ImageImageImage

The Official 2025 Offseason Thread #4 Free Agency Opens!

Moderators: bwgood77, Qwigglez, lilfishi22

How many wins do you expect the Suns to have this season?

61+
4
5%
56-60
0
No votes
51-55
0
No votes
46-50
4
5%
41-45
16
21%
36-40
14
18%
31-35
21
27%
26-30
14
18%
25 or under
5
6%
 
Total votes: 78

ImNotMcDiSwear
General Manager
Posts: 8,283
And1: 6,408
Joined: Dec 14, 2013
 

Re: The Official 2025 Offseason Thread #4 Free Agency Opens! 

Post#2141 » by ImNotMcDiSwear » Thu Jul 31, 2025 3:28 pm

garrick wrote:
Sunsdeuce wrote:
lilfishi22 wrote:I learned a lesson just this past season with Dunn. I thought the guy was gonna get like 10-15mpg max because his lack of offense is going to make him a weak link. But credit to him for working hard and working on his shot and while he still wasn't a good shooter by any definition of the word, it was enough to keep him in games long enough to be a menace defensively.

What we got in the guys we've drafted this year and the last are talented and hard working prospects with seemingly the right attitude and at least one projectable elite NBA skill/measurable. If we're talking about a guy who is more polished, could probably play right away, that's probably someone like Queen. But the guy has engagement and motor issues and as importantly, he's not very good defensively. And we've seen dudes with a bad motor and poor defense fade out as well despite being polished and ready to play on the offensive end. There's trade offs no matter who you go with. And I think taking the consensus BPA in the 2nd half of the lottery is a reasonably sound approach.

Let me preference by saying, I like Dunn. I think he’s going to be in the league a long time. But if he doesn’t develop an offensive game, I’m not sure what he’s role will be long term in this league. He was on a rollercoaster all year. Sometimes he was unplayable and other times he looked like a bonafide starter. To be quite frank, I’m still not sure who or what Dunn is yet. What I liked: his defense ethic. What I didn’t like, his standing around on offense, waiting to shoot threes in the corner. He’s bread and butter on offense should be endless movement. Cutting, driving, dunking. Last year, his bread and butter was corner threes (which were not exactly a sure thing). With his shooting limitations he should be poor mans Shawn Marion. He should live and breathe by cuts, put backs and offensive rebounding. Threes should be secondary.


He's a taller Josh Okogie.

Looks amazing when they're hitting their threes but if they aren't they're a huge liability on offense and sometimes unplayable. For Dunn I think his poor free throw shooting really limits him in cuts to the basket because when you can't even hit over 50 percent of your free throws teams you probably aren't going to want to get fouled for fear of missing so many free throws.


I thought Dunn showed some offensive upside at the tail end of last season and in summer league. I don't think he'll just be standing in the corner unless the offense redounds to iso-ball like it did last season - which is possible given that we have no point guard.

If Okogie was 6'8" he'd be a rotation player in this league. I think Dunn has a chance to be much better.

Returning to the question of JK - given their contracts, Dunn is clearly the better asset. Just looking at the players, Dunn has no injury history - last year's DNPs were all DNP-CD. Better blocks and steals rates. Higher TRB%.

OTOH, Kuminga has already shown he can generate his own offense and showed flashes of being a 20/6/5 guy his sophomore and junior seasons. I ragged on his 3FG% and FT% before noticing Dunn's 3FG% was also pretty bad last season at 31%, and his FT% was... 49%?! WTH?

Most importantly, I didn't realize that both JK and Dunn are 22 years old. Given that, I can see why we'd be interested in taking a chance on JK - just not in exchange for Dunn.
Saberestar
RealGM
Posts: 22,261
And1: 16,916
Joined: May 21, 2010

Re: The Official 2025 Offseason Thread #4 Free Agency Opens! 

Post#2142 » by Saberestar » Thu Jul 31, 2025 5:11 pm

garrick wrote:
Sunsdeuce wrote:
lilfishi22 wrote:I learned a lesson just this past season with Dunn. I thought the guy was gonna get like 10-15mpg max because his lack of offense is going to make him a weak link. But credit to him for working hard and working on his shot and while he still wasn't a good shooter by any definition of the word, it was enough to keep him in games long enough to be a menace defensively.

What we got in the guys we've drafted this year and the last are talented and hard working prospects with seemingly the right attitude and at least one projectable elite NBA skill/measurable. If we're talking about a guy who is more polished, could probably play right away, that's probably someone like Queen. But the guy has engagement and motor issues and as importantly, he's not very good defensively. And we've seen dudes with a bad motor and poor defense fade out as well despite being polished and ready to play on the offensive end. There's trade offs no matter who you go with. And I think taking the consensus BPA in the 2nd half of the lottery is a reasonably sound approach.

Let me preference by saying, I like Dunn. I think he’s going to be in the league a long time. But if he doesn’t develop an offensive game, I’m not sure what he’s role will be long term in this league. He was on a rollercoaster all year. Sometimes he was unplayable and other times he looked like a bonafide starter. To be quite frank, I’m still not sure who or what Dunn is yet. What I liked: his defense ethic. What I didn’t like, his standing around on offense, waiting to shoot threes in the corner. He’s bread and butter on offense should be endless movement. Cutting, driving, dunking. Last year, his bread and butter was corner threes (which were not exactly a sure thing). With his shooting limitations he should be poor mans Shawn Marion. He should live and breathe by cuts, put backs and offensive rebounding. Threes should be secondary.


He's a taller Josh Okogie.

Looks amazing when they're hitting their threes but if they aren't they're a huge liability on offense and sometimes unplayable. For Dunn I think his poor free throw shooting really limits him in cuts to the basket because when you can't even hit over 50 percent of your free throws teams you probably aren't going to want to get fouled for fear of missing so many free throws.

It’s basketball...a TALLER Okogie is a much better player than Okogie himself.

Dunn is 6'7 and Okogie just 6'4. That difference is gonna make Dunn much better than Okogie at both sides of the court.

His rookie year was pretty successful, he has already shown that he belongs to the league. In this Summer League he was really good and he keeps improving his shooting percentages and his usage on offense. And excellent defense is a given for him.
User avatar
SkyBill40
General Manager
Posts: 7,761
And1: 6,529
Joined: Oct 24, 2014
Location: Phoenix
       

Re: The Official 2025 Offseason Thread #4 Free Agency Opens! 

Post#2143 » by SkyBill40 » Thu Jul 31, 2025 5:28 pm

I just hope Ishbia doesn't screw us again and get Kuminga, which will more than likely push us right back into apron hell once again. Dunn is a no go in any discussion talks in my opinion and Mat needs to see it that way, too.
SweaterBae wrote:It's the perfect trade when nobody is happy.
sunsfan1o1
Rookie
Posts: 1,133
And1: 849
Joined: May 16, 2022

Re: The Official 2025 Offseason Thread #4 Free Agency Opens! 

Post#2144 » by sunsfan1o1 » Thu Jul 31, 2025 6:02 pm

dremill24 wrote:
sunsfan1o1 wrote:
Sunsdeuce wrote:Has there ever been a team maxed out on salary, with no draft picks, and projected to be a bottom five team? Like
Are we making history?

This is why you should stop listening to people who know nothing about basketball. There’s at least 13 teams worse than the Suns.
Celtics
Nets
Hornets
Bulls
Pacers
Heat
Sixers
Blazers
Kings
Raptors
Jazz
Wizards
Pelicans

Honorable mentions: warriors, lakers, bucks, spurs, grizzlies, mavericks, clippers, Pistons, twolves


So when you're wrong, we get to definitively say that you know nothing about basketball?

I’m not usually wrong. And I won’t be wrong here. Unless there’s some unfortunate reason like Booker or someone important missing the season or extended time suns be at least in the playin with 38-48 wins for the season.
User avatar
NapoleonII
Lead Assistant
Posts: 4,595
And1: 4,918
Joined: Aug 31, 2007

Re: The Official 2025 Offseason Thread #4 Free Agency Opens! 

Post#2145 » by NapoleonII » Thu Jul 31, 2025 6:21 pm

sunsfan1o1 wrote:
dremill24 wrote:
sunsfan1o1 wrote:This is why you should stop listening to people who know nothing about basketball. There’s at least 13 teams worse than the Suns.
Celtics
Nets
Hornets
Bulls
Pacers
Heat
Sixers
Blazers
Kings
Raptors
Jazz
Wizards
Pelicans

Honorable mentions: warriors, lakers, bucks, spurs, grizzlies, mavericks, clippers, Pistons, twolves


So when you're wrong, we get to definitively say that you know nothing about basketball?

I’m not usually wrong. And I won’t be wrong here. Unless there’s some unfortunate reason like Booker or someone important missing the season or extended time suns be at least in the playin with 38-48 wins for the season.


I'll jump onto your bandwagon. I think we'll win 38+ as well.

It does sound a bit ridiculous after losing KD, but he was always a suspect fit with Booker IMO. He fit with GSW because their offense both incorporated and featured his ISO-heavy, mid-range bread and butter shots. None of our coaches could figure it out with Book and all the moving parts (losing Ayton, losing CP3, etc)

Addition by subtraction needs to be the name of the game this season. If I remember correctly we actually performed pretty damn well in the games without Beal.

Now we'll add Brooks, Green (who will be forced to take a backseat next to Booker, which his career absolutely needed) and Williams? That's a lot of pluses. Brooks was a sniper last year from 3, and a dog on defense. Williams, who knows, maybe he'll play 50+ games, is a legit center.

And now with the lack of picks, and the lack of expectations, this team might be able to ball out and surprise a lot of folks.

I don't have 5k to throw around and I stay away from gambling, but I'd do it if I had that to spare.

I'll be rooting hard for this crew. I'm most interested in seeing Dunn's development and Khaman's bust-or-no-bust-ability.
Rebound Mound
Junior
Posts: 314
And1: 137
Joined: Feb 24, 2025

Re: The Official 2025 Offseason Thread #4 Free Agency Opens! 

Post#2146 » by Rebound Mound » Thu Jul 31, 2025 6:31 pm

I thought Hachimura is a much better option than Kuminga, as he is a more established player and more whay we need.
I am pretty sure the Lakers would love to have Kuminga.
Is it possible to do both a sign and trade ans a trade, so we get Hachimura, the fLakers get Kuminga and the Warriors get Richard, Allen or ONeale and a pick from the fLakers, whom could get two seconds from us.
sunsbg
Head Coach
Posts: 6,316
And1: 5,415
Joined: Feb 29, 2016

Re: The Official 2025 Offseason Thread #4 Free Agency Opens! 

Post#2147 » by sunsbg » Thu Jul 31, 2025 6:35 pm

Absolute ceiling of this team is 41 wins, but hopefully they look at least as entertaining to watch as those U18 Eurobasket games I'm watching last two offseasons with a lot better ball movement and smart play than Booker & KD Suns.
dremill24
Assistant Coach
Posts: 3,910
And1: 3,196
Joined: Jan 11, 2016
Contact:

Re: The Official 2025 Offseason Thread #4 Free Agency Opens! 

Post#2148 » by dremill24 » Thu Jul 31, 2025 6:47 pm

sunsfan1o1 wrote:
dremill24 wrote:
sunsfan1o1 wrote:This is why you should stop listening to people who know nothing about basketball. There’s at least 13 teams worse than the Suns.
Celtics
Nets
Hornets
Bulls
Pacers
Heat
Sixers
Blazers
Kings
Raptors
Jazz
Wizards
Pelicans

Honorable mentions: warriors, lakers, bucks, spurs, grizzlies, mavericks, clippers, Pistons, twolves


So when you're wrong, we get to definitively say that you know nothing about basketball?

I’m not usually wrong. And I won’t be wrong here. Unless there’s some unfortunate reason like Booker or someone important missing the season or extended time suns be at least in the playin with 38-48 wins for the season.


:lol: ok buddy.

But IF you are wrong, by the flawless logic you've presented, we will all know that you know nothing about basketball.
Trying out this Substack thing. Suns and NBA thoughts. Check it out: https://hoopsnexus.substack.com/
KdoubleDees23
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,926
And1: 1,284
Joined: Feb 09, 2023

Re: The Official 2025 Offseason Thread #4 Free Agency Opens! 

Post#2149 » by KdoubleDees23 » Thu Jul 31, 2025 6:55 pm

dremill24 wrote:
sunsfan1o1 wrote:
dremill24 wrote:
So when you're wrong, we get to definitively say that you know nothing about basketball?

I’m not usually wrong. And I won’t be wrong here. Unless there’s some unfortunate reason like Booker or someone important missing the season or extended time suns be at least in the playin with 38-48 wins for the season.


:lol: ok buddy.

But IF you are wrong, by the flawless logic you've presented, we will all know that you know nothing about basketball.


Suns will win 35 + Games so that bet of 30.5 . I am going over.
sunsbg
Head Coach
Posts: 6,316
And1: 5,415
Joined: Feb 29, 2016

Re: The Official 2025 Offseason Thread #4 Free Agency Opens! 

Post#2150 » by sunsbg » Thu Jul 31, 2025 7:05 pm

KdoubleDees23 wrote:
dremill24 wrote:
sunsfan1o1 wrote:I’m not usually wrong. And I won’t be wrong here. Unless there’s some unfortunate reason like Booker or someone important missing the season or extended time suns be at least in the playin with 38-48 wins for the season.


:lol: ok buddy.

But IF you are wrong, by the flawless logic you've presented, we will all know that you know nothing about basketball.


Suns will win 35 + Games so that bet of 30.5 . I am going over.


You'd have said the same last season for O/U 36.5. What makes you confident this season ? Booker has become a better leader ? The redundancy in backcourt has been solved ? Team is more experienced now ? I assume it's just blind hope the team will play harder without the drama queens.
sunsfan1o1
Rookie
Posts: 1,133
And1: 849
Joined: May 16, 2022

Re: The Official 2025 Offseason Thread #4 Free Agency Opens! 

Post#2151 » by sunsfan1o1 » Thu Jul 31, 2025 7:22 pm

dremill24 wrote:
sunsfan1o1 wrote:
dremill24 wrote:
So when you're wrong, we get to definitively say that you know nothing about basketball?

I’m not usually wrong. And I won’t be wrong here. Unless there’s some unfortunate reason like Booker or someone important missing the season or extended time suns be at least in the playin with 38-48 wins for the season.


:lol: ok buddy.

But IF you are wrong, by the flawless logic you've presented, we will all know that you know nothing about basketball.

It’s tentative of course things can change. The NBA season is fluid. But as of today this team is better than 30 wins.
We have 2 guys coming off 2 years under Udoka. One of which is a rising star. The other which is a dog and 3D. Williams is a top 5-10 center when healthy. Our backup C are good. Dunn will be better. Another dog. Booker won’t have to worry about making KD happy. Coach is coming from the Cavs. I think our bench needs more work but let’s see if we get Kuminga or something else. I’ll circle back once the season starts
PhxLax
Junior
Posts: 356
And1: 325
Joined: Jul 02, 2017
   

Re: The Official 2025 Offseason Thread #4 Free Agency Opens! 

Post#2152 » by PhxLax » Thu Jul 31, 2025 7:25 pm

I like that Hachimura idea. 3-team trade where Lakers get Kuminga and Suns get Hachimura would be ideal. Goodwin and Hachimura on the Lakers last year were solid. Hustled, grabbed loose balls, and made shots... Even Goodwin.
dremill24
Assistant Coach
Posts: 3,910
And1: 3,196
Joined: Jan 11, 2016
Contact:

Re: The Official 2025 Offseason Thread #4 Free Agency Opens! 

Post#2153 » by dremill24 » Thu Jul 31, 2025 8:14 pm

sunsfan1o1 wrote:
dremill24 wrote:
sunsfan1o1 wrote:I’m not usually wrong. And I won’t be wrong here. Unless there’s some unfortunate reason like Booker or someone important missing the season or extended time suns be at least in the playin with 38-48 wins for the season.


:lol: ok buddy.

But IF you are wrong, by the flawless logic you've presented, we will all know that you know nothing about basketball.

It’s tentative of course things can change. The NBA season is fluid. But as of today this team is better than 30 wins.
We have 2 guys coming off 2 years under Udoka. One of which is a rising star. The other which is a dog and 3D. Williams is a top 5-10 center when healthy. Our backup C are good. Dunn will be better. Another dog. Booker won’t have to worry about making KD happy. Coach is coming from the Cavs. I think our bench needs more work but let’s see if we get Kuminga or something else. I’ll circle back once the season starts


Completely missing the point...I suppose that tracks lol
Trying out this Substack thing. Suns and NBA thoughts. Check it out: https://hoopsnexus.substack.com/
dremill24
Assistant Coach
Posts: 3,910
And1: 3,196
Joined: Jan 11, 2016
Contact:

Re: The Official 2025 Offseason Thread #4 Free Agency Opens! 

Post#2154 » by dremill24 » Thu Jul 31, 2025 8:15 pm

PhxLax wrote:I like that Hachimura idea. 3-team trade where Lakers get Kuminga and Suns get Hachimura would be ideal. Goodwin and Hachimura on the Lakers last year were solid. Hustled, grabbed loose balls, and made shots... Even Goodwin.


Lakers have been working pretty hard to preserve cap space for '26 and/or '27 so moving Rui for a multi-year deal is highly unlikely unless its for a star thats unexpectedly available.
Trying out this Substack thing. Suns and NBA thoughts. Check it out: https://hoopsnexus.substack.com/
Blonde
Veteran
Posts: 2,934
And1: 3,919
Joined: Jun 16, 2014
Location: Phoenix
       

Re: The Official 2025 Offseason Thread #4 Free Agency Opens! 

Post#2155 » by Blonde » Thu Jul 31, 2025 8:43 pm

I see the proposed Kuminga trade (Royce/Richards/2nds for Kumbucket at 90m/4years) as a low risk, medium upside move. The type of move a team with a bleak outlook should be pursuing. If he cuts into Dunn’s development, just move off of Brooks to open up the other forward spot. Suns don’t need to be looking to maximize their win total next year. That said, I’m perfectly fine to pass on this one too, and I wouldn’t want to include Oso in a deal.
User avatar
Ghost of Kleine
Master of Tweets
Posts: 16,277
And1: 9,020
Joined: Apr 13, 2012

Re: The Official 2025 Offseason Thread #4 Free Agency Opens! 

Post#2156 » by Ghost of Kleine » Thu Jul 31, 2025 10:35 pm

Read on Twitter


Read on Twitter


At what cost though?? Because I definitely wouldn't want to he giving him the MLE or taxpayer MLE just to add another wing.
Image
User avatar
MrMiyagi
Suns Forum Eternal Optimist
Posts: 8,096
And1: 7,639
Joined: Jan 10, 2010
   

Re: The Official 2025 Offseason Thread #4 Free Agency Opens! 

Post#2157 » by MrMiyagi » Thu Jul 31, 2025 10:52 pm

Devastated by the Mikal extension
SHAZAM!

Suns traded Mikal Bridges, Cam Johnson, Jae Crowder and 4 1st round picks and a swap so some Vegas Bookies would like us.
sunsfan1o1
Rookie
Posts: 1,133
And1: 849
Joined: May 16, 2022

Re: The Official 2025 Offseason Thread #4 Free Agency Opens! 

Post#2158 » by sunsfan1o1 » Thu Jul 31, 2025 11:03 pm

dremill24 wrote:
sunsfan1o1 wrote:
dremill24 wrote:
:lol: ok buddy.

But IF you are wrong, by the flawless logic you've presented, we will all know that you know nothing about basketball.

It’s tentative of course things can change. The NBA season is fluid. But as of today this team is better than 30 wins.
We have 2 guys coming off 2 years under Udoka. One of which is a rising star. The other which is a dog and 3D. Williams is a top 5-10 center when healthy. Our backup C are good. Dunn will be better. Another dog. Booker won’t have to worry about making KD happy. Coach is coming from the Cavs. I think our bench needs more work but let’s see if we get Kuminga or something else. I’ll circle back once the season starts


Completely missing the point...I suppose that tracks lol

You’re gonna be ok. Sorry you must not know basketball since you probably agree with the under.
garrick
Head Coach
Posts: 7,326
And1: 4,041
Joined: Dec 02, 2006
     

Re: The Official 2025 Offseason Thread #4 Free Agency Opens! 

Post#2159 » by garrick » Fri Aug 1, 2025 12:12 am

ImNotMcDiSwear wrote:
garrick wrote:
Sunsdeuce wrote:Let me preference by saying, I like Dunn. I think he’s going to be in the league a long time. But if he doesn’t develop an offensive game, I’m not sure what he’s role will be long term in this league. He was on a rollercoaster all year. Sometimes he was unplayable and other times he looked like a bonafide starter. To be quite frank, I’m still not sure who or what Dunn is yet. What I liked: his defense ethic. What I didn’t like, his standing around on offense, waiting to shoot threes in the corner. He’s bread and butter on offense should be endless movement. Cutting, driving, dunking. Last year, his bread and butter was corner threes (which were not exactly a sure thing). With his shooting limitations he should be poor mans Shawn Marion. He should live and breathe by cuts, put backs and offensive rebounding. Threes should be secondary.


He's a taller Josh Okogie.

Looks amazing when they're hitting their threes but if they aren't they're a huge liability on offense and sometimes unplayable. For Dunn I think his poor free throw shooting really limits him in cuts to the basket because when you can't even hit over 50 percent of your free throws teams you probably aren't going to want to get fouled for fear of missing so many free throws.


I thought Dunn showed some offensive upside at the tail end of last season and in summer league. I don't think he'll just be standing in the corner unless the offense redounds to iso-ball like it did last season - which is possible given that we have no point guard.

If Okogie was 6'8" he'd be a rotation player in this league. I think Dunn has a chance to be much better.

Returning to the question of JK - given their contracts, Dunn is clearly the better asset. Just looking at the players, Dunn has no injury history - last year's DNPs were all DNP-CD. Better blocks and steals rates. Higher TRB%.

OTOH, Kuminga has already shown he can generate his own offense and showed flashes of being a 20/6/5 guy his sophomore and junior seasons. I ragged on his 3FG% and FT% before noticing Dunn's 3FG% was also pretty bad last season at 31%, and his FT% was... 49%?! WTH?

Most importantly, I didn't realize that both JK and Dunn are 22 years old. Given that, I can see why we'd be interested in taking a chance on JK - just not in exchange for Dunn.


Yeah Kuminga is by far the better offensive player since he has averaged .500 percent from the 2 which is far better than Ryan at .430 so he's a lot better at creating his shot which is not a strength of Dunn's and Kuminga is asking for upwards of 25M per season which is something we can't afford and we will be right back at the 2nd apron again so the contract is a no deal for me.
User avatar
lilfishi22
Forum Mod - Suns
Forum Mod - Suns
Posts: 36,146
And1: 24,484
Joined: Oct 16, 2007
Location: Australia

Re: The Official 2025 Offseason Thread #4 Free Agency Opens! 

Post#2160 » by lilfishi22 » Fri Aug 1, 2025 1:07 am

Blonde wrote:I see the proposed Kuminga trade (Royce/Richards/2nds for Kumbucket at 90m/4years) as a low risk, medium upside move. The type of move a team with a bleak outlook should be pursuing. If he cuts into Dunn’s development, just move off of Brooks to open up the other forward spot. Suns don’t need to be looking to maximize their win total next year. That said, I’m perfectly fine to pass on this one too, and I wouldn’t want to include Oso in a deal.

My issue with Kuminga is really just a difference in projection. He's obviously got potential at 23, he has the physical and athletic gifts and he has some skills, all of which if you add it up should turn into a star level player. He has that talent to be an all-star. But there's a lot of guys who has the talent, had the physical gits, had the skill set and just never ended up being all that good because of IQ, character, work ethic, attitude etc etc. By most measures, Josh Jackson should've been a star in this league. He had the insane athleticism, great physical gifts, he could play defense, make plays, score etc. But the guy was a total numbskull, had horrible basketball IQ and just never got it together. Kuminga is much less of that but what kept JJ from progressing might also be what keeps Kuminga from progressing further. I'd rather bet less on Dunn on being 90% of the player Kuminga is than $20m+ a year on what Kuminga could be.

Return to Phoenix Suns