EvanZ wrote:Rainwater wrote:Watching Team US I really don’t see the hype regarding AJ. Peterson really might be the better player. AJ might share the same fate as Mayo, Barrett, Wiggins where he just doesn’t live up to the hype. Hopefully, it changes in college.
I've watched AJ a few times now including some yesterday and I just don't see what everyone else seems to see. But I'm open to changing my opinion in the next year.
I thought the same whenever I saw some highlight clips of him.
I have the same feeling when I watch him as when I had watching RJ Barrett in High School and Fiba U19 WC while everybody else was praising him. Similiar to Wiggins also. Similar type of player with similiar weeknesses.
Just something about him that throws me off. I dont like prospect who make it seem "hard". RJ Barrett scored 39 points or whatever against the US and everyone went crazy, but every single point felt like it was the hardest thing to do for him. Just forcing and bulldozing his way through players, settling for tough mid range jumpers because he couldnt beat his man. When I see that I dont think "wow what a tough jumper he made, really nice", I think "all I see is someone who can't even comfortably beat his man at the youth level, those jumpers will not always fall".
When you're looking at a prospect you dont care about the points at the end, you should care about HOW he gets those points. An elite #1 level prospect needs to make things look easy. RJ ran into 3 defenders and made a tough layup but thats not a good sign. If you have to bulldoze and force yourself through defenders, even if you get the points at the end, thats not a good sign about how strong you are, its a bad sign about how bad you are at beating your man of the dribble and having to settle yourself to taking tough shots. In games like in the Canada - US game these shots might go in and you might have a good day, but thats not indicative of your talent.
And AJ gives me the same vibe as RJ back then, I just see him struggle way too much against this level of defenders.
Like this basket at 2:20
Yeah he got the tough layup and 2 points, but thats not a good sign. If you already have to settle for such a tough floater while running into the defender, its not gonna get better at the NBA level. Unless you're elite at converting floaters and tough layups like that, youre gonna struggle.
Not saying he is bad or anything, RJ Barret isnt either. But I dont see this superstar level wing player that people hyped him up to be