People were interested in these podcasts
Play Episode
85min
RealGM Radio
NBA Contender Tiers with Matt Moore
Wes Goldberg and Matt Moore rank every NBA team in terms of whether or not they are a contender after the first wave of free agency. #nba 0:00 Intro 7:00 Thunder 9:51 Rockets 16:34 Nuggets 18:43 Cavs and Knicks 29:27 Spurs 32:00 Timberwolves 37:48 Magic 41:22 Pistons 49:02 Bucks 52:13 Lakers & LeBron trade ideas 1:00:47 Mavericks 1:03:59 Pacers 1:09:27 Heat 1:13:43 Pelicans 1:17:07 Bulls 1:20:54 Wizards and Hornets RealGM Radio is powered in part by North Station Media (CLNS). For advertising or media inquiries, contact info@clnsmedia.com 🔔 Like, comment, and subscribe for more NBA insights and analysis! Follow RealGM Twitter: https://x.com/RealGM Follow Wes Goldberg Twitter: https://x.com/wcgoldberg PrizePicks: PrizePicks is the best place to get real money sports action. With over 10 million members and billions of dollars in awarded winnings, PrizePicks has made daily fantasy sports accessible to all. You just pick MORE or LESS on at least two players for a shot to win up to 1000x your cash! Run Your Game all season long on PrizePicks. Download the app today and use code CLNS to get $50 instantly after you play your first $5 lineup! Gametime: Take the guesswork out of buying tickets with Gametime. Download the Gametime app, create an account, and use code CLNS for $20 off your first purchase. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
RealGM Radio
Thunder Take Control of NBA Finals, Desmond Bane Trade and Kevin Durant Destinations With Dave DuFour
OKC's defensive masterclass and Jalen Williams' breakout performance have the OKLAHOMA CITY THUNDER on the brink of a championship. Wes Goldberg and Dave DuFour (The Athletic) analyze the THUNDER's path to success, dissecting their suffocating defense and the PACERS' struggles. The conversation shifts to blockbuster trade scenarios, including Desmond Bane's move to Orlando and potential Kevin Durant destinations. Charlotte's challenges with LaMelo Ball and roster construction strategies for struggling franchises round out this comprehensive NBA discussion. Timestamps 0:00 Intro 3:37 Thunder Defense 25:31 Exciting Finals for fans 34:00 Desmond Bane trade 50:14 Kevin Durant's next team 57:30 Trade Machine ideas RealGM Radio is powered in part by North Station Media (CLNS). For advertising or media inquiries, contact info@clnsmedia.com 🔔 Like, comment, and subscribe for more NBA insights and analysis! Follow RealGM Twitter: https://x.com/RealGM Follow Wes Goldberg Twitter: https://x.com/wcgoldberg PrizePicks: PrizePicks is the best place to get real money sports action. With over 10 million members and billions of dollars in awarded winnings, PrizePicks has made daily fantasy sports accessible to all. You just pick MORE or LESS on at least two players for a shot to win up to 1000x your cash! Run Your Game all season long on PrizePicks. Download the app today and use code CLNS to get $50 instantly after you play your first $5 lineup! Gametime: Take the guesswork out of buying tickets with Gametime. Download the Gametime app, create an account, and use code CLNS for $20 off your first purchase. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
RealGM Radio
Wild Pacers Comeback & Timberwolves Game 2 Adjustments (with Dane Moore)
Wes Goldberg reacts to a wild Indiana Pacers comeback in Game 1 vs the New York Knicks, Tyrese Haliburton's almost-game winner, and what went wrong for the Knicks down the stretch (0:44). Then he's joined by Dane Moore (The Dane Moore NBA Podcast) to discuss some adjustments the Minnesota Timberwolves can make ahead of Game 2 against the Oklahoma City Thunder (12:28). RealGM Radio is powered in part by North Station Media (CLNS). For advertising or media inquiries, contact info@clnsmedia.com 🔔 Like, comment, and subscribe for more NBA insights and analysis! Follow RealGM Twitter: https://x.com/RealGM Follow Wes Goldberg Twitter: https://x.com/wcgoldberg PrizePicks: PrizePicks is the best place to get real money sports action. With over 10 million members and billions of dollars in awarded winnings, PrizePicks has made daily fantasy sports accessible to all. You just pick MORE or LESS on at least two players for a shot to win up to 1000x your cash! Run Your Game all season long on PrizePicks. Download the app today and use code CLNS to get $50 instantly after you play your first $5 lineup! Gametime: Take the guesswork out of buying tickets with Gametime. Download the Gametime app, create an account, and use code CLNS for $20 off your first purchase. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
RealGM Radio
Can the NBA Copy the OKC Thunder's Blueprint? (With Esfandiar Baraheni)
Is the Oklahoma City Thunder's defense the best we've ever seen in the NBA playoffs? With standout performances from Shai Gilgeous-Alexander and Chet Holmgren, the Thunder's defensive dominance fueled their run to the NBA Finals. This episode explores their strategic dominance, the Minnesota Timberwolves' future challenges, and intriguing off-season trade possibilities. Wes Goldberg and Esfandiar Baraheni dissect the Thunder's unique defensive tactics and speculate on potential trade targets like Jaren Jackson Jr. and Trae Young. The conversation also touches on the Timberwolves' need to adapt with aging stars like Rudy Gobert. Timestamps 0:00 Intro 1:00 Thunder's defensive dominance 18:30 Best defense we've ever seen? 29:00 Timberwolves offseason questions 40:00 Under-the-radar offseason trade targets RealGM Radio is powered in part by North Station Media (CLNS). For advertising or media inquiries, contact info@clnsmedia.com 🔔 Like, comment, and subscribe for more NBA insights and analysis! Follow RealGM Twitter: https://x.com/RealGM Follow Wes Goldberg Twitter: https://x.com/wcgoldberg PrizePicks: PrizePicks is the best place to get real money sports action. With over 10 million members and billions of dollars in awarded winnings, PrizePicks has made daily fantasy sports accessible to all. You just pick MORE or LESS on at least two players for a shot to win up to 1000x your cash! Run Your Game all season long on PrizePicks. Download the app today and use code CLNS to get $50 instantly after you play your first $5 lineup! Gametime: Take the guesswork out of buying tickets with Gametime. Download the Gametime app, create an account, and use code CLNS for $20 off your first purchase. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

RGM GOAT Debate Thread (Part 2)

Moderators: cupcakesnake, bwgood77, zimpy27, infinite11285, Domejandro, ken6199, bisme37, Dirk, KingDavid

Who Is officially the goat!? Only have 10 slots Poll.

Larry Bird
6
1%
Shaquille O'Neal
2
0%
Wilt Chamberlain
17
3%
Michael Jordan
297
60%
Lebron James
118
24%
Kareem Abdul-Jabbar
17
3%
Oscar Robertson
1
0%
Hakeem Olajuwon
4
1%
Bill Russell
11
2%
Other Insert Comment
22
4%
 
Total votes: 495

ScrantonBulls
Starter
Posts: 2,255
And1: 3,183
Joined: Nov 18, 2023
     

Re: RGM GOAT Debate Thread (Part 2) 

Post#1861 » by ScrantonBulls » Thu May 22, 2025 4:29 am

bledredwine wrote:
zimpy27 wrote:For every 2.3 people that think Jordan is the GOAT, there is 1 person that think LeBron is the GOAT.

The gap is closing on consensus.



Nah. The PC forum posters headed over here to vote. They were all commenting around that time the voting changed as well.
If you poll the public, it's not close.

And when he retires, the gap widens again. That's how it always works.
I remember a Kobe vs MJ poll being way closer than it should have been.

Why? All of the Kobe fans that were on the forums because it was during Kobe's playing days.

The gap getting smaller after LBJ gets kicked out of the playoffs would make no sense, wouldn't you agree?

:lol: The mental gymnastics you perform to try and convince yourself that LeBron's legacy will fade is simply awesome. Fabricating a complete lie that Kobe was legitimately in the GOAT conversation with MJ, and then fabricating a false equivalence between Kobe and LeBron. I love it.
bledredwine wrote:There were 3 times Jordan won and was considered the underdog

1989 Eastern Conference Finals against the Detroit Pistons, the 1991 NBA Finals against the Magic Johnson-led Los Angeles Lakers, and the 1995 Eastern Conference Finals against the NY Knicks
bledredwine
RealGM
Posts: 14,520
And1: 5,700
Joined: Sep 17, 2010
   

Re: RGM GOAT Debate Thread (Part 2) 

Post#1862 » by bledredwine » Thu May 22, 2025 9:00 am

ScrantonBulls wrote:
bledredwine wrote:
zimpy27 wrote:For every 2.3 people that think Jordan is the GOAT, there is 1 person that think LeBron is the GOAT.

The gap is closing on consensus.



Nah. The PC forum posters headed over here to vote. They were all commenting around that time the voting changed as well.
If you poll the public, it's not close.

And when he retires, the gap widens again. That's how it always works.
I remember a Kobe vs MJ poll being way closer than it should have been.

Why? All of the Kobe fans that were on the forums because it was during Kobe's playing days.

The gap getting smaller after LBJ gets kicked out of the playoffs would make no sense, wouldn't you agree?

:lol: The mental gymnastics you perform to try and convince yourself that LeBron's legacy will fade is simply awesome. Fabricating a complete lie that Kobe was legitimately in the GOAT conversation with MJ, and then fabricating a false equivalence between Kobe and LeBron. I love it.


You’ll see :wink:
LeBron has a 17.8% field goal percentage and a 12.5% 3-point percentage in clutch situations, and also made 20 of 116 game winning/tying shots in 4th/OT during his career :wink:
michaelm
RealGM
Posts: 11,998
And1: 5,159
Joined: Apr 06, 2010
 

Re: RGM GOAT Debate Thread (Part 2) 

Post#1863 » by michaelm » Thu May 22, 2025 10:32 am

ScrantonBulls wrote:
bledredwine wrote:
zimpy27 wrote:For every 2.3 people that think Jordan is the GOAT, there is 1 person that think LeBron is the GOAT.

The gap is closing on consensus.



Nah. The PC forum posters headed over here to vote. They were all commenting around that time the voting changed as well.
If you poll the public, it's not close.

And when he retires, the gap widens again. That's how it always works.
I remember a Kobe vs MJ poll being way closer than it should have been.

Why? All of the Kobe fans that were on the forums because it was during Kobe's playing days.

The gap getting smaller after LBJ gets kicked out of the playoffs would make no sense, wouldn't you agree?

:lol: The mental gymnastics you perform to try and convince yourself that LeBron's legacy will fade is simply awesome. Fabricating a complete lie that Kobe was legitimately in the GOAT conversation with MJ, and then fabricating a false equivalence between Kobe and LeBron. I love it.

So only people who disagree with you engage in mental gymnastics ?.

Kobe was not on LeBron’s or Jordan’s level imo either, while still a great player who was very good at winning. However it is not untrue that at the height of his career he actually was likened to Jordan, which is different than him really being on Jordan’s or LeBron’s level, and it is also true that any such talk has faded in his retirement.

We shall see what happens with Jordan vs LeBron, but recency bias is a thing. I doubt the memory of LeBron will fade after he is retired as much as Kobe’s has, and on the other hand the Jordan partisans who followed him in his time are aging and presumably the Jordan publicity machine will eventually wind down, but imo it is true to say that how LeBron will be evaluated by posterity awaits posterity.
lessthanjake
Analyst
Posts: 3,036
And1: 2,749
Joined: Apr 13, 2013

Re: RGM GOAT Debate Thread (Part 2) 

Post#1864 » by lessthanjake » Thu May 22, 2025 3:28 pm

ScrantonBulls wrote:
bledredwine wrote:
zimpy27 wrote:For every 2.3 people that think Jordan is the GOAT, there is 1 person that think LeBron is the GOAT.

The gap is closing on consensus.



Nah. The PC forum posters headed over here to vote. They were all commenting around that time the voting changed as well.
If you poll the public, it's not close.

And when he retires, the gap widens again. That's how it always works.
I remember a Kobe vs MJ poll being way closer than it should have been.

Why? All of the Kobe fans that were on the forums because it was during Kobe's playing days.

The gap getting smaller after LBJ gets kicked out of the playoffs would make no sense, wouldn't you agree?

:lol: The mental gymnastics you perform to try and convince yourself that LeBron's legacy will fade is simply awesome. Fabricating a complete lie that Kobe was legitimately in the GOAT conversation with MJ, and then fabricating a false equivalence between Kobe and LeBron. I love it.


I think it’s genuinely very rare for a sports player to become the most common answer from people regarding the GOAT of the player’s sport without having already been widely considered the GOAT at the tail end of their career. Off the top of my head, I can’t think of any example of it happening. Guys like Jordan, Gretzky, Pele, Ruth, Brady, etc. were all widely considered the GOAT while they were playing. Messi is currently widely considered the GOAT while he is still playing, and that seems likely to stick afterwards. And the annals of sports are also filled with lots of players who got at least some “GOAT” talk at the tail end of their careers but stopped being talked about that way afterwards. Public perception of a player’s greatness in the waning stages of a player’s career is generally the high water mark. If LeBron does not end his career as the consensus GOAT, I think it’s pretty unlikely that he will ever be considered the consensus GOAT. That said, he actually is still playing, so there’s still some time for him to do it—for instance, if he won another title, I think there’s a decent chance that’d significantly shift the balance. The other thing I’ll note about this is that LeBron not being considered the consensus GOAT doesn’t mean Jordan will keep holding the title perpetually—Jordan will just remain the default answer until someone eventually comes along and supplants him, likely aided in part by Jordan becoming ancient history. Whoever supplants Jordan will just very likely be considered to have supplanted him while that guy is still playing.
OhayoKD wrote:Lebron contributes more to all the phases of play than Messi does. And he is of course a defensive anchor unlike messi.
michaelm
RealGM
Posts: 11,998
And1: 5,159
Joined: Apr 06, 2010
 

Re: RGM GOAT Debate Thread (Part 2) 

Post#1865 » by michaelm » Fri May 23, 2025 2:47 pm

lessthanjake wrote:
ScrantonBulls wrote:
bledredwine wrote:

Nah. The PC forum posters headed over here to vote. They were all commenting around that time the voting changed as well.
If you poll the public, it's not close.

And when he retires, the gap widens again. That's how it always works.
I remember a Kobe vs MJ poll being way closer than it should have been.

Why? All of the Kobe fans that were on the forums because it was during Kobe's playing days.

The gap getting smaller after LBJ gets kicked out of the playoffs would make no sense, wouldn't you agree?

:lol: The mental gymnastics you perform to try and convince yourself that LeBron's legacy will fade is simply awesome. Fabricating a complete lie that Kobe was legitimately in the GOAT conversation with MJ, and then fabricating a false equivalence between Kobe and LeBron. I love it.


I think it’s genuinely very rare for a sports player to become the most common answer from people regarding the GOAT of the player’s sport without having already been widely considered the GOAT at the tail end of their career. Off the top of my head, I can’t think of any example of it happening. Guys like Jordan, Gretzky, Pele, Ruth, Brady, etc. were all widely considered the GOAT while they were playing. Messi is currently widely considered the GOAT while he is still playing, and that seems likely to stick afterwards. And the annals of sports are also filled with lots of players who got at least some “GOAT” talk at the tail end of their careers but stopped being talked about that way afterwards. Public perception of a player’s greatness in the waning stages of a player’s career is generally the high water mark. If LeBron does not end his career as the consensus GOAT, I think it’s pretty unlikely that he will ever be considered the consensus GOAT. That said, he actually is still playing, so there’s still some time for him to do it—for instance, if he won another title, I think there’s a decent chance that’d significantly shift the balance. The other thing I’ll note about this is that LeBron not being considered the consensus GOAT doesn’t mean Jordan will keep holding the title perpetually—Jordan will just remain the default answer until someone eventually comes along and supplants him, likely aided in part by Jordan becoming ancient history. Whoever supplants Jordan will just very likely be considered to have supplanted him while that guy is still playing.

I suspect with the passage of time Jordan will become like Bill Russell, regarded as amazing in his day but with his day receding into the distant past.

I can’t see that LeBron will be the one to supplant him though, he hasn’t done anything to really set him apart like 2 threepeats, taking the sport to the world, making the NIke brand, etc. As you say if he was going to supplant Jordan he would probably have done so by now, and statistics particularly longevity statistics won’t do it imo as they didn’t really for Kareem whether or not they should have done.
bledredwine
RealGM
Posts: 14,520
And1: 5,700
Joined: Sep 17, 2010
   

Re: RGM GOAT Debate Thread (Part 2) 

Post#1866 » by bledredwine » Fri May 23, 2025 9:20 pm

michaelm wrote:
lessthanjake wrote:
ScrantonBulls wrote::lol: The mental gymnastics you perform to try and convince yourself that LeBron's legacy will fade is simply awesome. Fabricating a complete lie that Kobe was legitimately in the GOAT conversation with MJ, and then fabricating a false equivalence between Kobe and LeBron. I love it.


I think it’s genuinely very rare for a sports player to become the most common answer from people regarding the GOAT of the player’s sport without having already been widely considered the GOAT at the tail end of their career. Off the top of my head, I can’t think of any example of it happening. Guys like Jordan, Gretzky, Pele, Ruth, Brady, etc. were all widely considered the GOAT while they were playing. Messi is currently widely considered the GOAT while he is still playing, and that seems likely to stick afterwards. And the annals of sports are also filled with lots of players who got at least some “GOAT” talk at the tail end of their careers but stopped being talked about that way afterwards. Public perception of a player’s greatness in the waning stages of a player’s career is generally the high water mark. If LeBron does not end his career as the consensus GOAT, I think it’s pretty unlikely that he will ever be considered the consensus GOAT. That said, he actually is still playing, so there’s still some time for him to do it—for instance, if he won another title, I think there’s a decent chance that’d significantly shift the balance. The other thing I’ll note about this is that LeBron not being considered the consensus GOAT doesn’t mean Jordan will keep holding the title perpetually—Jordan will just remain the default answer until someone eventually comes along and supplants him, likely aided in part by Jordan becoming ancient history. Whoever supplants Jordan will just very likely be considered to have supplanted him while that guy is still playing.

I suspect with the passage of time Jordan will become like Bill Russell, regarded as amazing in his day but with his day receding into the distant past.

I can’t see that LeBron will be the one to supplant him though, he hasn’t done anything to really set him apart like 2 threepeats, taking the sport to the world, making the NIke brand, etc. As you say if he was going to supplant Jordan he would probably have done so by now, and statistics particularly longevity statistics won’t do it imo as they didn’t really for Kareem whether or not they should have done.


I don't think so for a couple of reasons;

1. Russell's career began just a decade after the inception of the NBA.

The game had not developed, you didn't have many bigs, and you certainly didn't have a player that "had it all" other than maybe Wilt.
Jordan was more of a Maradona, where he was an outlier that played when the NBA had developed after plenty of decades.

2. We have video

You can look on YouTube. So for anyone trying to compare someone, you just pull of video and say "enjoy the eye test"
Thanks to that, people can't take the Lebron comparisons and era conversation too seriously, because you see what a freak
Jordan was, that he was more skilled than the players today and that the things he was able to do would not come easy for anyone.

3. Russell had some big flaws

Russell very well may have been an outlier and effective on both ends, but stats say otherwise since his teammates usually carried the scoring and he has had multiple finals series with terrible field goal percentage and low volume. He had to have been an absolute freak monster of a defender to make up for that in the GOAT debate, and that's why most people don't rate him GOAT (lack on the offensive end). If Russell was a dominant offensive
player, he'd be number 2 or even 1, no question. But his scoring... sucked, comparatively. And that's important. Jordan has 10 scoring titles and was clearly the best scorer we've seen. He also was a hell of an assister, rebounder, steals, blocks all for his position and one of the best defenders in the league. You just don't see that.

Jordan is the Pele of basketball if Pele came later (Hence, why I say Maradona)

He's Mike Tyson's peak dominance compared with Ali's career and that's fricking nuts. He's Gretzky or Babe.
I haven't seen anyone that close to 87-93 Jordan... yet. That Jordan would dominate series after series, putting up historical finals series.
96-98 Jordan? Sure, I've seen players that are closer

That's why I was excited for Wemby but that hasn't shaped up yet either.
LeBron has a 17.8% field goal percentage and a 12.5% 3-point percentage in clutch situations, and also made 20 of 116 game winning/tying shots in 4th/OT during his career :wink:
michaelm
RealGM
Posts: 11,998
And1: 5,159
Joined: Apr 06, 2010
 

Re: RGM GOAT Debate Thread (Part 2) 

Post#1867 » by michaelm » Sat May 24, 2025 2:56 am

bledredwine wrote:
michaelm wrote:
lessthanjake wrote:
I think it’s genuinely very rare for a sports player to become the most common answer from people regarding the GOAT of the player’s sport without having already been widely considered the GOAT at the tail end of their career. Off the top of my head, I can’t think of any example of it happening. Guys like Jordan, Gretzky, Pele, Ruth, Brady, etc. were all widely considered the GOAT while they were playing. Messi is currently widely considered the GOAT while he is still playing, and that seems likely to stick afterwards. And the annals of sports are also filled with lots of players who got at least some “GOAT” talk at the tail end of their careers but stopped being talked about that way afterwards. Public perception of a player’s greatness in the waning stages of a player’s career is generally the high water mark. If LeBron does not end his career as the consensus GOAT, I think it’s pretty unlikely that he will ever be considered the consensus GOAT. That said, he actually is still playing, so there’s still some time for him to do it—for instance, if he won another title, I think there’s a decent chance that’d significantly shift the balance. The other thing I’ll note about this is that LeBron not being considered the consensus GOAT doesn’t mean Jordan will keep holding the title perpetually—Jordan will just remain the default answer until someone eventually comes along and supplants him, likely aided in part by Jordan becoming ancient history. Whoever supplants Jordan will just very likely be considered to have supplanted him while that guy is still playing.

I suspect with the passage of time Jordan will become like Bill Russell, regarded as amazing in his day but with his day receding into the distant past.

I can’t see that LeBron will be the one to supplant him though, he hasn’t done anything to really set him apart like 2 threepeats, taking the sport to the world, making the NIke brand, etc. As you say if he was going to supplant Jordan he would probably have done so by now, and statistics particularly longevity statistics won’t do it imo as they didn’t really for Kareem whether or not they should have done.


I don't think so for a couple of reasons;

1. Russell's career began just a decade after the inception of the NBA.

The game had not developed, you didn't have many bigs, and you certainly didn't have a player that "had it all" other than maybe Wilt.
Jordan was more of a Maradona, where he was an outlier that played when the NBA had developed after plenty of decades.

2. We have video

You can look on YouTube. So for anyone trying to compare someone, you just pull of video and say "enjoy the eye test"
Thanks to that, people can't take the Lebron comparisons and era conversation too seriously, because you see what a freak
Jordan was, that he was more skilled than the players today and that the things he was able to do would not come easy for anyone.

3. Russell had some big flaws

Russell very well may have been an outlier and effective on both ends, but stats say otherwise since his teammates usually carried the scoring and he has had multiple finals series with terrible field goal percentage and low volume. He had to have been an absolute freak monster of a defender to make up for that in the GOAT debate, and that's why most people don't rate him GOAT (lack on the offensive end). If Russell was a dominant offensive
player, he'd be number 2 or even 1, no question. But his scoring... sucked, comparatively. And that's important. Jordan has 10 scoring titles and was clearly the best scorer we've seen. He also was a hell of an assister, rebounder, steals, blocks all for his position and one of the best defenders in the league. You just don't see that.

Jordan is the Pele of basketball if Pele came later (Hence, why I say Maradona)

He's Mike Tyson's peak dominance compared with Ali's career and that's fricking nuts. He's Gretzky or Babe.
I haven't seen anyone that close to 87-93 Jordan... 1 :evil: yet. That Jordan would dominate series after series, putting up historical finals series.
96-98 Jordan? Sure, I've seen players that are closer

That's why I was excited for Wemby but that hasn't shaped up yet either.

I agree with most of this, and for me personally I doubt anyone will exceed him in my lifetime, but I watched him in his time. 50 years after his career I could see a narrative arising that he was obviously great but dominated lesser days, LeBron fans are running that line of argument already as well as outright detraction from Jordan.

The Air Jordan tag continues to be iconic, they still sell boatloads of the shoes I believe, and there isn’t really an equivalent tag for LeBron, forearm jolt LeBron not having quite the same resonance.

We shall see with Wemby, but he hasn’t really looked on the level of a young Jordan or young LeBron thus far.
User avatar
GrindCityHustle
Veteran
Posts: 2,606
And1: 2,574
Joined: May 05, 2019
 

Has the Michael Jordan hype faded? 

Post#1868 » by GrindCityHustle » Sat May 24, 2025 3:56 pm

As an old head I know my generation will burn down Paris before they take off Jordan from the top of the list. I prefer to look at in more objectively with age.

That said I feel maybe the new generation is less enamored with number 23 than even 5 years ago. He is looked at as a dude that is the prototype for the perfect player even though he wasn't

My personal opinion is that LeBron played at a higher level longer. I feel Jordan had the best prime of any player ever and did it twice on top of that.

Do you feel the newer generation feels the same way about Jordan or is the way the game is looked at now is different.
Image

nbagenerations.createaforum.com
sp6r=underrated
RealGM
Posts: 20,832
And1: 13,597
Joined: Jan 20, 2007
 

Re: Has the Michael Jordan hype faded? 

Post#1869 » by sp6r=underrated » Sat May 24, 2025 4:06 pm

FWIW, I think Lebron is clearly # 1 by objective criteria.

That said even if MJ had a better case, he would be fading. First, a majority of NBA fans probably don't remember MJ. MJ never had an overwhelming objective case for the GOAT. Kareem had a very credible argument as did Russell. But MJ passed those guys easily on a majority of lists for a subjective reason, people loved watching MJ play. That wasn't true for Kareem or Russell. Now a majority of fans don't remember watching MJ so he doesn't get the style points. And that makes it easier for them to notice real flaws dismissed by the MJ generation, which I am one by age, he just didn't have many elite seasons compared to Kareem and especially Lebron.

Second, the style of play in MJ's era is extremely different from today, which wasn't true in 2013 but it is now. A lot of young fans watch MJ games, sneer at the players and dismiss MJ's accomplished due to opposition quality, "played against plumbers." MJ fans did this to the older players before him. And 2040 fans will do this to Lebron.

So yea, MJ is fading a bit. First, for a good reason. He's lost the halo that 80s/90 kids gave him. Second, the inevitable passage of time weakens all athletes reps which are basically sand castles.
Showtime 80
Junior
Posts: 425
And1: 757
Joined: Nov 09, 2019

Re: Has the Michael Jordan hype faded? 

Post#1870 » by Showtime 80 » Sat May 24, 2025 4:23 pm

GrindCityHustle wrote:As an old head I know my generation will burn down Paris before they take off Jordan from the top of the list. I prefer to look at in more objectively with age.

That said I feel maybe the new generation is less enamored with number 23 than even 5 years ago. He is looked at as a dude that is the prototype for the perfect player even though he wasn't

My personal opinion is that LeBron played at a higher level longer. I feel Jordan had the best prime of any player ever and did it twice on top of that.

Do you feel the newer generation feels the same way about Jordan or is the way the game is looked at now is different.


Not a chance and here’s a nice breakdown on why:

;pp=ygUZY29saW4gY293aGVyZCBqb3JkYW4gbmlsZQ%3D%3D

This line sums it up, “LeBron tries to be cool, MJ is cool”.

Michael ascended to that rare Babe Ruth, Pele, Ali, Gretzky, Senna realm when you become not just a sport icon but also a cultural icon. LeBron for how great he is did not reach that level. Even the modern misguided Hip Hop urban “culture” which worships ghetto behaviors and has grown men dressing and acting like brain dead teenagers is still mesmerized by Jordan and his brand which is as un-hip hop as they come, he just made it too cool.

Mike made the baggy shorts, wrist band on the forearm, bald look, the number 23, basketball sneakers among other things into trend setting statements. What trend has LeBron started? Team hopping?

You also have thousands upon thousands of hours of MJ footage which a lot of has been re-mastered to HD and it looks like he just played a game last week unlike the greats from prior eras. This along with the fact that the man is still the most exciting athlete who ever put on a uniform and there will be no shortage of new fans coming for the foreseeable future.
Showtime 80
Junior
Posts: 425
And1: 757
Joined: Nov 09, 2019

Re: Has the Michael Jordan hype faded? 

Post#1871 » by Showtime 80 » Sat May 24, 2025 4:31 pm

sp6r=underrated wrote:FWIW, I think Lebron is clearly # 1 by objective criteria.

That said even if MJ had a better case, he would be fading. First, a majority of NBA fans probably don't remember MJ. MJ never had an overwhelming objective case for the GOAT. Kareem had a very credible argument as did Russell. But MJ passed those guys easily on a majority of lists for a subjective reason, people loved watching MJ play. That wasn't true for Kareem or Russell. Now a majority of fans don't remember watching MJ so he doesn't get the style points. And that makes it easier for them to notice real flaws dismissed by the MJ generation, which I am one by age, he just didn't have many elite seasons compared to Kareem and especially Lebron.

Second, the style of play in MJ's era is extremely different from today, which wasn't true in 2013 but it is now. A lot of young fans watch MJ games, sneer at the players and dismiss MJ's accomplished due to opposition quality, "played against plumbers." MJ fans did this to the older players before him. And 2040 fans will do this to Lebron.

So yea, MJ is fading a bit. First, for a good reason. He's lost the halo that 80s/90 kids gave him. Second, the inevitable passage of time weakens all athletes reps which are basically sand castles.


In 1998 an old MJ dominated a league that had this list of players:

Shaq
Kobe
Duncan
Iverson
Allen
Kidd
Garnett
Nash
Webber
Billups
Wallace
Hamilton

Guess what those guys did after he retired? They went on to absolutely dominate the NBA up until 2014 overlapping with guys like LeBron, Curry, Durant and Harden.

People who are not blind know that prime Jordan would’ve dominated the 50’s, 60’s, 70’s, 2000’s,, 10’s, 20’s or 40’s like you said. That’s what being the greatest is all about.
Jta444
Senior
Posts: 516
And1: 591
Joined: Feb 19, 2021
         

Re: RGM GOAT Debate Thread (Part 2) 

Post#1872 » by Jta444 » Sat May 24, 2025 4:34 pm

Mike is SGA on steroids.

A stronger, slightly heavier SGA with even more quickness and hops, with an even more automatic midrange. Also better defense, bigger hands, and an even better attacking mentality although SGA is no slouch in that department.

I think Mike is what you’d get if you merge SGA and Ant together, without the 3 point shooting of both though.

Goes to show you how Mike if he played today would easily be the best player, above Jokic for sure. He would dominate.
Swindle
Bench Warmer
Posts: 1,259
And1: 1,036
Joined: Jan 26, 2010
Location: Daytona Beach
 

Re: RGM GOAT Debate Thread (Part 2) 

Post#1873 » by Swindle » Sat May 24, 2025 5:46 pm

I’ve been reading that it’s reported MJ hates the GOAT debate and thinks more current players deserve more respect. He’s gonna be a special contributor during NBC’s NBA coverage so don’t be surprised if you see him hyping today’s players in an effort to move the game forward.
MavsDirk41
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,445
And1: 4,259
Joined: Dec 07, 2022
     

Re: Has the Michael Jordan hype faded? 

Post#1874 » by MavsDirk41 » Sat May 24, 2025 5:49 pm

sp6r=underrated wrote:FWIW, I think Lebron is clearly # 1 by objective criteria.

That said even if MJ had a better case, he would be fading. First, a majority of NBA fans probably don't remember MJ. MJ never had an overwhelming objective case for the GOAT. Kareem had a very credible argument as did Russell. But MJ passed those guys easily on a majority of lists for a subjective reason, people loved watching MJ play. That wasn't true for Kareem or Russell. Now a majority of fans don't remember watching MJ so he doesn't get the style points. And that makes it easier for them to notice real flaws dismissed by the MJ generation, which I am one by age, he just didn't have many elite seasons compared to Kareem and especially Lebron.

Second, the style of play in MJ's era is extremely different from today, which wasn't true in 2013 but it is now. A lot of young fans watch MJ games, sneer at the players and dismiss MJ's accomplished due to opposition quality, "played against plumbers." MJ fans did this to the older players before him. And 2040 fans will do this to Lebron.

So yea, MJ is fading a bit. First, for a good reason. He's lost the halo that 80s/90 kids gave him. Second, the inevitable passage of time weakens all athletes reps which are basically sand castles.


The only thing James has over Jordan is the longevity/accumulating stats argument. I dont see any other possible argument. And James will never escape his finals failure in 2011 and his picking his teammates moreso than any other generational talent that i can think of. I have Kareem #2 all tine. Too young to have watched his career but he is the greatest college player ever and has the championships and accolades to be in the goat discussion. There is no consensus goat but Jordan is the closest thing we have to one. 20 years from now who knows, could be Wemby.
MavsDirk41
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,445
And1: 4,259
Joined: Dec 07, 2022
     

Re: RGM GOAT Debate Thread (Part 2) 

Post#1875 » by MavsDirk41 » Sat May 24, 2025 5:54 pm

Swindle wrote:I’ve been reading that it’s reported MJ hates the GOAT debate and thinks more current players deserve more respect. He’s gonna be a special contributor during NBC’s NBA coverage so don’t be surprised if you see him hyping today’s players in an effort to move the game forward.


Interested in what he says about Wemby. Wemby could be the next face of the nba.
bledredwine
RealGM
Posts: 14,520
And1: 5,700
Joined: Sep 17, 2010
   

Re: RGM GOAT Debate Thread (Part 2) 

Post#1876 » by bledredwine » Sat May 24, 2025 6:03 pm

Swindle wrote:I’ve been reading that it’s reported MJ hates the GOAT debate and thinks more current players deserve more respect. He’s gonna be a special contributor during NBC’s NBA coverage so don’t be surprised if you see him hyping today’s players in an effort to move the game forward.



I already knew he didn't like the GOAT conversation as he thought it was disrespectful to past players during his playing days.

But what sources did you hear/read this from?
LeBron has a 17.8% field goal percentage and a 12.5% 3-point percentage in clutch situations, and also made 20 of 116 game winning/tying shots in 4th/OT during his career :wink:
The4thHorseman
General Manager
Posts: 8,666
And1: 5,343
Joined: Jun 18, 2011

Re: Has the Michael Jordan hype faded? 

Post#1877 » by The4thHorseman » Sat May 24, 2025 6:40 pm

MavsDirk41 wrote:
sp6r=underrated wrote:FWIW, I think Lebron is clearly # 1 by objective criteria.

That said even if MJ had a better case, he would be fading. First, a majority of NBA fans probably don't remember MJ. MJ never had an overwhelming objective case for the GOAT. Kareem had a very credible argument as did Russell. But MJ passed those guys easily on a majority of lists for a subjective reason, people loved watching MJ play. That wasn't true for Kareem or Russell. Now a majority of fans don't remember watching MJ so he doesn't get the style points. And that makes it easier for them to notice real flaws dismissed by the MJ generation, which I am one by age, he just didn't have many elite seasons compared to Kareem and especially Lebron.

Second, the style of play in MJ's era is extremely different from today, which wasn't true in 2013 but it is now. A lot of young fans watch MJ games, sneer at the players and dismiss MJ's accomplished due to opposition quality, "played against plumbers." MJ fans did this to the older players before him. And 2040 fans will do this to Lebron.

So yea, MJ is fading a bit. First, for a good reason. He's lost the halo that 80s/90 kids gave him. Second, the inevitable passage of time weakens all athletes reps which are basically sand castles.


The only thing James has over Jordan is the longevity/accumulating stats argument. I dont see any other possible argument. And James will never escape his finals failure in 2011 and his picking his teammates moreso than any other generational talent that i can think of. I have Kareem #2 all tine. Too young to have watched his career but he is the greatest college player ever and has the championships and accolades to be in the goat discussion. There is no consensus goat but Jordan is the closest thing we have to one. 20 years from now who knows, could be Wemby.

Picking his teammates :lol:
Braggins
RealGM
Posts: 14,397
And1: 9,204
Joined: Jan 05, 2014

Re: RGM GOAT Debate Thread (Part 2) 

Post#1878 » by Braggins » Sat May 24, 2025 6:45 pm

This website is oversaturated with genX and older millennial posters, so the MJ consensus on here will outlive the MJ consensus irl, but its inevitable that Lebron will be considered the GOAT at some point after he retires. I think its very obvious he already should be considered the GOAT and its silly its still even a debate.
MavsDirk41
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,445
And1: 4,259
Joined: Dec 07, 2022
     

Re: Has the Michael Jordan hype faded? 

Post#1879 » by MavsDirk41 » Sat May 24, 2025 6:49 pm

The4thHorseman wrote:
MavsDirk41 wrote:
sp6r=underrated wrote:FWIW, I think Lebron is clearly # 1 by objective criteria.

That said even if MJ had a better case, he would be fading. First, a majority of NBA fans probably don't remember MJ. MJ never had an overwhelming objective case for the GOAT. Kareem had a very credible argument as did Russell. But MJ passed those guys easily on a majority of lists for a subjective reason, people loved watching MJ play. That wasn't true for Kareem or Russell. Now a majority of fans don't remember watching MJ so he doesn't get the style points. And that makes it easier for them to notice real flaws dismissed by the MJ generation, which I am one by age, he just didn't have many elite seasons compared to Kareem and especially Lebron.

Second, the style of play in MJ's era is extremely different from today, which wasn't true in 2013 but it is now. A lot of young fans watch MJ games, sneer at the players and dismiss MJ's accomplished due to opposition quality, "played against plumbers." MJ fans did this to the older players before him. And 2040 fans will do this to Lebron.

So yea, MJ is fading a bit. First, for a good reason. He's lost the halo that 80s/90 kids gave him. Second, the inevitable passage of time weakens all athletes reps which are basically sand castles.


The only thing James has over Jordan is the longevity/accumulating stats argument. I dont see any other possible argument. And James will never escape his finals failure in 2011 and his picking his teammates moreso than any other generational talent that i can think of. I have Kareem #2 all tine. Too young to have watched his career but he is the greatest college player ever and has the championships and accolades to be in the goat discussion. There is no consensus goat but Jordan is the closest thing we have to one. 20 years from now who knows, could be Wemby.

Picking his teammates :lol:



You want to argue that lol? Lets go….
MavsDirk41
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,445
And1: 4,259
Joined: Dec 07, 2022
     

Re: RGM GOAT Debate Thread (Part 2) 

Post#1880 » by MavsDirk41 » Sat May 24, 2025 6:52 pm

Braggins wrote:This website is oversaturated with genX and older millennial posters, so the MJ consensus with on here with outlive the MJ consensus irl, but its inevitable that Lebron will be considered the GOAT at some point after he retires. I think its very obvious he already should be considered the GOAT and its silly its still even a debate.



If it was obvious more people would think he is… so its not obvious

Return to The General Board