bebopdeluxe wrote:I would do Fitz for Lito and Reggie in a HEARTBEAT.
Since I would do Fitz for Lito and our 1st round pick, I would definitely do it for Lito and Reggie. Brown is a nice WR, but if I had to choose between giving up our #1 pick and trading Brown, I would trade Brown. We still need help and depth on defense (especially with letting Spikes go), and having our pick at 19 allows us to add another impact body there.
With Fitz, Westbrook, Curtis and - hopefully - a healthy LJ, we will have lots of weapons on offense....and I think Avant or Baskett can do enough as a 3rd WR so we'll be OK. We could even add another WR after trading Brown (we could sign D.J. Hackett or Bryant Johnson, or trade for somebody like Holt - who wouldn't cost us our #1 pick), and still keep our top picks in next month's draft.
hackett and johnson are not as good as brown. in your scenario, the eagles are taking one step forward and like...a step and a half back. it's self-defeating.
you're saying that maybe baskett and avant can do enough...maybe we'll be okay. and then you're suggesting that maybe we can sign one of the awful WRs still available.
what's the point? we already have reggie brown to underproduce. why spend $30 million over 4 years to get even less production from hackett or johnson?
lito and a pick makes the most sense. my feeling is that if a trade does happen, the eagles are going to have the upper hand. everything i've heard is pointing to the cardinals not being able to get anything done with fitzgerald and if they can't get anything done, they really can't demand anything ridiculous for him because they're going to have trouble fielding a team with his $16 mil against the cap this season. i think that assuming the eagles can get fitzgerald, people are going to be delightfully surprised at how relatively little they'll have to give up. they're playing it perfectly. let them keep negotiating and let them keep getting further and further from a deal and let the available free agents that the cardinals can sign keep dwindling. eventually they'll have to make a move. and that plays right into the eagles hands, if we're to assume they are actually targeting fitzgerald.
but anyway, i think trading lito and the eagles number 1/2 WR for a WR is a bad idea.