Paul and West or Deron and Boozer

[IggyTheBEaST]

Tough one.

[xAIRNESSx]

I think Boozer has a bigger advantage over West than Paul has over Deron, so I take D-Will and Booze.

[Gerald3Wallace]

agreed with Airness

paul is beter than deron

but the gap bewtween booz over west is bigger..

so id take deron and booz

[sca]

Deron & Boozer

[WesWesley]

I'd go with Paul and West, just because Paul is so much better than everyone else.

[farzi]

Paul and west because of paul.

[risktaker91]

Deron and Boozer.

[hermes]

deron and boozer
because of boozer

[667Club]

Deron and Paul are equal and Boozer is better than West. Utah beats No if they meet in the playoffs.

[That Nicka]

I think Boozer has a bigger advantage over West than Paul has over Deron, so I take D-Will and Booze.

[AgEnT50]

agreed with Airness

paul is beter than deron

but the gap bewtween booz over west is bigger..

so id take deron and booz

x2

[Hard2dhole]

Considering the responses given i would have expected the poll to be a runaway win for Boozer - Dwill.
Overall Paul has out played Dwill but head to head Deron owns Paul. I say that's this is makes this match up too close to call.
Boozer and West is an easy call Boozer.
So the Utah duo is my pick.

[ITK9]

I think Boozer has a bigger advantage over West than Paul has over Deron, so I take D-Will and Booze.

+1

[Monkeyfeng06]

boozer over west and deron pwns paul when playing 1v1.

deron and boozer for sure.

[Teddy KGB]

I would take Paul and West because I think that Chris Paul will go down as the greatest Point Guard to ever play the game.

[Icefire10304]

Deron and Boozer.

[Optimism Prime]

Considering the responses given i would have expected the poll to be a runaway win for Boozer - Dwill.
Overall Paul has out played Dwill but head to head Deron owns Paul. I say that's this is makes this match up too close to call.
Boozer and West is an easy call Boozer.
So the Utah duo is my pick.

I don't understand that argument.

If Paul is better against 28 teams than Deron is, but Deron's better against Paul... how is that in any way, shape, or form, "too close to call"? They play head-to-head far LESS often than they play other teams. Wouldn't you want the point guard who's putting up better numbers overall? It's like saying, "Oh, well, Team X beat Team Y, so even though Team Y has a higher seed... Team X is better." The whole head-to-head argument is poorly constructed, misleading, and seems nothing more than a justification to pick Deron over Paul.

That said, back on topic...

I agree with others; the gap between Boozer and West is far greater than that between Paul and Williams.

On 29 teams, I think that Boozer/Paul would be the best combo, but I've always felt that Deron was more of a "Sloan Player" than was Paul--which is why, even though I think Paul's a better player, Deron was the right draft choice.

[Nolan]

I'll take Paul and West. Paul has been amazing this year and West is the most underrated player in the league.

[kookie_819]

I would take Paul and West because I think that Chris Paul will go down as the greatest Point Guard to ever play the game.

But Deron>Paul head to head, so Deron > All.