Another one. Arenas or McGrady?

[Alex_De_Large]

Who have done more in the NBA?

[Alex_De_Large]

Playmaking: Tmac
Rebounder: Tmac
Defense: Tmac
Shoter: Tmac
Clutch: Arenas

[nate33]

Playmaking: Tmac
Rebounder: Tmac
Defense: Tmac
Shoter: Tmac
Clutch: Arenas

You gotta be kidding me.

Do you honestly think TMac is a better shooter than Arenas?

[nate33]

To answer your question, TMac has done more in the NBA since he has played 11 seasons. Arenas has played just 6 (ignoring this year).

Arenas has been the better player in his last 3 full seasons though.

[Alex_De_Large]

talking about shoting, heres the percentage

this season 0,439 mcgrady and 0,390 arenas scoring 22 points game.
overall of all seasons 0,439 and 0,427 also scoring 22 for game.

How is arenas the better shoter? he is better in last minutes and thats why he is the most clutch player in the nba along with baron and kobe.

[Teddy KGB]

Arenas is a better shooter if you look at last year rather than this year when he's played all of 8 games

[nate33]

talking about shoting, heres the percentage

this season 0,439 mcgrady and 0,390 arenas scoring 22 points game.
overall of all seasons 0,439 and 0,427 also scoring 22 for game.

How is arenas the better shoter? he is better in last minutes and thats why he is the most clutch player in the nba along with baron and kobe.

Pace-adjusted per-40 numbers for each player over the last 3 seasons:

Code: Select all

mcgrady,t  PTS  REB  AST  STL  BLK   TO eFG%  TS%  PER
2007-08   24.1  5.5  6.3  1.3  0.6  2.8 .473 .506 19.3
2006-07   28.0  6.1  7.4  1.5  0.6  3.4 .474 .515 23.2
2005-06   27.6  7.4  5.4  1.4  1.0  2.9 .442 .494 21.9

arenas,gi  PTS  REB  AST  STL  BLK   TO eFG%  TS%  PER
2006-07   28.2  4.5  5.9  1.9  0.2  3.2 .484 .565 24.1
2005-06   27.9  3.3  5.7  1.9  0.3  3.5 .507 .581 23.9
2004-05   24.8  4.6  5.0  1.7  0.3  2.9 .498 .565 21.4

Arenas has averaged more points per minute with a higher eFG% and a dramatically higher TS%.

[Donkey McDonkerton]

ARINAS...hahah

[Baller 24]

Id take Tmac overall, because I mean he is the better player, but Arenas is the better shooter by a large margin.

[Teddy KGB]

wow hadn't realised just how sick arenas was...

[TheKingOfVa360]

Playmaking: Arenas
Rebounder: Toss up-Both are good rebounders
Defense: Tmac
Shooter: Arenas
Clutch: Arenas
Eyes:Arenas
Back:Arenas

[nyu3]

Prime T-Mac > Prime Arenas
T-Mac also accomplished more.

However, Arenas has been better last couple of seasons. T-Mac is changing his game and could be the better overall player again.

[Flash3]

-= original quote snipped =-


You gotta be kidding me.

Do you honestly think TMac is a better shooter than Arenas?

Shoter, not Shooter.

T-Mac is a better shoter than Areans, bar none.

[TheKingOfVa360]

NYU Arenas hasn't reached his prime yet! That's what you guys fail to understand.

[Teddy KGB]

-= original quote snipped =-

Shoter, not Shooter.

T-Mac is a better shoter than Areans, bar none.

Oh, the irony!

[Donkey McDonkerton]

-= original quote snipped =-



Oh, the irony!

It wasn't him, he was just making fun of the OP....

[Teddy KGB]

I know. The irony is that he made fun of the OP's spelling and then spelled Arenas wrong

[Donkey McDonkerton]

I know. The irony is that he made fun of the OP's spelling and then spelled Arenas wrong

sorry, gotcha.

[magicfan4life05]

too much ironing

[J-Mezzy]

Prime McGrady was compared to Jordan and Kobe. Pime McGrady had one of the best statistical seasons of all time. Prime McGrady was a top 5 player. McGrady has been a among top 5 vote gettes for MVP multiple times. McGrady is the easy choice over Arenas. The only thing Arenas has on him is one playoffs series win over a young and inexperienced Bulls team.