both runs (the bubble in 2020 along with pretty good shooting from outside, and ridiculous outside shooting in 2023). If that all happened from 2010-2013, or 2000-2003 or most other 4 year stretches in league history, they probably don’t reach the finals at all.
That’s not to take away from what they did, they got it done so full credit. But there was a lot of variance and circumstance we benefited from those seasons so to assume they should have won a chip if the right move was made, is hubris, and disrespectful to the 2020 Lakers and 2023 Nuggets.
Also I don’t see how we did anything wrong in the Dame situation, we didn’t tell his stupid agent to say “only Miami” and get the league and Portland working against us. And if we had given our best package that doesn’t include Jimmy or Bam, then you’re talking about Tyler (who is performing at Dame’s level this season), Niko (developing well and still cheap) and the pick we used for Ware. We probably go nowhere with Dame, we are watching Tyler light it up in Portland (or wherever they rerouted him to), and the posters here are killing Pat for mortgaging our future for two geriatrics and possibly getting Bam to leave Miami.
Oh and I give Jimmy full credit for the things he DID do while he was here, but there is a degree of overrating with his play. He lives in this sort of weird headspace for most fans where people give him all his credit for his superstar moments he's had, but simultaneously never expect them moving forward, so he never gets real superstar criticism when he's quiet or disappears.
- In 2020 he filled a Scottie Pippen role on a team of Pippens, but had two huge Finals games so gets all the credit for that run when it was the most ensemble cast of any we've had.
- 2022 was his best run imo and he doesn't get credit enough because it didn't end at the Finals, but also he doesn't really get criticized even though it was a 1 seed that lost a game 7 at home.
- 2023 he had a historic series against Milwaukee, but he was good to mediocre the next 3 rounds. The ankle injury had a lot to do with it, but people give him a pass for that and just say he had a great playoffs ignoring that other than getting in Grant Williams face and mean mugging for the camera, he was just average the next 3 rounds, and basically invisible against Denver in the Finals.
That's to say nothing of the fact he missed roughly 25% of all regular season games per year, or missed the entire 2024 playoffs, or was putrid in 2021 (I know the team had a ridiculously short offseason, but that was like JO vs the Celtics in 2010 levels of bad and he's almost never critiqued for it).
Sorry but I’ve been around long enough to know Monday morning quarterbacking when I see it. Same arguments, different year.
greg4012 wrote:
Antagonizing Riley for not allowing Bosh to risk his life on the court and for getting the runaround from Lebron seems like wild work. Am I misremembering here?
lol criticizing the franchise for anything to do with Bosh is a WILD take, he got more money than Wade in 2014 when LeBron left, had the offense restructured to feature him with Dwyane taking a backseat when he was healthy, and had the franchises full support throughout his medical situation. Chris has had nothing but glowing things to say about Miami, and in interviews looks at himself as more of a Heat than a Raptor even though he spent less time here and had his best statistical years by far in Toronto.