League Circles wrote:Tetlak wrote:League Circles wrote:Yeah Vuc could be addition by subtraction, but depends on how Billy might use him.
Given our lack of 3 point shooting, I'd actually prefer to keep Carter over Phillips. Depends on who we draft though. If we draft a C at 12 and can't trade anyone for whatever reason, and Billy doesn't think he'll give Smith a long look backing up Matas at the 4, then I'd definitely be OK buying out Vuc.
This is absolutely wild to me. We're in a rebuild and you'd rather keep a 5th string career journeyman PG than a developmental wing who is athletic and has a ceiling as a 2 way player?
From my perspective, Carter is currently our 3rd string "1" behind Coby and Ayo. I think for insurance purposes you can't count guys as playing multiple positions in this context (even though obviously a guy like Ball can play the 1).
I'm not high in Phillips, partly because of how high I am on Matas. I don't call them wings, I call them "4s".
If Carter is the 5th string "1", then Phillips is at very best the 5th string "4" behind Matas, Smith, Giddey and Patrick.
Also factoring into this preference is that I think there is a higher chance of drafting frontcourt guy who does a lot of what Phillips does, but better, than there is that the Bulls draft a shooter type, so I actually see Carter as more likely to help us win this year, and I don't want either on our team beyond next season.
Is Carter a “1” in any real sense other than being short for an NBA player? He doesn’t create or pass well, and his POA defense was never as advertised.
I also don’t get downplaying multi-positional players for depth purposes, or, for that matter, calling Giddey and Matas both 4s when they are starting next to each other - if using a strict 1-5 listing, one has to be a 3.
I think it helps thinking of 4 position groups - guards (1-2), wings (2-3), forwards (3-4) and bigs (4-5). Ball is arguable re G v W.
Guards: Coby, Ayo, (Ball), Carter
Wings: Ball, Huerter, Terry
Forwards: Giddey, Matas, Pat, Phillips
Bigs: Vuc, Collins, Smith
It’s true that we have more depth a forward than any other spot - but Bulls also generally play with 2 forwards - one at the 3 and one at the 4 - and only 1 guard and 1 wing (though sometimes will go two forwards with 2 guards or even two wings). Anyway, given minutes at the 3 and 4 generally go to forwards- need twice the number of forwards as compared to either guards or wings. Also, if hope to ship off Pat…
Anyway, Carter is kind of useless and should never play. Phillips is useful as a Pat Williams injury and/or suckage hedge (not to mention risk of injury to Matas, etc.). Phillips is also still 21 years old, and has development potential (albeit it being slow); he is less than a year older than Matas. Carter, who is about to turn 30…. not so much.