JustMoe wrote:
People like SDU, who always kept defending Boris, have good reason to mock us now, but those who kept silent or even joined the bunch a back then shouldn't start coming up with "See, I told you so" stuff now - just my opinion.
i was always more tolerant and defending of diaw than most
i totally understand why people get frustrated with him, i did and do too, i just stick up for him because deep down i believe that we CAN get enough out him to be a good contributor to a title
i also believe that his contract is not his fault, he played as best he could when we needed him, then WE chose to change his role when amare came back, then WE chose to diminish his role when we signed grant hill
if this team had no amare and no hill, just like we didnt in the season where diaw was MIP, then i have NO DOUBT he would be putting up the same numbers. This theory is backed by the numbers he has put up as a starter this year also
the biggest issue is his contract, which now does look to be overpaid, but this isnt his fault. We asked him to do everything, he did it, then we paid him, then we reduced his role
BUT had we not paid him long term, then reduced his role, he may have walked the next offseason because playing with amare was "stifling" him and he could be putting up 14 5 and 5 with another team and we would hate losing him.
the front office reacted, and they took a pro active move that has proven to be incorrect, but it wasnt one that couldnt have been seen with amare coming back, but as mentioned, if they didnt sign him then, they may have lost him, so i understand the contract we offered, it just didnt work in our favour this time. Barbosas does, proving you win some you lose some
i dont blame diaw as much as others for diaws faults, i think he is the sort of guy that needs a clearly defined role to contribute, one that he is struggling in with amare and hill in our team
look what happens when he starts - thats the diaw i know he can be
IMO, when hill retires next offseason after our back to back championship, diaw will become a starter at SF or PF, nash may be gone, and we will really see diaw grow into his own at that point where he will be even better than 04-05
just my thoughts