Klomp wrote:life_saver wrote:Malone, Jenkins are probably better coaches than Finch...if the team ends up having underwhelming playoffs, then wouldn't be surprised to see the team move on from Finch
I don't necessarily agree that Malone and Jenkins are better. To be honest, after the Top 3 or so coaches, there's probably a glut of roughly 10-15 coaches that don't have much separation in their actual coaching ability. What separates guys to make it feel like a difference is situations. I don't think Mike Malone suddenly overhauled his coaching philosophy in his time between Sacramento and Denver. Nick Nurse has a title to his name too, so why did things go so poorly in Philadelphia?
That being said, the repeated same issues for the majority of the past four seasons are concerning. And that's the kind of thing that can potentially result in a coaching change. I don't think it's as dire as others think though, and I don't think a change is some magic cure-all either.
There is one thing that is worth monitoring, however. Micah Nori. I have to think he could be one of the heavy favorites to land the coaching job in Denver. Regardless, I don't want to lose him, especially not to a division rival. So if we have to make a change in order to keep him in town, I honestly think it is worth considering.
Every year Finch is given a weird, difficult roster problem. Every year, he figures out a way to make it work.
2022: Build around KAT and D'Lo, two of the worst pick & roll defenders at their position. This should have been a bottom 10 defense, instead Finch comes up with an innovative trapping scheme that unearths actual defensive strengths for Towns (switchability and speed on traps) and D'Lo (nail help and communication). The league eventually figures the scheme out and beats the traps (while also figuring out how to make Vando unplayable), but this scheme was why we made the playoffs and finished with a 13th ranked defense instead of a 25th ranked one. Finch even builds a second, more conservative scheme that helps us finish the season strong.
2023: Ok Finchy, now build around 2 centers in the starting lineup. One can shoot and one can't defend. Oh now the shooter is injured, and the defender has a big back. After an ugly start to the season, this team coalesces around a top 10 defense. On the offensive end, Finch gets the ball out of the hands of the erratic D'Lo and lets SloMo run the show. We end up getting a point guard upgrade and go into the playoffs looking strong. Unfortunately Jaden punches a wall, and Towns looks a little weak coming back from injury. We still look respectful against the eventual champs.
2024: All the ingredients in place, no new funky roster problems to solves, Finch keeps the ship steady on the way to the best season since 2004 and arguably ever. I'm still mad Finch couldn't throw more at Luka. Ironic that I'm most mad at Finch in by far our best season.
2025: After all the mental gymnastics Finch did over the years to make Towns work, they trade him. Now we ask Finch to approach last seasons' success, but now there are 2 bigs that can't shoot. We're also out of high IQ passers, because SloMo is gone and Conley is old now. Oh and Randle decides to start the season with the defensive effort level of a sloth on fentanyl. Oh and Rudy looks older and like he maybe can't play offense anymore. Ugly awful start, but once again... Finch figures this roster out. We become a whirling dirvish of drive and kicks, putting Randle and Ant in playmaking situations they're actually comfortable with. Finch finally lets Jaden out of his cage as a driver. We finish the season a top 5 defense, and a top 10 offense.
We're just being one of those fanbases that blames the coach for anything going wrong we can't understand. To me, Finch has been a consistent problem solver who has been given complicated roster puzzles and that he always eventually solves.
I don't get the Nurse example. Nurse got a healthy-ish roster in Philidelphia for a few months last season, and it was the best Embiid and the Sixers have ever looked in this era. The roster has been injury hell since then, and the roster is very much built our of complimentary players for the teams stars. I think it's really silly fan thinking to even have coaching on the list of Phili's problems. Malone has been good in Sacramento and Denver. I've always felt he was solid. If there was something going on behind the scenes there, it is what it is.