peZt wrote:King Ken wrote:sisibilio wrote:Talented at what? Certainly It can't be at the game of basketball.
It's quite a lot. I can break down where he's more talented. Thabeet not working in the NBA is all on Thabeet. He just didn't want it. Once he got that check, he was gone.
There is literally just one thing Thabeet is more "talented" at: Jumping higher
Quickness (Thabeet)
- Thabeet: Real burst for a 7-3 player
- Mara: Slow but moves well, no upshift
Full Court Speed (Thabeet)
- Thabeet: Beats guards in transition, runs with the play
- Mara: Last man down the floor, slow to build momentum
Lateral Movement for Size (Thabeet)
- Thabeet: Can switch and guard out to the 3-point line
- Mara: Exposed in space, no recovery quickness
Explosiveness (Thabeet)
- Thabeet: Off the floor in a flash, elite vertical for size
- Mara: Ground-bound in games despite a clean 33-inch max at BWB. Today, his max vert was 28 inches.
Athleticism (Thabeet)
- Thabeet: Rare size, speed, and bounce combination
- Mara: Below NBA-average for the position
Body Type for Position (Thabeet)
- Thabeet: Functional 7-3 frame with room to add mass
- Mara: Narrow shoulders, no base, weak legs, wrong frame for the 5
Acceleration & Deceleration (Thabeet)
- Thabeet: Has real gears for a 7-footer
- Mara: One speed, no pace change
Fluidity (Mara)
- Thabeet: Mechanical, jerky, robotic in his movement
- Mara: Smooth and coordinated, moves like a European multi-sport athlete
Finishing (Mara)
- Thabeet: Lob and putback dependent, limited touch
- Mara: 67% from the floor, NBA-level efficiency at the rim
Feel for the Game (Mara)
- Thabeet: Still learning, raw instincts
- Mara: Plays within himself, mature reads, always in the right spot
BBIQ (Mara)
- Thabeet: Coachable but processing slowly
- Mara: High-level processing on both ends
Paint Protection / Rim Protection (both)
- Thabeet: 4.5 bpg, elite anchor, mobile rim deterrent
- Mara: 2.6 bpg, smart and positional, length over leap
Passing (Mara)
- Thabeet: Solid outlets, limited beyond that
- Mara: 2.5 apg, real high-post facilitator, short-roll reads
Shooting- Thabeet: 12-15 footers in the offense, soft stroke, projectable
- Mara: Open gym sniper but the form collapses in motion. Classic Josh Smith / Zac Risacher problem. 15 mechanical things going on in the jumper that only surface once he's moving in game flow
Hands (tied)
- Thabeet: Soft, reliable, rarely bobbles
- Mara: Soft, reliable, NBA-grade catch radius
Free Throw- Thabeet: 63% with good form, projectable to mid-70s
- Mara: 56.4%, real concern with no clear fix
Post Game (both limited)
- Thabeet: Raw, no go-to move, puts ball on the floor
- Mara: Gets moved off the block, no anchor base
Self-Creation- Thabeet: None
- Mara: None
P&R Defense- Thabeet: Tools to recover but got tangled in college
- Mara: Drop coverage only, no flexibility
Switchability- Thabeet: Rare switch ability for 7-3
- Mara: None, scheme-dependent
Rebounding- Thabeet: Above average on the defensive glass, real nose for the ball
- Mara: 6.8 rpg, positional, can't box out NBA bodies
Toughness & Anchoring- Thabeet: Question mark, hits the floor too much
- Mara: Willing but structurally outmatched
Big Game Performance- Thabeet: Helpless vs DeJuan Blair, failed the NBA-body test
- Mara: 26/9/3/2 vs Arizona in the Final Four
Conference Hardware- Thabeet: Big East DPOY
- Mara: Big Ten DPOY
Background- Thabeet: Late starter, raw, age uncertain
- Mara: Multi-sport European pro base, more developed feel
Offensive Role at Next Level- Thabeet: Athletic lob threat and rim runner
- Mara: PnR vertical roller with short-roll passing, almost entirely scheme-fed
Motivation & Love for the Game- Thabeet: Memphis teammates confirmed the talent was real. He got the check and mailed it in. The love wasn't there
- Mara: European pro system, professional demeanor, Final Four engagement. The work and the want look real
NBA Archetype- Thabeet: Tools bet, athletic anchor projection
- Mara: PnR-dependent backup 5 with feel and low stamina
Translation Risk- Thabeet: Talent was NBA-ready. Heart wasn't. Career was a motivation failure dressed up as a skill ceiling
- Mara: Frame caps the ceiling, scheme misfit kills the floor. But the motor and the want should keep him on the floor wherever he lands