OT: NY Yankees 2025 Season Thread (Hal is cheap, Brian is dumb)

[blue and orange]

You know what else is trendy? Fans that have the ability to make passive aggressive comments like that because of agendas.

Hey this all Judge's fault ok.

[blue and orange]

So I have an agenda because I'm not blaming a player who is batting .500, I was the first one on here to call out Judge for not coming through in game 1 with the bases loaded. So how do I have an agenda?

[kNicksGmen]

Team excluding judge must have hit like .150 this postseason. Embarrassing.

Meanwhile the jays 8/9 hitters are raking.

[KnicksGadfly]

Max Fried and Rodon should be ashamed of themselves. Gil, I wish we traded you for Tucker. Loser.

[GIMME_DATT]

The lineup around judge was hot garbage . Grisham played to the back of his baseball card which is a bad hitter . Volpe is awful , but can’t get benched ever.

And fried and Rondon pitched like bums

[knicks94]

Hal should consider putting up playoff banners at the Stadium since the Yankees aren't winning squat as long as he's still alive.

[knicks94]

The lineup around judge was hot garbage . Grisham played to the back of his baseball card which is a bad hitter . Volpe is awful , but can’t get benched ever.

And fried and Rondon pitched like bums

Grisham is a 5th outfielder who had a fluke year. He'd fit right in with the Mets next season! Volpe has to be the most useless Yankee since Kevin Youkilis. Fried and Rodon at times look like Koufax and Carlton during the regular season, but in October they turn into Javy Vazquez and Kevin Brown.

[JXL]

Bullpen was straight trash. Lineup around Judge is homeless person piss. Hal and Brian has ruined the prestige of the Yankees.

[VirginiaKnickFan]

Fire Cashman - Fire Boone...that is all.

[knicks94]

Here's who I wouldn't bring back next season:

Volpe
Grisham
Wells
Goldschmidt
Williams
Doval
Leiter
Weaver
Loaisaga

[Butch718]

Out of all the potential free agents I would bring back the following:

Rosario - UTL player that can hit left handed pitching
Hill - Solid bullpen guy

On the fence:
Belli - I wouldn’t be sad if he left, but wouldn’t be opposed to him staying if the deal is right.
Goldschmidt - Still a solid defensive 1B that can spell occasional relief to Rice

Out:
Williams
Grisham (he will regress and was awful during post season)
Weaver
Loaisiga
Yarbrough
Boone
Volpe

They need to part ways with Volpe and stick with Caballero until Lombard is ready to come up.

Sign or trade for a contact hitter to split 3B with McMahon.

Let the Martian and Jones be your everyday outfielders, or trade one of them. Do not platoon either player and stunt their development. No half measures.

Get a solid backup catcher.

Commit to Ben Rice as your everyday 1B and occasional backup catcher.

Sign, call up or trade for 3-4 new bull pen arms. Commit to Warren as a long reliever or trade him.

[MrDollarBills]

Maybe having a philosophy of home run or bust instead of putting the ball in play, and an over reliance on analytics over good fundamental play just doesn't work against playoff pitching.

Cashman is an idiot.

Anyway, the team brought this on themselves, this was pure karma. Judge is wasting what little is left of his prime here.

[VirginiaKnickFan]

Maybe having a philosophy of home run or bust instead of putting the ball in play, and an over reliance on analytics over good fundamental play just doesn't work against playoff pitching.

Cashman is an idiot.

Anyway, the team brought this on themselves, this was pure karma. Judge is wasting what little is left of his prime here.

Imagine how many World Series rings he would have if he was on the Dodgers.

[MrDollarBills]

Maybe having a philosophy of home run or bust instead of putting the ball in play, and an over reliance on analytics over good fundamental play just doesn't work against playoff pitching.

Cashman is an idiot.

Anyway, the team brought this on themselves, this was pure karma. Judge is wasting what little is left of his prime here.

Imagine how many World Series rings he would have if he was on the Dodgers.

What kills me is that if I remember correctly, Hal was the main reason why Judge is still here. Cashman was not trying to pay him.

This is now the 2nd time in a row where a team did film work, devised a strategy and busted the Yankees' asses. Meanwhile Cashman and his nerds have dudes swinging at balls in the dirt trying to chase non existent home runs.

[VirginiaKnickFan]

Maybe having a philosophy of home run or bust instead of putting the ball in play, and an over reliance on analytics over good fundamental play just doesn't work against playoff pitching.

Cashman is an idiot.

Anyway, the team brought this on themselves, this was pure karma. Judge is wasting what little is left of his prime here.

Imagine how many World Series rings he would have if he was on the Dodgers.

What kills me is that if I remember correctly, Hal was the main reason why Judge is still here. Cashman was not trying to pay him.

This is now the 2nd time in a row where a team did film work, devised a strategy and busted the Yankees' asses. Meanwhile Cashman and his nerds have dudes swinging at balls in the dirt trying to chase non existent home runs.

A swing for the fences offense will never go deep in the playoffs. Cashman and moronic analytics staff just don't get it.