NoDopeOnSundays wrote:Guano wrote:I cant see ilia not getting a title shot. It would be insane for him to vacate the belt for a contender fight.
That's an idiotic rule to be honest, you'd think they'd want guys to be double champs. Having a guy vacate his belt cheapens it for the next person that wins it, because it'll always be "You didn't beat the champ" to get it.
That's generally the debate, but the trade-off of keeping divisions going and having more reliable schedules for each title defense might be better for business.
Most double-champs have failed to remain active in both divisions. Also, I'm not sure if it's my bias or the stats would support it but it feels like guys that bounce up and down weight-classes fall off fast (Volkanovski being a recent example, Roy Jones Jr being my most memorable fall).
It's also worth noting that UFC originally had a "no double-champs" policy. I remember a long period of MMA fans wanting GSP to fight Anderson Silva because they were long-term P4P #1 and 2. But Dana White would always default to UFC policy to shoot it down. If I remember right, it took Conor McGregor's massive drawing power to overturn the policy.
Ghetto Gospel wrote:a few interesting things. seems like dana isn't really dead set on an ilia vs islam superfight at 155 right now and what diego lopes said about no more double champs going forward is kind of half true. they'd just be expected to get busy and actually defend both belts now rather than what was going on in the past where they just held the divisions up for a while.
seems like ilia wants nothing but a title shot though. not sure what leverage he has here since he just vacated..?
I get why Ilia wouldn't want a contender's fight, but I'm guessing the UFC could change that by sweetening their offer. The expectation of double-champs defending both titles makes a lot of sense, since PPV's depend on those title fights at the top. I'd prefer the UFC discourage guys from moving up and down classes too frequently because I feel like it hurts fighter health
...but then again, I just think the UFC and MMA in general needs better rules about weight cutting. It sometimes feels like being a division champ comes down to being better at weight-cutting. Frankie Edgar is that last guy I can recall that truly felt undersized in his division, though Jiri has a case since he consistently claims he could make 185.