AROD'S Value

[Dark Star]

20 team league....heres my team

Ryan Doumit
(Pit - C,OF) COFUtilBN
1B Carlos Pena
(TB - 1B) 1BUtilBN
2B Tadahito Iguchi
(SD - 2B) 2BUtilBN
3B Alex Rodriguez
(NYY - 3B) 3BUtilBN
SS Derek Jeter
(NYY - SS) SSUtilBN
OF Manny Ramirez
(Bos - OF) OFUtilBN
OF Bill Hall
(Mil - OF) OFUtilBN
OF Josh Willingham
(Fla - OF) OFUtilBN
Util Orlando Cabrera
(CWS - SS) SSUtilBN
Util Chris Duncan
(StL - 1B,OF) 1BOFUtilBN
BN Jayson Nix
(Col - 2B) 2BUtilBN
BN Luke Scott
(Bal - OF) OFUtilBN
BN Maicer Izturis
(LAA - 2B,3B) 2B3BUtilBN
BN Ryan Spilborghs
(Col - OF) OFUtilBN
BN Nate McLouth
(Pit - OF) OFUtilBN

lookin at moving arod and willingham for holliday and beltre

cant seem to pull the trigger but i want to---i think holliday could be better than arod by himself and beltre fills 3b---any thoughts or better moves come to mind----thanks to all

[Dark Star]

anyone?

[Griff83]

anyone?

id possible make that trade on the basis that Beltre is going to have a huge year and greatly outproduce Willingham.

[Dark Star]

20 teams though--depth is big---what about holliday anyone think he can match/beat arod---or come pretty close---he was better than arod in 06 and hes not gonna get worse---or am i a tard

[OldNo7]

Arod is the clear cut #1 guy, while Holliday is a top 10. There isnt a huge difference. Holliday will hit for higher avg, Arod will hit 10 more HR and get you more runs and RBI because of the stronger lineup.

[Basketball Jesus]

That trade makes absolutely no sense.

[Dark Star]

That trade makes absolutely no sense.

so you dont think that beltre will make up the difference or even make my team better?

[Basketball Jesus]

No. Not at all. Right now Beltre has a slight edge over Willingham in terms of fantasy value and that

[Dark Star]

cool thanks---ive been very confused with this one