2025 College Football Thread !!!

[Cactus Jack]

I have Allar as QB1 and Mateer as QB2.

The combo of size and elite level arm talent for Allar will most likely keep him as QB1 for me

Yeah, Allar has the most upside out of everyone. I'm not sure he has the clutch gene? But he has the measurables for sure. I love his mechanics.

[clyde21]

I have Allar as QB1 and Mateer as QB2.

The combo of size and elite level arm talent for Allar will most likely keep him as QB1 for me

Allar has a fun arm but man he's just not that good

[clyde21]

Mateer is Baker 2.0, he'll go #1, unless Sellers has a crazy rest of the season

[Cactus Jack]

Mateer is Baker 2.0, he'll go #1, unless Sellers has a crazy rest of the season

You don't think Anthony Richardson will sour teams on Sellers?

[azcatz11]

Mateer is Baker 2.0, he'll go #1, unless Sellers has a crazy rest of the season

What’s so good about Mateer? He reminds me of Manziel. He’s very small and makes a lot of poor decisions.

[Duke4life831]

I have Allar as QB1 and Mateer as QB2.

The combo of size and elite level arm talent for Allar will most likely keep him as QB1 for me

Allar has a fun arm but man he's just not that good

Agreed. He definitely leaves a lot to be desired. But I think his floor is pretty high. The giant arm, he’s accurate and he is pretty damn good when it comes to turning it over. Today was only his 11th interception in his career. I think his floor is Joe Flacco-esque. Joe never really took that next step from solid starter to a big time playmaker.

And I think that’s what Allar is right now. He just lacks making plays. I think you take him with the hope he can get that in him someday. And if he doesn’t, he most likely will be a solid starter

Mateer is definitely the guy you take if you’re willing to take a bigger risk trying to find a big time playmaker

[Cactus Jack]

Mateer is Baker 2.0, he'll go #1, unless Sellers has a crazy rest of the season

What’s so good about Mateer? He reminds me of Manziel. He’s very small and makes a lot of poor decisions.

Kind of...I watched too much of him at Wazzu to really buy in.

[Cactus Jack]

I think his floor is Joe Flacco-esque. Joe never really took that next step from solid starter to a big time playmaker.

And I think that’s what Allar is right now. He just lacks making plays. I think you take him with the hope he can get that in him someday. And if he doesn’t, he most likely will be a solid starter.

Flacco isn't that bad of a comp actually lol.

[azcatz11]

I have Allar as QB1 and Mateer as QB2.

The combo of size and elite level arm talent for Allar will most likely keep him as QB1 for me

Allar has a fun arm but man he's just not that good

Agreed. He definitely leaves a lot to be desired. But I think his floor is pretty high. The giant arm, he’s accurate and he is pretty damn good when it comes to turning it over. Today was only his 11th interception in his career. I think his floor is Joe Flacco-esque. Joe never really took that next step from solid starter to a big time playmaker.

And I think that’s what Allar is right now. He just lacks making plays. I think you take him with the hope he can get that in him someday. And if he doesn’t, he most likely will be a solid starter

Mateer is definitely the guy you take if you’re willing to take a bigger risk trying to find a big time playmaker

I think people are sleeping on Beck. And he’s still only 22 and has a live arm I never realized he had.

[clyde21]

Mateer is Baker 2.0, he'll go #1, unless Sellers has a crazy rest of the season

What’s so good about Mateer? He reminds me of Manziel. He’s very small and makes a lot of poor decisions.

He's got a sick arm and is a playmaker, very Baker-ish, a lot of teams will be in even if he can sometimes erratic

[clyde21]

Mateer is Baker 2.0, he'll go #1, unless Sellers has a crazy rest of the season

You don't think Anthony Richardson will sour teams on Sellers?

nah, teams will always give the freaks a chance, and I don't think he and Richardson are alike tbh, Richardson was bad bad he should've never went that high, at least Sellers can complete some passes

[bluejerseyjinx]

North Carolina is on a roll now !!!!!!

Dude you guys are playing a division 2 school

Tar Heels gonna run the table !!!!!!!!!!!!