You'll notice that I didn't mention his block rate at all. If anyone's fixating on it, it's you not me. But since you brought it up, Dybantsa got fewer blocks than both of those guys despite being a whole lot taller than either of them. He also got very few steals if you're rating him as a perimeter player, and not a ton of rebounds to make up for deficiencies there. He rebounded more like a guard than a guy who's 6'10" and super athletic. Barnes also had a great steal rate and Williams had a solid one, including a great one his freshman season if we're comparing like to like.JMAC3 wrote:AJ is going to play the 3, it is much easier to hide him on players and he is more switchable defender than a lumbering big. AJ also won't really be counted on to defend the rim, if you are projecting as a 4/5 like Boozer rim protection is more of a needed skill.
Scottie Barnes had 11 blocks in college.
Jalen Williams had 17,11 and 18 his three seasons.
Yet everyone is going to fixate on Dybantsa block numbers this year when in the past we didn't care at all for other players. Remember when CJ Stroud S2 score was all that was talked about? It hasn't been mentioned before or after for any other draft class. People latch onto something and assign it value but there is no consistency to why it matters from year to year.
Again with these excuses. Plenty of other guys played defense without fouling in college, Dybantsa just did the "not fouling" part and forgot about the defense. Boozer also was a one-man offense who Duke couldn't go without, yet somehow he managed to get a lot more steals, more blocks, and a lot more rebounds than AJ (don't interpret this as me saying Boozer is going to be a great defender, because I'm not). And I'll reiterate, when BYU had it's full team in the first half of the year, and was therefore less reliant on Dybantsa to do everything on offense, he still wasn't playing good defense. And again, in high school AJ was also not known for his defense either.JMAC3 wrote:Barnes and Williams are all defensive players in NBA. Playing defense without fouling is all that really matters in terms of winning games, Dybantsa being on the floor for 35 minutes is more valuable to BYU then him having two blocks but playing 29 mins with a bunch of fouls. It is the same with Acuff, both their teams needed their offense more then they needed an extra stock per game.

If it was just BYU telling him not to foul, what was the issue before college exactly? 130 games played, 1.3 steals, .5 blocks, 6.6 rebounds, about the same as his college stats. He's just not doing much on that end of the court. He's a good prospect because of what he can do with the ball in his hands, and not what he's doing without it.
























