Crazy-Canuck wrote:greg4012 wrote:Crazy-Canuck wrote:
Prime kg and Duncan couldn't cover 3 turnstiles up front. In the regular season, yes. But zero chance any team with more than 1 turnstile starter does anything in the playoffs. History has shown this every year the NBA has ever existed.
Mad respect for bam, but zero chance he can cover 2 bad defenders in the playoffs, let alone three. We just saw herro get targeted relentlessly and there was nothing anyone could do. Now, give the offense 2 more guys to target.
We are seeing it now in goldenstate and that's with jimmy and dray in the backline. Both Jimmy and steph have come out and said they are begging for some elite 2 way play on the perimeter, a guy who guards.
We are seeing the suns this year. Get rid of Beal/kd and add in a big wing in brooks, and magically they look good. The recipe has never changed in the playoffs.
But, if you think miami will be the first team to buck this trend, it'll be hella impressive.
2 is the line. And it works if at least one can hold water.
In 2020, Miami went to the finals with Goran Dragic and Duncan Robinson in the starting lineup all playoffs. During that playoff run, Herro was 2nd on the team in minutes played, Duncan was 5th, and Goran was 6th (due to missing most of the finals).
Norm probably edges out Goran as a defender overall imo.
I dream of the day where Miami has a lineup full of 2-way players. But, it's not as hard line as you make it out to be. Especially when you have the best defender in the world on your team.
Ill give you Duncan. But, Goran is a better defender than powell. Powell is just atrocious off ball. Hes in that herro tier. That 2020 team also had some good tough defenders though which is something this team lacks outside of bam.
Maybe im just looking too far ahead when it's just game 17 coming up.
Def looking ahead, but I enjoy assessing it.
From what I've seen from Powell in Miami, I disagree that Goran was a better defender (and I love Goran). Tools is part of it. Powell has a 6'11 wingspan and weighs 215 pounds and is just a better lateral mover. Goran had a solid 6'7 wingspan but I don't think he ever pushed 200 pounds.
We can argue eye test all day, but we can also look to some numbers for sake of comparison.
Powell is a solid onball defender and that counts for A LOT. He developed a reputation for ballwatching and losing his man when offball, but I haven't seen that pop up in Miami's scheme and under Miami's coaching much (scheme matters a ton in this highly nuanced discussion).
Powell is leading the team in deflections to date and has a higher steal percentage currently than any of Goran's in Miami.
In all of Goran's seasons with Miami, he never recorded a positive DBPM (he was -1.6 in the 2020 season referenced and -0.8 in the playoffs). Powell is at +0.8 DBPM so far this season and has never had a DBPM as low as Goran's -1.6.
Powell is currently 6th on the team in DRTG (a tricky stat to fully make sense of an individual basis) at 110.7. That DRTG is better than Miami's overall DRTG of 111.2 and is better than the DRTG of 27 teams in the NBA.
There's nothing to suggest that Powell in Miami (or for his career) is an inferior defender to 2020 Dragic. Everything suggests the opposite.
Scheme and coaching matter a ton into how a player plays off-ball defense.