ImageImageImageImageImage

Should Poeltl start over CMB when he returns?

Moderators: HiJiNX, 7 Footer, Morris_Shatford, niQ, Duffman100, tsherkin, Reeko, lebron stopper, DG88

Who should start when Poeltl returns?

Poeltl starts, bench CMB
29
46%
CMB starts, bench Poeltl
26
41%
Start both CMB & Poeltl
8
13%
 
Total votes: 63

User avatar
CPT
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 14,606
And1: 3,165
Joined: Jan 21, 2002
Location: Osaka/Seoul/Toronto
         

Re: Should Poeltl start over CMB when he returns? 

Post#21 » by CPT » Yesterday 7:05 am

I don’t particularly want to see Barnes/CMB/Poeltl on the floor together for any significant amount of time, so scrap the idea of them both starting.

I’d probably go matchup dependent, but if I had to call one the “starter,” I’d let it be Poeltl until CMB shows he’s just straight up better than healthy Poeltl (he’s more or less convinced me already).

I feel like not losing your job to injury might be one of those old school things that may no longer make sense, but for now, I think players would still respect that principle. CMB doesn’t seem like the type to lose confidence or get bent out of shape by being sent to the bench when the veteran starter returns from injury. To be fair, Poeltl would probably be fine with the decision as well.

It will be a good problem to have if/when Poeltl comes back at full strength.
Appostis
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,150
And1: 3,332
Joined: May 11, 2021
   

Re: Should Poeltl start over CMB when he returns? 

Post#22 » by Appostis » Yesterday 7:22 am

CPT wrote:I don’t particularly want to see Barnes/CMB/Poeltl on the floor together for any significant amount of time, so scrap the idea of them both starting.

I’d probably go matchup dependent, but if I had to call one the “starter,” I’d let it be Poeltl until CMB shows he’s just straight up better than healthy Poeltl (he’s more or less convinced me already).

I feel like not losing your job to injury might be one of those old school things that may no longer make sense, but for now, I think players would still respect that principle. CMB doesn’t seem like the type to lose confidence or get bent out of shape by being sent to the bench when the veteran starter returns from injury. To be fair, Poeltl would probably be fine with the decision as well.

It will be a good problem to have if/when Poeltl comes back at full strength.


If Barnes and CMBs 3point shooting holds, you'd have a lineup with 4 players with over 30% 3point shooting..
User avatar
CPT
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 14,606
And1: 3,165
Joined: Jan 21, 2002
Location: Osaka/Seoul/Toronto
         

Re: Should Poeltl start over CMB when he returns? 

Post#23 » by CPT » Yesterday 7:33 am

Appostis wrote:
CPT wrote:I don’t particularly want to see Barnes/CMB/Poeltl on the floor together for any significant amount of time, so scrap the idea of them both starting.

I’d probably go matchup dependent, but if I had to call one the “starter,” I’d let it be Poeltl until CMB shows he’s just straight up better than healthy Poeltl (he’s more or less convinced me already).

I feel like not losing your job to injury might be one of those old school things that may no longer make sense, but for now, I think players would still respect that principle. CMB doesn’t seem like the type to lose confidence or get bent out of shape by being sent to the bench when the veteran starter returns from injury. To be fair, Poeltl would probably be fine with the decision as well.

It will be a good problem to have if/when Poeltl comes back at full strength.


If Barnes and CMBs 3point shooting holds, you'd have a lineup with 4 players with over 30% 3point shooting..


Is that supposed to be good?
Appostis
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,150
And1: 3,332
Joined: May 11, 2021
   

Re: Should Poeltl start over CMB when he returns? 

Post#24 » by Appostis » Yesterday 8:51 am

CPT wrote:
Appostis wrote:
CPT wrote:I don’t particularly want to see Barnes/CMB/Poeltl on the floor together for any significant amount of time, so scrap the idea of them both starting.

I’d probably go matchup dependent, but if I had to call one the “starter,” I’d let it be Poeltl until CMB shows he’s just straight up better than healthy Poeltl (he’s more or less convinced me already).

I feel like not losing your job to injury might be one of those old school things that may no longer make sense, but for now, I think players would still respect that principle. CMB doesn’t seem like the type to lose confidence or get bent out of shape by being sent to the bench when the veteran starter returns from injury. To be fair, Poeltl would probably be fine with the decision as well.

It will be a good problem to have if/when Poeltl comes back at full strength.


If Barnes and CMBs 3point shooting holds, you'd have a lineup with 4 players with over 30% 3point shooting..


Is that supposed to be good?


Considering the defense and size of the lineup.. it's not exactly bad.
User avatar
CPT
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 14,606
And1: 3,165
Joined: Jan 21, 2002
Location: Osaka/Seoul/Toronto
         

Re: Should Poeltl start over CMB when he returns? 

Post#25 » by CPT » Yesterday 10:48 am

Appostis wrote:
CPT wrote:
Appostis wrote:
If Barnes and CMBs 3point shooting holds, you'd have a lineup with 4 players with over 30% 3point shooting..


Is that supposed to be good?


Considering the defense and size of the lineup.. it's not exactly bad.


Over 33% maybe. 30% is bad. That’s not an efficient shot, and it’s not spacing the floor because those guys won’t be shooting them.

Without checking, I would imagine most teams are at this level or better. League average is 36%. Maybe some teams fall short because they have 1-2 guys who just don’t shoot at all, but 30% is such a low bar.
Kingsway_fan
RealGM
Posts: 14,286
And1: 9,991
Joined: May 25, 2016
Location: Paris
 

Re: Should Poeltl start over CMB when he returns? 

Post#26 » by Kingsway_fan » Yesterday 1:02 pm

Has there been any update on YAK???
User avatar
HumbleRen
RealGM
Posts: 19,624
And1: 26,929
Joined: Jul 02, 2021
 

Re: Should Poeltl start over CMB when he returns? 

Post#27 » by HumbleRen » Yesterday 1:38 pm

CPT wrote:
Appostis wrote:
CPT wrote:
Is that supposed to be good?


Considering the defense and size of the lineup.. it's not exactly bad.


Over 33% maybe. 30% is bad. That’s not an efficient shot, and it’s not spacing the floor because those guys won’t be shooting them.

Without checking, I would imagine most teams are at this level or better. League average is 36%. Maybe some teams fall short because they have 1-2 guys who just don’t shoot at all, but 30% is such a low bar.


Percentage doesn’t matter. It’s all about spacing. Nobody would respect Scottie, Poeltl and CMB when it comes to spacing.

Scottie and CMB could shoot 40% from the 3 for 2 months straight and it wouldn’t change the abhorrent spacing that would provide with Poeltl at the 5.

It takes 2-3 seasons of high level shooting to change your perception around the league.
Image

sig credits to Clutch0z24
RaptorLakerJay
Pro Prospect
Posts: 805
And1: 543
Joined: Jun 25, 2012

Re: Should Poeltl start over CMB when he returns? 

Post#28 » by RaptorLakerJay » Yesterday 2:00 pm

I get why Poeltl should start but CMB absolutely needs 30+ minutes a game without a question.
User avatar
CPT
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 14,606
And1: 3,165
Joined: Jan 21, 2002
Location: Osaka/Seoul/Toronto
         

Re: Should Poeltl start over CMB when he returns? 

Post#29 » by CPT » Yesterday 2:16 pm

HumbleRen wrote:
CPT wrote:
Appostis wrote:
Considering the defense and size of the lineup.. it's not exactly bad.


Over 33% maybe. 30% is bad. That’s not an efficient shot, and it’s not spacing the floor because those guys won’t be shooting them.

Without checking, I would imagine most teams are at this level or better. League average is 36%. Maybe some teams fall short because they have 1-2 guys who just don’t shoot at all, but 30% is such a low bar.


Percentage doesn’t matter. It’s all about spacing. Nobody would respect Scottie, Poeltl and CMB when it comes to spacing.

Scottie and CMB could shoot 40% from the 3 for 2 months straight and it wouldn’t change the abhorrent spacing that would provide with Poeltl at the 5.

It takes 2-3 seasons of high level shooting to change your perception around the league.


This is also very true, I was just pointing out that having 4 guys over 30% isn’t some impressive accomplishment.
ConSarnit
Head Coach
Posts: 6,484
And1: 6,192
Joined: May 05, 2015
 

Re: Should Poeltl start over CMB when he returns? 

Post#30 » by ConSarnit » Yesterday 4:38 pm

CPT wrote:
HumbleRen wrote:
CPT wrote:
Over 33% maybe. 30% is bad. That’s not an efficient shot, and it’s not spacing the floor because those guys won’t be shooting them.

Without checking, I would imagine most teams are at this level or better. League average is 36%. Maybe some teams fall short because they have 1-2 guys who just don’t shoot at all, but 30% is such a low bar.


Percentage doesn’t matter. It’s all about spacing. Nobody would respect Scottie, Poeltl and CMB when it comes to spacing.

Scottie and CMB could shoot 40% from the 3 for 2 months straight and it wouldn’t change the abhorrent spacing that would provide with Poeltl at the 5.

It takes 2-3 seasons of high level shooting to change your perception around the league.


This is also very true, I was just pointing out that having 4 guys over 30% isn’t some impressive accomplishment.


Barnes shooting has dropped off a cliff (again):

Pre Nov. 1 (6 games): 50% 3pt

Post Nov. 1 (38 games): 28% 3pt

CMB is taking 1.9 3pa per36. That's piddling volume, even for a big.

Poeltl obviously is who he is. Throw Shead into the mix and the shooting looks bad.

Shooting is our biggest issue right now (outside of injuries).
YogurtProducer
RealGM
Posts: 32,233
And1: 34,610
Joined: Jul 22, 2013
Location: Saskatchewan
       

Re: Should Poeltl start over CMB when he returns? 

Post#31 » by YogurtProducer » Yesterday 4:44 pm

ConSarnit wrote:Shooting is our biggest issue right now (outside of injuries).

Yep. It will be a bit better once RJ is back as IQ/RJ/Ingram is a "fine" (not great) shooting 1 thru 3. Especially if IQ goes back to his 38ish% ways.

We really just need to get a 3 point gunner who teams actually fear off the bench. Battle is okay but the volume isnt there (his 3 point rate is somehow loser than Shead).
Rainman66
Rookie
Posts: 1,071
And1: 164
Joined: Jun 14, 2009
Location: GTA
   

Re: Should Poeltl start over CMB when he returns? 

Post#32 » by Rainman66 » Yesterday 4:44 pm

Start Poetl and trade for expiring Zach Collins, re-sign Mamu in offseason for mle $ or more, draft C in first round.
User avatar
Johnny Bball
RealGM
Posts: 55,743
And1: 60,402
Joined: Feb 01, 2015
 

Re: Should Poeltl start over CMB when he returns? 

Post#33 » by Johnny Bball » Yesterday 4:47 pm

Give the minutes to CMB. If he can't handle certain bigs, bring in Yak early, And pairing him with Shead makes more sense for Poeltl
User avatar
HumbleRen
RealGM
Posts: 19,624
And1: 26,929
Joined: Jul 02, 2021
 

Re: Should Poeltl start over CMB when he returns? 

Post#34 » by HumbleRen » Yesterday 4:54 pm

CPT wrote:
HumbleRen wrote:
CPT wrote:
Over 33% maybe. 30% is bad. That’s not an efficient shot, and it’s not spacing the floor because those guys won’t be shooting them.

Without checking, I would imagine most teams are at this level or better. League average is 36%. Maybe some teams fall short because they have 1-2 guys who just don’t shoot at all, but 30% is such a low bar.


Percentage doesn’t matter. It’s all about spacing. Nobody would respect Scottie, Poeltl and CMB when it comes to spacing.

Scottie and CMB could shoot 40% from the 3 for 2 months straight and it wouldn’t change the abhorrent spacing that would provide with Poeltl at the 5.

It takes 2-3 seasons of high level shooting to change your perception around the league.


This is also very true, I was just pointing out that having 4 guys over 30% isn’t some impressive accomplishment.


Nah I’m with you, my post was in support of your post.
Image

sig credits to Clutch0z24
ConSarnit
Head Coach
Posts: 6,484
And1: 6,192
Joined: May 05, 2015
 

Re: Should Poeltl start over CMB when he returns? 

Post#35 » by ConSarnit » Yesterday 5:05 pm

YogurtProducer wrote:
ConSarnit wrote:Shooting is our biggest issue right now (outside of injuries).

Yep. It will be a bit better once RJ is back as IQ/RJ/Ingram is a "fine" (not great) shooting 1 thru 3. Especially if IQ goes back to his 38ish% ways.

We really just need to get a 3 point gunner who teams actually fear off the bench. Battle is okay but the volume isnt there (his 3 point rate is somehow loser than Shead).


We really need someone who can do what Dick is supposed to do: movement shooting. We need someone who can actually cause confusion for the other team. If 4 of our 8 top rotation guys are bad shooters we need someone who is above and beyond to compensate. We don't have that guy.
TheGeneral99
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,149
And1: 6,825
Joined: Mar 11, 2023
   

Re: Should Poeltl start over CMB when he returns? 

Post#36 » by TheGeneral99 » Yesterday 5:08 pm

I am going to say no given his age and back issues.

CMB fit very well with the starters, and Poeltl's steadiness and veteran skill/IQ will be very helpful for the bench.
User avatar
LoveMyRaps
RealGM
Posts: 31,637
And1: 52,399
Joined: Jun 10, 2013
       

Re: Should Poeltl start over CMB when he returns? 

Post#37 » by LoveMyRaps » Yesterday 6:51 pm

Rainman66 wrote:Start Poetl and trade for expiring Zach Collins, re-sign Mamu in offseason for mle $ or more, draft C in first round.


I like this. Easier said than done though.

Truthfully, our top priority this deadline should be to get rid of Poeltl's contract.
In Masai We Trust :meditate:
Image
Rainman66
Rookie
Posts: 1,071
And1: 164
Joined: Jun 14, 2009
Location: GTA
   

Re: Should Poeltl start over CMB when he returns? 

Post#38 » by Rainman66 » Yesterday 7:12 pm

LoveMyRaps wrote:I like this. Easier said than done though.

Truthfully, our top priority this deadline should be to get rid of Poeltl's contract.

Right, its time to start, dump and save, Its a Poetl deadline sale!
(start Poetl, dump for expiring, save on a 12-15 mill deal for Mamu and have space to sign first rounder) ...sigh
User avatar
LoveMyRaps
RealGM
Posts: 31,637
And1: 52,399
Joined: Jun 10, 2013
       

Re: Should Poeltl start over CMB when he returns? 

Post#39 » by LoveMyRaps » Yesterday 7:15 pm

Rainman66 wrote:
LoveMyRaps wrote:I like this. Easier said than done though.

Truthfully, our top priority this deadline should be to get rid of Poeltl's contract.

Right, its time to start, dump and save, Its a Poetl deadline sale!
(start Poetl, dump for expiring, save on a 12-15 mill deal for Mamu and have space to sign first rounder) ...sigh



There's a 5% chance we can trade Poeltl right now. There's gonna be a 0% chance we can trade him next season, once the extension kicks in and his cap hit becomes 28mil AAV.
In Masai We Trust :meditate:
Image
Rainman66
Rookie
Posts: 1,071
And1: 164
Joined: Jun 14, 2009
Location: GTA
   

Re: Should Poeltl start over CMB when he returns? 

Post#40 » by Rainman66 » Yesterday 7:29 pm

LoveMyRaps wrote:There's a 5% chance we can trade Poeltl right now. There's gonna be a 0% chance we can trade him next season, once the extension kicks in and his cap hit becomes 28mil AAV.

:noway: talk about shooting yourself in your own foot. FO needs to find a way to get things done I guess, can't let Mamu walk for nothing.

Return to Toronto Raptors