ImageImageImageImageImage

Roster is a mess - missed draft picks are part of reason

Moderators: DG88, niQ, Duffman100, tsherkin, Reeko, lebron stopper, HiJiNX, 7 Footer, Morris_Shatford

Godaddycurse
RealGM
Posts: 22,452
And1: 14,350
Joined: Nov 13, 2019
 

Re: Roster is a mess - missed draft picks are part of reason 

Post#41 » by Godaddycurse » Sat Nov 1, 2025 5:22 pm

DelAbbot wrote:
Godaddycurse wrote:
DelAbbot wrote:
This approach has seen success in recent history. Without talking about OKC, the HOU demonstrated this is a very fruitful approach to building a contender


houston is not a contender (yet), jury's still out on if they will get there with how imbalanced their roster is


They executed the TWO's plan. Tank for a few years, accumulating several blue chip prospects, and clear cap space to sign vets to complement their blue chip prospects - then consolidate trade for a max-contract star to improve the fit of their roster (KD was a perfect fit, even though has age risk).


of their 4 top 5 picks only Amen has star potential. Green was bad, Jabari is meh and Reed doesn't look good so far.
DelAbbot
RealGM
Posts: 15,468
And1: 21,886
Joined: May 22, 2019
   

Re: Roster is a mess - missed draft picks are part of reason 

Post#42 » by DelAbbot » Sat Nov 1, 2025 5:24 pm

anotherhomer wrote:also , many players in the '21 class has surpassed our ROY, barnes
Cade, Giddey, Mobley, Wagner, Alpergun

Other guys nipping at Barnes include Trey Murphy, Jalen Johnson

Barnes is still a good player though


Cade and Mobley were drafted ahead of Barnes so it's not fair to compare them. But seeing Giddey's 3pt develop and becoming a better player (due to his consistency) than Scottie Barnes really hurts.
Harcore Fenton Mun
RealGM
Posts: 14,502
And1: 8,482
Joined: Jul 17, 2006

Re: Roster is a mess - missed draft picks are part of reason 

Post#43 » by Harcore Fenton Mun » Sat Nov 1, 2025 5:25 pm

Houston's not good because of their drafting. It's their owner, he's got a mandate on winning.
Image
DelAbbot
RealGM
Posts: 15,468
And1: 21,886
Joined: May 22, 2019
   

Re: Roster is a mess - missed draft picks are part of reason 

Post#44 » by DelAbbot » Sat Nov 1, 2025 5:25 pm

Godaddycurse wrote:
DelAbbot wrote:
Godaddycurse wrote:
houston is not a contender (yet), jury's still out on if they will get there with how imbalanced their roster is


They executed the TWO's plan. Tank for a few years, accumulating several blue chip prospects, and clear cap space to sign vets to complement their blue chip prospects - then consolidate trade for a max-contract star to improve the fit of their roster (KD was a perfect fit, even though has age risk).


of their 4 top 5 picks only Amen has star potential. Green was bad, Jabari is meh and Reed doesn't look good so far.


HOU didn't do it to perfection but they executed that plan. OKC executed it to perfection with the Jalen Williams pick (as well as Giddey and Chet picks) and still have a war-chest of picks to use
User avatar
Psubs
RealGM
Posts: 20,951
And1: 11,951
Joined: Nov 20, 2004
Location: Toronto

Re: Roster is a mess - missed draft picks are part of reason 

Post#45 » by Psubs » Sat Nov 1, 2025 6:13 pm

Not getting Walker Kessler might be the omission that could've fixed everything.
Image
Jerry Lucas
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,883
And1: 1,830
Joined: Apr 01, 2021
     

Re: Roster is a mess - missed draft picks are part of reason 

Post#46 » by Jerry Lucas » Sat Nov 1, 2025 6:29 pm

DelAbbot wrote:2) After that play-in embarrassment vs Diar Derozan, the FO knee-jerk reacted in pivoting from drafting based on length & defense to only based on shooting, by picking Gradey Dick who profiled exactly the opposite of their last 8 years of drafting philosophy (which yielded many successes like PS, OG), passing on Keyonte George.

As the creator of the 4/4 Masai/Bobby-type FRP Barttorvik queries and therefore the board authority on the matter, this is fake news. It was actually the opposite. Gradey produced like a Masai-type FRP in his draft year and Keyonte didn't. They would have had to actually do what you are claiming they did in order to avoid some of their mistakes (go against their type by picking Desmond Bane over Malachi as another prime example).
My Masai/Bobby-type FRP Barttorvik queries: 4/4, zero misses

Team Find The Next Superstar Closer
User avatar
Nature
Sophomore
Posts: 230
And1: 461
Joined: Jul 16, 2019
 

Re: Roster is a mess - missed draft picks are part of reason 

Post#47 » by Nature » Sat Nov 1, 2025 6:33 pm

Shakril wrote:
Los_29 wrote:
Nature wrote:
Those two moves in particular set the team back 10-15 years. It sounds ridiculous, I know, but I believe it's that bad.

The worst part is that I think both were orchestrated by our current and recently extended GM.


I say 100 years.

Not getting situational big Walker Kessler is demoralizing for this franchise. We might never recover.


Sorry, but thats just BS. We have seen franchises recover within two years and they were in worse situations.

Our problem right now is not the players we have, but the way we are playing. Against the Cavs it was a step forward, but all in all, we are bad because we play stupid. Its honestly the first time i think its Darko's fault.


It's going to be hard for us to have a conversation because we'd first have to agree to a definition of recovery and neither of us have that time on our hands. Of course, we'll have to right some of our wrongs, but that's not what I mean when I say we were set back a decade.

Here's where I'm coming from. We were in an incredible position to rebuild entering the 2022/23 season. A core of Siakam/OG/Fred clearly wasn't talented enough to build around, we had the reigning ROY on our squad (who played the same position as our best player), and our core was signed to decent enough contracts.

As the year progressed, the cracks in the foundation quickly widened. There were rumoured spats between Fred and Barnes, publicized struggles between Siakam and our front office, and Scottie was relegated to shooting corner 3s by a COTY coach who struggled to make the roster work. Point is, we had good players, but for a slew of reasons it just wasn't working and, contract decisions would have to be made soon.

The front office responded by first doing absolutely nothing for way, way too long. Then, they performed a series of what can only be surmised as panic (panac?) moves due mainly to contract mismanagement and their unwillingness to see the writing on the wall.

We traded a first for Thad Young in early 2022. Traded another first in Feb of 2023 for Poeltl. Lost reigning All-Star Fred for nothing in 2023. Traded DPOY candidate OG for pennies on the dollar in late 2023. A few months later, we traded All-NBA Siakam for an even worse return in 2024.

Imagine how different the roster would look if we'd handled that era even semi-competently?

I could keep going but I've ranted long enough. Let's get to the point.

The Toronto Raptors have to draft and develop their way to contention - all while being extremely diligent with player contracts. The entire operation revolves around drafting well, developing well, and managing contracts.

How long does it take, on average, for a player to hit their prime? Seven years?

We should be in year 2-4 of developing a few great prospects. We had enough assets to fuel an incredible and unavoidable rebuild.

Instead, we're developing D-level talent, have no blue chip prospects, are riddled with untradeable contracts, and we're headed towards the play-in.

Not all hope is lost. Maybe Bobby becomes competent, maybe we draft Jokic in the 2nd round, maybe we win the lottery this year... Stuff can happen! But it doesn't negate the fact that we should be years further along than we are. Instead, we're still in free-fall.
Image
User avatar
ItsDanger
RealGM
Posts: 28,824
And1: 26,023
Joined: Nov 01, 2008

Re: Roster is a mess - missed draft picks are part of reason 

Post#48 » by ItsDanger » Sat Nov 1, 2025 6:38 pm

I've brought it up previously few times but it bears repeating. Team needs to be far more aggressive at the draft instead of just waiting around for your turn. They definitely have to be top 3 inactive teams come draft time. No excuses last few years and it's continued.
Organization can be defined as an organized body of people with a particular purpose. Not random.
Jerry Lucas
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,883
And1: 1,830
Joined: Apr 01, 2021
     

Re: Roster is a mess - missed draft picks are part of reason 

Post#49 » by Jerry Lucas » Sat Nov 1, 2025 6:39 pm

PushDaRock wrote:
DelAbbot wrote:
PushDaRock wrote:
They clearly valued Thad Young who they saw as a vet who could also be a playoff rotation piece on a team lacking wing depth. They re-signed him as well, so it wasn't just a pure salary dump move in their minds. Obviously it didn't work out, but that's a different than it just being a pure salary dump.

Who's to say Masai didn't have Koloko over those guys anyways? It's a crapshoot after 20 and it's more eye of the beholder.


There is 0 chance Masai was so focused on Koloko that he would have picked Koloko at 20th in the first round. There were strong rumors of them targetting Andrew Nembhard in the same group as Koloko - so dropping from 20th to 2nd round was detrimental to their choice availability


Again, they got Thad Young as well who they valued at the time.

Zero chance he goes off the board like he did with Caboclo?

They obviously really liked Koloko, not sure why it's so far fetched he still might have been their guy.

As the creator of the 4/4 Masai/Bobby-type FRP Barttorvik queries and therefore the board authority on the matter, they were going to take Walker Kessler if they never traded down for Thad Young.
My Masai/Bobby-type FRP Barttorvik queries: 4/4, zero misses

Team Find The Next Superstar Closer
User avatar
Nature
Sophomore
Posts: 230
And1: 461
Joined: Jul 16, 2019
 

Re: Roster is a mess - missed draft picks are part of reason 

Post#50 » by Nature » Sat Nov 1, 2025 6:54 pm

YogurtProducer wrote:
Nature wrote:
hyper316 wrote:Trading for Thad and Jakob and throwing away picks set the team back for years


Those two moves in particular set the team back 10-15 years. It sounds ridiculous, I know, but I believe it's that bad.

The worst part is that I think both were orchestrated by our current and recently extended GM.

Come on man, nothing sets a franchise back 10-15 outside having 20 year old MJ and cutting him


I stand by it. We're already in year 4 since the Thad trade and year 3 since the Jak trade.

How many more years considering our current situation until we're perennial threats to make the ECF again? We are devoid of top talent and riddled with untradeable contracts.

Those two moves in the context of what they led to set us back longer than most care to admit.
Image
User avatar
ForeverTFC
RealGM
Posts: 18,093
And1: 19,775
Joined: Dec 07, 2004
         

Re: Roster is a mess - missed draft picks are part of reason 

Post#51 » by ForeverTFC » Sat Nov 1, 2025 6:56 pm

You wanted to make this thread so badly eh? Your post is an argument against your position brother...
YogurtProducer
RealGM
Posts: 30,762
And1: 33,430
Joined: Jul 22, 2013
Location: Saskatchewan
       

Re: Roster is a mess - missed draft picks are part of reason 

Post#52 » by YogurtProducer » Sat Nov 1, 2025 7:00 pm

Nature wrote:
YogurtProducer wrote:
Nature wrote:
Those two moves in particular set the team back 10-15 years. It sounds ridiculous, I know, but I believe it's that bad.

The worst part is that I think both were orchestrated by our current and recently extended GM.

Come on man, nothing sets a franchise back 10-15 outside having 20 year old MJ and cutting him


I stand by it. We're already in year 4 since the Thad trade and year 3 since the Jak trade.

How many more years considering our current situation until we're perennial threats to make the ECF again? We are devoid of top talent and riddled with untradeable contracts.

Those two moves in the context of what they led to set us back longer than most care to admit.

Even assuming we went best player available with the benefit of hindsight, Kessler and Edey(?) instead of Poeltl isn’t fundamentally changing this team.

Saying we got set back 10-15 years is just insane. For all you know, we don’t do those trades and end up in the lotter for a decade anyways.
User avatar
Nature
Sophomore
Posts: 230
And1: 461
Joined: Jul 16, 2019
 

Re: Roster is a mess - missed draft picks are part of reason 

Post#53 » by Nature » Sat Nov 1, 2025 7:11 pm

YogurtProducer wrote:
Nature wrote:
YogurtProducer wrote:Come on man, nothing sets a franchise back 10-15 outside having 20 year old MJ and cutting him


I stand by it. We're already in year 4 since the Thad trade and year 3 since the Jak trade.

How many more years considering our current situation until we're perennial threats to make the ECF again? We are devoid of top talent and riddled with untradeable contracts.

Those two moves in the context of what they led to set us back longer than most care to admit.

Even assuming we went best player available with the benefit of hindsight, Kessler and Edey(?) instead of Poeltl isn’t fundamentally changing this team.

Saying we got set back 10-15 years is just insane. For all you know, we don’t do those trades and end up in the lotter for a decade anyways.


I'm not saying we should have kept the picks. Maybe we do something else with the picks. Maybe we package one with OG and trade up. That's not really the point...

What I'm saying is using those picks to trade for Thad and Poeltl were definitely not the right moves. And adding Poeltl to the group delayed decisions that should have been made 3 years ago. Like I said, it's the context and subsequent actions of what those moves led to that were disastrous.
Image
Pointgod
RealGM
Posts: 24,204
And1: 24,503
Joined: Jun 28, 2014

Re: Roster is a mess - missed draft picks are part of reason 

Post#54 » by Pointgod » Sat Nov 1, 2025 7:30 pm

Nature wrote:
hyper316 wrote:Trading for Thad and Jakob and throwing away picks set the team back for years


Those two moves in particular set the team back 10-15 years. It sounds ridiculous, I know, but I believe it's that bad.

The worst part is that I think both were orchestrated by our current and recently extended GM.


The Thad Young trade showed that the front office had run out of ideas. The Poeltl trade solidified that they were cooked. The problem goes beyond those two trades and into the fact that we let Lowry, Fred and GTJ go for nothing, then overpaid useless vets in free agency.

We should have just done a full instead of trying to build from the middle. If we had started the rebuild earlier, then we would have realized that Scottie is not a #1 earlier and tried to get that player through the draft or instead of locking ourselves into Ingram.
Masai4PM
Junior
Posts: 362
And1: 872
Joined: Aug 10, 2020
   

Re: Roster is a mess - missed draft picks are part of reason 

Post#55 » by Masai4PM » Sat Nov 1, 2025 8:26 pm

I agree with the premise of this thread and we should trade some of these players (with IQ, RJ, etc) for draft picks and fillers, and load up on talent from future drafts.

The roster is a mess, lacks high end talent, and is filled with either mediocre players or overpaid players, often times both.
User avatar
bape_lovers
RealGM
Posts: 25,009
And1: 19,111
Joined: Oct 28, 2010
Location: 6ix side
 

Re: Roster is a mess - missed draft picks are part of reason 

Post#56 » by bape_lovers » Sat Nov 1, 2025 8:28 pm

It’s always doom, people will destroy Ja Maront too if we had him with his performance and off court issues. Don’t take anyone seriously here. Boggie is only person that can rant and 70% right tbh. I take his rants more than anyone here

Appostis wrote:Or... Starting PG is struggling starting out. If you're convinced he's not worth the contract that's fine... but he would be 20 mil a year in the best of cases.

And the starting center been hobbled or out the entire season?

It's 6 games.. Dick had 1 steller game and though I wish that number of good vs bad game was reversed it's such a small sample size that you're really reaching here.

Rest is people complaining about late first round and second round picks not landing.. *head shake*
Image

Credit to JaysRule, Detective
User avatar
Clutch0z24
General Manager
Posts: 9,922
And1: 9,970
Joined: May 08, 2014
   

Re: Roster is a mess - missed draft picks are part of reason 

Post#57 » by Clutch0z24 » Sat Nov 1, 2025 8:34 pm

Just look at what the Spurs did....Post Kawhi they kept DeRozan/Aldridge around (2 Players who are all stars in their own right but you are not winning with these 2 as your lead players) They were a hovering 32-35 win team since 2019-2022 In that time span they have drafted players like Vassell, Joshua Primo, Sochan...Sochan and Vassell are ok players but they are not going to change your franchise right...

The year they blew that mid team up and traded everyone for draft picks and actually tried to be bad their franchise changed around for the better....(If you don't try you will always lose) They got lucky and got #1 pick and drafted Victor, Castle, Harper 3 years in a row with actually tanking and being a 22 win type of team for the last 3 years...

Now they are prolly going to win a championship in the future because of it and have an exciting core to cheer for and fun to watch.

Thats what you have to do in the NBA to get good results not half ass it and try to compete with a bad team. Never works.
Image
DelAbbot
RealGM
Posts: 15,468
And1: 21,886
Joined: May 22, 2019
   

Re: Roster is a mess - missed draft picks are part of reason 

Post#58 » by DelAbbot » Sat Nov 1, 2025 9:02 pm

Clutch0z24 wrote:Just look at what the Spurs did....Post Kawhi they kept DeRozan/Aldridge around (2 Players who are all stars in their own right but you are not winning with these 2 as your lead players) They were a hovering 32-35 win team since 2019-2022 In that time span they have drafted players like Vassell, Joshua Primo, Sochan...Sochan and Vassell are ok players but they are not going to change your franchise right...

The year they blew that mid team up and traded everyone for draft picks and actually tried to be bad their franchise changed around for the better....(If you don't try you will always lose) They got lucky and got #1 pick and drafted Victor, Castle, Harper 3 years in a row with actually tanking and being a 22 win type of team for the last 3 years...

Now they are prolly going to win a championship in the future because of it and have an exciting core to cheer for and fun to watch.

Thats what you have to do in the NBA to get good results not half ass it and try to compete with a bad team. Never works.


I rather not use Spurs as an example of successful tanking because they got once-in-a-generation lucky in getting Wemby.
Anticon
General Manager
Posts: 8,309
And1: 5,289
Joined: Dec 16, 2004

Re: Roster is a mess - missed draft picks are part of reason 

Post#59 » by Anticon » Sat Nov 1, 2025 9:08 pm

The picks themselves were fine; it was the draft slots that caused the situation they're in.

Bad decisions from 2022-24 and bad luck in 2025. Just have to keep moving on.
YogurtProducer
RealGM
Posts: 30,762
And1: 33,430
Joined: Jul 22, 2013
Location: Saskatchewan
       

Re: Roster is a mess - missed draft picks are part of reason 

Post#60 » by YogurtProducer » Sat Nov 1, 2025 9:12 pm

Clutch0z24 wrote:Just look at what the Spurs did....Post Kawhi they kept DeRozan/Aldridge around (2 Players who are all stars in their own right but you are not winning with these 2 as your lead players) They were a hovering 32-35 win team since 2019-2022 In that time span they have drafted players like Vassell, Joshua Primo, Sochan...Sochan and Vassell are ok players but they are not going to change your franchise right...

The year they blew that mid team up and traded everyone for draft picks and actually tried to be bad their franchise changed around for the better....(If you don't try you will always lose) They got lucky and got #1 pick and drafted Victor, Castle, Harper 3 years in a row with actually tanking and being a 22 win type of team for the last 3 years...

Now they are prolly going to win a championship in the future because of it and have an exciting core to cheer for and fun to watch.

Thats what you have to do in the NBA to get good results not half ass it and try to compete with a bad team. Never works.

Okay - now do all those mid level teams who blow it up and suck for a decade.

Or those mid level teams who don’t blow it up and end up leveling up anyways.

Acting like there is only one route to relevancy is just a bad argument

Return to Toronto Raptors