dTox wrote:Not sure where to post this, maybe here?
?t=1FtKW2QSwt6CKIOGmTOK3A&s=19
Sent from my Pixel 9 Pro using RealGM mobile app
Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
Moderators: 7 Footer, Morris_Shatford, niQ, Duffman100, tsherkin, Reeko, lebron stopper, DG88, HiJiNX
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
-
mihaic
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 5,829
- And1: 3,963
- Joined: Jul 05, 2006
-
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
-
YogurtProducer
- RealGM
- Posts: 30,986
- And1: 33,692
- Joined: Jul 22, 2013
- Location: Saskatchewan
-
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
Tofubeque wrote:When you strip all the narrative away you’ve got the 2 former Raptors of this matchup both playing PF, and the rookie we kept also plays… PF. Sometimes the Xs and Os just don’t work.
OG of course could have worked as a wing here but he didn’t want to, and that I think is the main shame of the thing. He wasn’t that far from Scottie’s timeline.
Real question is heading into next season if you could pick one of Siakam/OG/Barnes which one would you actually want.
Siakam is to old, but I feel like OG might slowly become the actual answer. Paying that much for a supporting player is kind of gross, but OG's defence and fit next to Ingram/Poeltl in the front court is probably the best basketball wise. Unless Barnes takes a leap of course.
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
-
YogurtProducer
- RealGM
- Posts: 30,986
- And1: 33,692
- Joined: Jul 22, 2013
- Location: Saskatchewan
-
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
Scase wrote:TorontoBarneys wrote:Raps in 4 wrote:
We literally got nothing for Fred.
Just a master class in asset mismanagement.
I still remember the copes. "We didn't get nothing for Fred, him leaving opened up cap space, which is a good thing."
The brilliant "We didn't get nothing for him, we got Schroder" argument will forever live in infamy lmao
One of the funniest part of this board is watching one of these posters make one comment and watching the other half dozen of them showing up to whack off together on things that happened years ago now.
I think it is time to move on fellas.
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
- Duffman100
- Forum Mod - Raptors

- Posts: 48,386
- And1: 73,257
- Joined: Jun 27, 2002
-
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
Again, I'm going to have to bring out the constant negativity rule in this thread and the several others.
Contribute something to this forum other than complaining about the past or find a new place to post.
Contribute something to this forum other than complaining about the past or find a new place to post.
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
- SFour
- RealGM
- Posts: 41,471
- And1: 61,857
- Joined: Apr 07, 2012
-
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
YogurtProducer wrote:Tofubeque wrote:When you strip all the narrative away you’ve got the 2 former Raptors of this matchup both playing PF, and the rookie we kept also plays… PF. Sometimes the Xs and Os just don’t work.
OG of course could have worked as a wing here but he didn’t want to, and that I think is the main shame of the thing. He wasn’t that far from Scottie’s timeline.
Real question is heading into next season if you could pick one of Siakam/OG/Barnes which one would you actually want.
Siakam is to old, but I feel like OG might slowly become the actual answer. Paying that much for a supporting player is kind of gross, but OG's defence and fit next to Ingram/Poeltl in the front court is probably the best basketball wise. Unless Barnes takes a leap of course.
I'm still taking Barnes...he's going to be a beast when he reaches OG/Siakam's age
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
- XTC
- General Manager
- Posts: 8,699
- And1: 8,776
- Joined: Nov 09, 2005
-
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
OG, Pascal, and Fred where not the problem. Infact in 2023, a line up of Fred-OG-Barnes-Siakam-Poeltl had a net rating of +8.6 and kept up with other starting line ups just fine... it was the bench which was the issue. We legit got killed whenever our bench came in.
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
-
MiamiSPX
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 5,420
- And1: 6,791
- Joined: May 19, 2023
-
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
YogurtProducer wrote:Tofubeque wrote:When you strip all the narrative away you’ve got the 2 former Raptors of this matchup both playing PF, and the rookie we kept also plays… PF. Sometimes the Xs and Os just don’t work.
OG of course could have worked as a wing here but he didn’t want to, and that I think is the main shame of the thing. He wasn’t that far from Scottie’s timeline.
Real question is heading into next season if you could pick one of Siakam/OG/Barnes which one would you actually want.
Siakam is to old, but I feel like OG might slowly become the actual answer. Paying that much for a supporting player is kind of gross, but OG's defence and fit next to Ingram/Poeltl in the front court is probably the best basketball wise. Unless Barnes takes a leap of course.
Well if the hypothetical is picking one of them ONLY for next season, then I don't know how the answer is anyone but Siakam. He just had another All-Star season, while Barnes stagnated, and I would not bet on OG playing 74 games again with the minutes he's logging.
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
- NinjaBro
- RealGM
- Posts: 28,041
- And1: 43,792
- Joined: Aug 21, 2014
- Location: Shamblesland
-
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
If we can't complain about the past, what else are we going to talk about?Duffman100 wrote:Again, I'm going to have to bring out the constant negativity rule in this thread and the several others.
Contribute something to this forum other than complaining about the past or find a new place to post.
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
-
youngRAPZ
- Bench Warmer
- Posts: 1,290
- And1: 1,037
- Joined: Mar 17, 2011
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
YogurtProducer wrote:Scase wrote:TorontoBarneys wrote:
I still remember the copes. "We didn't get nothing for Fred, him leaving opened up cap space, which is a good thing."
The brilliant "We didn't get nothing for him, we got Schroder" argument will forever live in infamy lmao
One of the funniest part of this board is watching one of these posters make one comment and watching the other half dozen of them showing up to whack off together on things that happened years ago now.
I think it is time to move on fellas.
Circle Jerk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
-
youngRAPZ
- Bench Warmer
- Posts: 1,290
- And1: 1,037
- Joined: Mar 17, 2011
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
NinjaBro wrote:If we can't complain about the past, what else are we going to talk about?Duffman100 wrote:Again, I'm going to have to bring out the constant negativity rule in this thread and the several others.
Contribute something to this forum other than complaining about the past or find a new place to post.
lol I think this comment is actually his point. If you can’t contribute anything other than complaining about the past maybe take the summer off and come back when the games are back so you can complain about something that’s actually happening now.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
-
PushDaRock
- RealGM
- Posts: 15,970
- And1: 11,901
- Joined: Jun 22, 2011
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
dTox wrote:Not sure where to post this, maybe here?
?t=1FtKW2QSwt6CKIOGmTOK3A&s=19
Sent from my Pixel 9 Pro using RealGM mobile app
He's gotten visibly frustrated at Towns on the defensive end numerous time during the playoffs
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
-
youngRAPZ
- Bench Warmer
- Posts: 1,290
- And1: 1,037
- Joined: Mar 17, 2011
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
PushDaRock wrote:dTox wrote:Not sure where to post this, maybe here?
?t=1FtKW2QSwt6CKIOGmTOK3A&s=19
Sent from my Pixel 9 Pro using RealGM mobile app
He's gotten visibly frustrated at Towns on the defensive end numerous time during the playoffs
He’s learned well from FVV lol jk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
-
PushDaRock
- RealGM
- Posts: 15,970
- And1: 11,901
- Joined: Jun 22, 2011
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
XTC wrote:OG, Pascal, and Fred where not the problem. Infact in 2023, a line up of Fred-OG-Barnes-Siakam-Poeltl had a net rating of +8.6 and kept up with other starting line ups just fine... it was the bench which was the issue. We legit got killed whenever our bench came in.
I would agree that the bench was the biggest issue but the starters also had a major issue closing games because of how bad they were in the half court offensively. Once the game slowed down and other teams prioritized not turning it over, we were at a major disadvantaged due to a lack of shot making talent.
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
-
mademan
- RealGM
- Posts: 32,198
- And1: 31,256
- Joined: Feb 18, 2010
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
XTC wrote:OG, Pascal, and Fred where not the problem. Infact in 2023, a line up of Fred-OG-Barnes-Siakam-Poeltl had a net rating of +8.6 and kept up with other starting line ups just fine... it was the bench which was the issue. We legit got killed whenever our bench came in.
Hard to build a bench after youve paid all of your top guys. Wouldve been even more difficult after giving raises to all of them, including Barnes. FO was right to trade them but dumb not to forsee the problems. They took too long and got worse deals than they should have
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
-
ATLTimekeeper
- RealGM
- Posts: 42,747
- And1: 23,864
- Joined: Apr 28, 2008
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
Jerry Lucas wrote:ATLTimekeeper wrote:Jerry Lucas wrote:What I would want to know is, did this meeting in Miami happen before or after Brooklyn didn't go through with trading KD that summer, and started that season with him still there (the date of that being announced was August 24, 2022 IIRC).
Because everything I've heard was that the schism in the locker room becoming beyond repair was basically due to Masai deciding not to trade Scottie and salary filler for KD in the summer of 2022. The players on Siakam's side of the timeline age-wise (led by FVV not Siakam himself) wanted that trade to get made, while the players on Scottie's side of the timeline age-wise were not angling for it and obviously ended up getting their way, as Masai did not ultimately make that move.
From that moment on the (relatively) older players on the team just looked at Scottie as "could have been KD."
You think the players had influence on Masai's decision, and that's what the meeting was about?
I haven't seen any reporting on this other than Scottie was always off the table for KD.
It is interesting that they had to have a meeting to see if this would work. It was after the first round loss to Philadelphia. Scottie just won ROY and that Philly writer came out and said OG was an unhappy camper.
Masai is literally on record admitting that this has happened in at least 1 other instance, which was the Poeltl trade. He talked to the 4 other players in the starting 5 (Scottie/Pascal/FVV/OG) and they all said they needed a legit C as the 5th starter. Wasn't the only influence, but it was partially influenced by that.
But who knows when this meeting in Miami happened. Could have been before or after KD decided to start that season with Brooklyn.
That's a little different than asking them if they should trade Scottie for KD
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
- Duffman100
- Forum Mod - Raptors

- Posts: 48,386
- And1: 73,257
- Joined: Jun 27, 2002
-
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
NinjaBro wrote:If we can't complain about the past, what else are we going to talk about?Duffman100 wrote:Again, I'm going to have to bring out the constant negativity rule in this thread and the several others.
Contribute something to this forum other than complaining about the past or find a new place to post.
I have no problem if you complain about the past. What I care is if that's all you do.
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
- NinjaBro
- RealGM
- Posts: 28,041
- And1: 43,792
- Joined: Aug 21, 2014
- Location: Shamblesland
-
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
There was a time window where we could've done something with that core. Barnes was still on his rookie contract. OG, FVV, and Pascal haven't got their max yet and were still relatively on bargain contracts compared to now. Masai could've done something but he did a half measure because he was so busy with giants of Africa.mademan wrote:XTC wrote:OG, Pascal, and Fred where not the problem. Infact in 2023, a line up of Fred-OG-Barnes-Siakam-Poeltl had a net rating of +8.6 and kept up with other starting line ups just fine... it was the bench which was the issue. We legit got killed whenever our bench came in.
Hard to build a bench after youve paid all of your top guys. Wouldve been even more difficult after giving raises to all of them, including Barnes. FO was right to trade them but dumb not to forsee the problems. They took too long and got worse deals than they should have
He even admitted he wasn't so hands on the raptors when the Nick Nurse era disaster was happening in real time. Either you go all in with this core and get them some real bench help or completely blow it up after Kawhi left. There were lots of role players and even up and coming stars available on the cheap like Brunson and Hartenstein. Masai went half measure and that's was the problem.
Masai is way more hands on now and we can see the results. Direction is much better.
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
-
YogurtProducer
- RealGM
- Posts: 30,986
- And1: 33,692
- Joined: Jul 22, 2013
- Location: Saskatchewan
-
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
SFour wrote:YogurtProducer wrote:Tofubeque wrote:When you strip all the narrative away you’ve got the 2 former Raptors of this matchup both playing PF, and the rookie we kept also plays… PF. Sometimes the Xs and Os just don’t work.
OG of course could have worked as a wing here but he didn’t want to, and that I think is the main shame of the thing. He wasn’t that far from Scottie’s timeline.
Real question is heading into next season if you could pick one of Siakam/OG/Barnes which one would you actually want.
Siakam is to old, but I feel like OG might slowly become the actual answer. Paying that much for a supporting player is kind of gross, but OG's defence and fit next to Ingram/Poeltl in the front court is probably the best basketball wise. Unless Barnes takes a leap of course.
I'm still taking Barnes...he's going to be a beast when he reaches OG/Siakam's age
Yep that is the hope!
Offense still scares me, but if he becomes Draymond with some better finishing thats a good good player
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
-
ConSarnit
- Head Coach
- Posts: 6,309
- And1: 6,045
- Joined: May 05, 2015
-
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
It's not shocking that any of these guys are doing well. There are some caveats though.
Siakam: playing in perhaps the most ideal spot he could land. Gets properly slotted as a #2 option while playing o a team that runs alot with a great playmaking #1 option guard/wing & 3+D center. We didn't have either of those.
OG: same guy he always was. A great 3+D role player who fits anywhere. We couldn't afford him because we aren't the Knicks (or any other high spending team).
FVV: same guy he always was. Makes $40m+ which is untenable unless he's on a young team like HOU.
These guys were always good players but we got priced out and our roster construction wasn't great.
Siakam: playing in perhaps the most ideal spot he could land. Gets properly slotted as a #2 option while playing o a team that runs alot with a great playmaking #1 option guard/wing & 3+D center. We didn't have either of those.
OG: same guy he always was. A great 3+D role player who fits anywhere. We couldn't afford him because we aren't the Knicks (or any other high spending team).
FVV: same guy he always was. Makes $40m+ which is untenable unless he's on a young team like HOU.
These guys were always good players but we got priced out and our roster construction wasn't great.
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
- TorontoBarneys
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 5,985
- And1: 7,140
- Joined: Dec 30, 2022
-
Re: Grange: Former Raptors' success a reminder of the road not taken
YogurtProducer wrote:Tofubeque wrote:When you strip all the narrative away you’ve got the 2 former Raptors of this matchup both playing PF, and the rookie we kept also plays… PF. Sometimes the Xs and Os just don’t work.
OG of course could have worked as a wing here but he didn’t want to, and that I think is the main shame of the thing. He wasn’t that far from Scottie’s timeline.
Real question is heading into next season if you could pick one of Siakam/OG/Barnes which one would you actually want.
Siakam is to old, but I feel like OG might slowly become the actual answer. Paying that much for a supporting player is kind of gross, but OG's defence and fit next to Ingram/Poeltl in the front court is probably the best basketball wise. Unless Barnes takes a leap of course.
Barnes' defense is also very highly rated, even if it's not DPOY level like OG's is, and Barnes is still a better offensive player than OG and brings more overall to the table.
Preferring OG over him is wild. OG works in NYC because all the other pieces are already in place. Barnes is a superior foundational piece even if he's been disappointing.









