sco wrote:I think that's right. I think he's a very high BBIQ guy and his improvements will come from creating space through recognition of opportunities and craftiness, which he has. I think he's stronger than he's given credit for and has an elite sense of where the ball is going for rebounds. The wildcard is whether he can continue to be an above average 3pt shooter.
I think that is all correct, except I'll add, he's a WAY below average shooter. People look at percentage, but they do not look at the impact of his shooting. He passes up even wide open shots regularly. People do not guard him at the three point line frequently. His release speed is incredibly slow. He cannot shoot step backs, side steps, off the dribble effectively. Shooting is much more than percentage. His higher percentage is still only a moderately efficient shot.
What creates pressure on the defense is being able to do all these other things as a weapon that create gravity / options, he doesn't do any of that today.
I don't say this all as some huge knock on Giddey as much as I say it that his shooting is much further away than his percentage would indicate this year in terms of how it impacts the game.
If Giddey were to become as good a shooter as Coby White (whom had a lower percentage last year), he might be a max player. Coby does all of the above things I mentioned, shoots quickly, off the dribble, on step backs, and uses his shooting as a weapon. He's not an elite shooter, because he can't do those things at super high percentages, but he's a very good shooter.