KyRo23 wrote:Exp0sed wrote:UglyBugBall wrote:
The real MVP's in the past either carried their teams to a near top seed or didn't get awarded MVP. Jokic has been getting awards for absolute empty stat team mediocrity in the regular season.
real MVPs played with other star and even superstars. that's in, two or three all time greats and hall of famers playing together.
Jokic has never played alongside another all-star and he's the only MVP in history to have never played with another all-star, 10 years into his career - that's still the case
and ur right, the one time Murray played liked an all-star in the playoffs, he won a chip. go figure...

This isn’t true. Murray played like an all star in the playoffs in the 2019-2020 season in which they didn’t win. You could argue he played better this season than their championship run
Murray played great in those runs, but there is still a reason why he's talked about as a guy who can "play like an all star" rather than being an All Star. The 2020 run was 19 games. The 2023 title run was 20. Between them, Murray failed to score 20 points 14 times (7 times a year). To put that in perspective, SGA had 6 sub 20 point games all last season. And those low scoring games weren't due to Murray not taking shots as others were scoring. They generally were mid to high teens in attempts and 40s, 30s, 20% range for FG%. 7 of those games he had less points than field goal attempts.
So basically in a bit more than 1/3 of the two playoff runs that people hold up as All Star Murray, he wasn't very good. But in another 1/3 he scored 30 or more and in 5 of those games he scored 40 or more (though 3 of those 5 were in the first series of 2020 against Utah, he's only had 2 since, both exactly 40).
That's the duality of Murray. He's an amazing shot maker when he's on, but isn't great at drawing fouls or getting easy buckets, so when he's off, he's really off and will sometimes shoot you out of the game. He's an OK passer, but better as a secondary passer with Jokic than as the offensive originator, so the Nuggets have never been quite as successful staggering star minutes as they'd like. He's pretty strong for his size and will fight on defense, especially against bigger guys, but isn't a particularly good defender (and looked bad earlier this year, but has improved).
So basically, Murray is a good to very good player who is awesome to watch when he's on. And on those "on" days, he can score with anyone in the league, but who has more off days and less broad excellence than the tier of guards above him. I'm a fan of Murray, but there wasn't a year where I ever thought that he was robbed of an All Star birth, though in any single game, he can go head to head with almost any of those guys.