lethalizer wrote:cupcakesnake wrote:Johnny Firpo wrote:Both would have deserved it, I don't have any problem with this, whatsoever. SGA is the rare all-time great who did not look like one until the age of 23-24. He looked like a very good player. He must have worked so hard, and so many hours to get there. Superstars usually look like superstars at 21-22. He is the rare exception. Jokic might actually have been similar in that, now that I think about it. 7 international MVPs in a row, that's amazing. Hopefully Luka can be in really good shape next year, and maybe Wemby joining the hunt too, this could go on for a while. We could get to 10 in a row for sure.
Shai looked like a superstar at age 21-22. It went under the radar because he was playing on a tanking OKC team that was shutting him down with dubious injuries for most of the season. For anyone watching, the skill set was there. Back in 2021, Shai was getting into the paint at will, scoring efficiently from everywhere on the floor, defending, and playmaking. I felt it was clear this was a top 5 guard hiding in plain sight, and I wasn't the only one. It's just that most people weren't watching OKC, which is pretty fair considering how aggressive the tank was.
Yeah as a fan of OKC who has the fortune(or in this case, misfortune) of watching every game even during the rock bottom tanking seasons, I was getting glimpses of greatness when the 20-21 season started. During that 2021 February run, I was really getting hyped up but I still wasn't entirely sure if he could keep it up. When the 2021-2022 season rolled around though, I thought yeah, we have a great one coming up here.
I remember pinching myself and saying, "we can't be getting another superstar this soon after losing 2 MVPs, can we? that sh*t is incredibly rare."
But yet, here we are.
I'm always more interested in player skill sets and what they can do on the court, but I get that people only want to acknowledge guys once they're doing it on a winning team. Fans prefer to look at team success and credit that success to the star players.
Back when Shai was starting to show his game, everyone was ranking Booker, Morant, Donovan Mitchell, and even Trae above him. I remember thinking: Ok but Shai is the only one of these guys who gets to the rim at at a high level and doesn't have problems shooting or defending. His skillset is a level up from these guys. I wasn't advocating for Shai for all-NBA while he was playing half seasons on a tank squad, but I was comfortable already saying he's probably the best young guard in the league. He still had to "prove it" in most people's mind (by prove it, that meant do it on a winning team), but it was clear that the skills were there. Not sure if I was thinking MVP, but I was thinking eventual best guard in the league.