76ciology wrote:Sixersftw wrote:I think it comes down to if you trust VJ's handle and rim finishing to improve vs Ace's decision making. I'm at the point where I don't trust either player to get there but I'm completely wrapped around the axle from watching prospects. Glad I ain't making the choice.
Tre was my initial pick but, man, the defense is bad bad.
In your comparison between VJ’s handle and finishing versus Ace’s decision-making, I’m taking VJ.
VJ already has a solid foundation in his handle and finishing. On the other hand, Ace’s decision making is downright poor right now. It’s like VJ is starting halfway down the track, while Ace is still at the starting line.
Ace’s shot creation mostly comes from the midrange, and even then, it’s usually just a couple of simple dribbles before pulling up over defenders. VJ, meanwhile, shows much more variety, he has solid volume in pick-and-roll actions, unassisted threes, and midrange attempts. As a shot creator, VJ is clearly ahead, both has almost the same number in volume of unassisted shots in halfcourt, VJ is just more diverse in shot diet and has diverse set of shot creation talent.
In terms of halfcourt rim frequency, VJ is getting to the rim on 30% of his possessions, while Ace is only at about 16%, and he’s finishing poorly when he gets there.
I’m higher on Ace than I used to be, I think he can become a solid 3&D player. But VJ has the tools to be more than that. He processes the game better, can handle the ball, shoot, pass, and score from the midrange. His profile reminds me of Derrick White. Both are around the same size (6’4” without shoes, 8’5.5” standing reach).
I also find it a red-flag on Ace’s performance in his last 10 games. A Ben Simmons’ personality?
And lastly, between the two, Edgecombe’s numbers is clearly nearer to past top 3 picks.
Two totally different positions that Ace and VJ play....
