Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
Moderators: Chris Porter's Hair, floppymoose, Sleepy51
Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
-
- Analyst
- Posts: 3,227
- And1: 1,037
- Joined: Jul 02, 2019
-
Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
Jester_ wrote:(Referring to the practice of butt caning) Yeah that's why we (Singapore) have beautiful streets and safe communities while y'all (San Francisco) live in bum-adled squalor and think it's freedom
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
- cladden
- Analyst
- Posts: 3,508
- And1: 437
- Joined: Oct 13, 2006
-
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
I like it. Not completely unearned IMO.
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
- cpower
- RealGM
- Posts: 20,832
- And1: 8,668
- Joined: Mar 03, 2011
-
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
thats beyond terrible, they are using rebounds and steals to define defense. Draymond is top 8 defense for sure
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
- KevinMcreynolds
- RealGM
- Posts: 13,171
- And1: 3,494
- Joined: Feb 07, 2010
- Location: Sacramento
-
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
#1 must be Erick Dampier
floppymoose wrote:Too much Vlad. Sixers can't handle it. Solid gold.
"I'm a big proponent of footwork. Believe me." ~Jim Barnett
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
-
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 5,678
- And1: 1,966
- Joined: Jun 17, 2004
-
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
Some of those guys ahead of Draymond were absolute monsters defensively. People forget Garnett in Minnesota was amazing, I saw games where he guarded Kobe and McGrady the best I had ever seen. Mind you Garnett is a guy who finished his career at center, the fact that he was guarding two of the best shooting guards is something.
Rodman was another guy, started on the perimeter guarding guys like Jordan then finished his career guarding guys like Malone. How he grabbed so many rebounds at his size is just almost a modern mystery, 18 rpg? Crazy.
Ben Wallace was good, as a help defender just so much quickness and timing around the hoop.
Dwight Howard in his prime could clean up the paint better than anyone I've ever seen. Better than Dikembe or Gobert imo. Quicker feet and better leaping ability to get to the spot.
Dray is the best disruptive defender of that bunch. Drays ability is his eye for seeing things.
Rodman was another guy, started on the perimeter guarding guys like Jordan then finished his career guarding guys like Malone. How he grabbed so many rebounds at his size is just almost a modern mystery, 18 rpg? Crazy.
Ben Wallace was good, as a help defender just so much quickness and timing around the hoop.
Dwight Howard in his prime could clean up the paint better than anyone I've ever seen. Better than Dikembe or Gobert imo. Quicker feet and better leaping ability to get to the spot.
Dray is the best disruptive defender of that bunch. Drays ability is his eye for seeing things.
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
-
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 5,764
- And1: 4,131
- Joined: Jul 26, 2012
-
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
Camby and O'Neal over Ewing??? Need to close this list and forget forever.
Thurmond 26th
Cumby 27th
This is Wilt career numbers against Nate
RS 47games 15.5pts
PS 17games 12.5pts
Thurmond 26th
Cumby 27th
This is Wilt career numbers against Nate
RS 47games 15.5pts
PS 17games 12.5pts
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
- oaktownwarriors87
- RealGM
- Posts: 13,854
- And1: 4,418
- Joined: Mar 01, 2005
-
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
KevinMcreynolds wrote:#1 must be Erick Dampier
Danny Fortson, but close.
cdubbz wrote:Donte DiVincenzo will outplay Poole this season.
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
-
- Pro Prospect
- Posts: 847
- And1: 36
- Joined: May 31, 2006
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
Not many players on that list can guard 1-5 and has done it in the playoffs and finals.
Keith not so Smart
Mark don't know JACK about coaching..
Kerr Riding Coattails
Mark don't know JACK about coaching..
Kerr Riding Coattails
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
-
- General Manager
- Posts: 9,964
- And1: 1,502
- Joined: Mar 25, 2011
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
I would take prime Dray as a defender over DRob, Wilt and maybe Dwight
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 20,387
- And1: 1,642
- Joined: Jul 15, 2005
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
Where does Jordan Poole rank on the list?
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
- cladden
- Analyst
- Posts: 3,508
- And1: 437
- Joined: Oct 13, 2006
-
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
Jester_ wrote:I would take prime Dray as a defender over DRob, Wilt and maybe Dwight
I mean I didn't watch Wilt so it's hard to say. I think it's inherently easier to be an impactful defender as a center than a tweener PF. I think Dray's skills on the defensive end surpasses Dwight and David Robinson (AFAICT I was pretty young during his tenure) but his impact not necessarily so. It's a tough question. The only defender I can recall that was decidedly on his level in the present day was Kawhi for a couple years but it didn't last that long. He was unbelievable that time the Spurs beat the Miami Lebrons but he has nowhere near the same career impact. I suspect you have to go to Rodman to find someone equally skilled. Centers play on easy mode when it comes to defensive impact. I have to plead ignorance on Pippen. I was a child during his prime.
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
- KevinMcreynolds
- RealGM
- Posts: 13,171
- And1: 3,494
- Joined: Feb 07, 2010
- Location: Sacramento
-
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
Twinkie defense wrote:Where does Jordan Poole rank on the list?

floppymoose wrote:Too much Vlad. Sixers can't handle it. Solid gold.
"I'm a big proponent of footwork. Believe me." ~Jim Barnett
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
- Coxy
- RealGM
- Posts: 48,567
- And1: 15,020
- Joined: Jun 17, 2008
-
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
cladden wrote:Jester_ wrote:I would take prime Dray as a defender over DRob, Wilt and maybe Dwight
I mean I didn't watch Wilt so it's hard to say. I think it's inherently easier to be an impactful defender as a center than a tweener PF. I think Dray's skills on the defensive end surpasses Dwight and David Robinson (AFAICT I was pretty young during his tenure) but his impact not necessarily so. It's a tough question. The only defender I can recall that was decidedly on his level in the present day was Kawhi for a couple years but it didn't last that long. He was unbelievable that time the Spurs beat the Miami Lebrons but he has nowhere near the same career impact. I suspect you have to go to Rodman to find someone equally skilled. Centers play on easy mode when it comes to defensive impact. I have to plead ignorance on Pippen. I was a child during his prime.
Of every player in the NBA I've watched since the early 90's, Pippen was by far the best all round defensive player I've seen. He's number 1 for me. There was nothing on defense that he wasn't elite at with that ridiculously long and athletic frame.
The best defensive big man I've watched is Duncan. He wasn't the best shot blocker, but as a man defender, and patroller of the paint, he was amazing. So smart.
Best starting 5 defensive team I've watched.
Payton
Jordan
Pippen
Duncan
Hakeem
Good luck beating that team in all their primes.
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
- EvanZ
- RealGM
- Posts: 14,771
- And1: 4,105
- Joined: Apr 06, 2011
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
Coxy wrote:cladden wrote:Jester_ wrote:I would take prime Dray as a defender over DRob, Wilt and maybe Dwight
I mean I didn't watch Wilt so it's hard to say. I think it's inherently easier to be an impactful defender as a center than a tweener PF. I think Dray's skills on the defensive end surpasses Dwight and David Robinson (AFAICT I was pretty young during his tenure) but his impact not necessarily so. It's a tough question. The only defender I can recall that was decidedly on his level in the present day was Kawhi for a couple years but it didn't last that long. He was unbelievable that time the Spurs beat the Miami Lebrons but he has nowhere near the same career impact. I suspect you have to go to Rodman to find someone equally skilled. Centers play on easy mode when it comes to defensive impact. I have to plead ignorance on Pippen. I was a child during his prime.
Of every player in the NBA I've watched since the early 90's, Pippen was by far the best all round defensive player I've seen. He's number 1 for me. There was nothing on defense that he wasn't elite at with that ridiculously long and athletic frame.
The best defensive big man I've watched is Duncan. He wasn't the best shot blocker, but as a man defender, and patroller of the paint, he was amazing. So smart.
Best starting 5 defensive team I've watched.
Payton
Jordan
Pippen
Duncan
Hakeem
Good luck beating that team in all their primes.
lol yeah, I heard these guys were good on offense too
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 20,387
- And1: 1,642
- Joined: Jul 15, 2005
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
Before the three point shot became so dominant centers weren't asked to switch onto guards and defend the perimeter. A lot of the all-time great bigs would have trouble defending in today's NBA. I consider Shaq to be maybe the most dominant player in NBA history and I wonder if he could stay on the court if he was a young player in the year 2025 (though he would probably be shooting threes lol). Could you see Patrick Ewing chasing Stephen Curry around? No.
I think Wilt would still be an elite defender if he played in the modern era though.
I think Wilt would still be an elite defender if he played in the modern era though.
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
- floppymoose
- Senior Mod - Warriors
- Posts: 59,303
- And1: 17,420
- Joined: Jun 22, 2003
- Location: Trust your election workers
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
Yeah Camby hunted blocks more than played defense.
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
-
- Senior
- Posts: 659
- And1: 204
- Joined: Jul 15, 2021
-
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
Hakeem was the best I ever saw. Blocks, steals, boards, he had it all. He had the quickness to guard centers, pf, and sf's.....
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
-
- General Manager
- Posts: 9,964
- And1: 1,502
- Joined: Mar 25, 2011
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
Twinkie defense wrote:Before the three point shot became so dominant centers weren't asked to switch onto guards and defend the perimeter. A lot of the all-time great bigs would have trouble defending in today's NBA. I consider Shaq to be maybe the most dominant player in NBA history and I wonder if he could stay on the court if he was a young player in the year 2025 (though he would probably be shooting threes lol). Could you see Patrick Ewing chasing Stephen Curry around? No.
I think Wilt would still be an elite defender if he played in the modern era though.
Young Shaq was basically a beefier Giannis. He was also a very underrated defender. I think he would've adjusted fine
Lakers onwards fat Shaq i dono about though
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
-
- Veteran
- Posts: 2,696
- And1: 1,855
- Joined: Aug 30, 2021
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
Dunno about rodman top 5 but seeing some of the names on that list its puts into perspective how good draymonds been to be listed among those greats
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
-
- Sixth Man
- Posts: 1,910
- And1: 1,149
- Joined: Feb 23, 2009
-
Re: Draymond ranked 13th greatest defensive NBA player ever...
Not mad about that. Looks around right to me. And yeah, the only one I really questioned is Rodman.
Return to Golden State Warriors