Rank These 12 All Stars

[Kush]

1. TMAC
2.Bosh
3.Deron William
4. Carmelo
5. Amare
6.Gilbert Arenas
7.Boozer
8. Allan Iverson
9.Baron Davis
10.Paul Pierce
11.Elton Brand
12. Manu Ginobili

[etopn23]

-= original quote snipped =-



Coming from the kid who has Manu dead last. Your credibility is lost.

Dunno. You put Elton Brand second on your list?

[j3yuen]

we can't assume that everyone is 100% healthy because T-mac has never been 100% healthy..
A healthy T-mac is an oxymoron...
A healthy T-mac would be better than kobe... A healthy tmac may even be better than jordan lol

[tracey_nice]

-= original quote snipped =-



Fixed, just for you.

I forgot good list thanks for the correction.

[penbeast0]

we can't assume that everyone is 100% healthy because T-mac has never been 100% healthy..
A healthy T-mac is an oxymoron...
A healthy T-mac would be better than kobe... A healthy tmac may even be better than jordan lol

Actually, there have been years/stretches where he was healthy, he's just never had the consistent focus of a Jordan, or even Kobe. That's one explanation of the Yaoless win streak phenomenon. It wakes Tracy up and gives him that consistent fire that he otherwise doesn't always have.

[Dirk_diggler_41]

The fact that McGrady has lead his team to a top 4 seed in the West without Yao 2 seasons in a row should automatically make him more important than all of these other players.

Yao missed this entire season? Fact is T-Mac, up to this point, has missed more games than Yao.

[etopn23]

-= original quote snipped =-



Yao missed this entire season? Fact is T-Mac, up to this point, has missed more games than Yao.

Look at the Rockets record with Yao as compared to with T-Mac. It's obvious that the team does better when he's on the court. FYI - Yao will have missed more games than McGrady this season, and has missed more games over the last 3 seasons than McGrady has.

As far as importance to his team, he should be #1 far and away. It's like watching two different teams when he isn't on the court - 1 a playoff team, 1 a lottery bound team.

[jeff1624]

1. T-mac
2. Brand(Underrated)
3. Amare
4. Carmelo
5. Iverson
6. Arenas
7. Deron
8. Pierce
9. Boozer
10. Davis
11. Bosh
12. Ginobili

[TAI8]

Carmelo Anthony
Gilbert Arenas
Elton Brand
Carlos Boozer
Chris Bosh
Baron Davis
Manu Ginobili
Allen Iverson
Tracy McGrady
Paul Pierce
Amare Stoudemire
Deron Williams


Assume all players are 100% healthy

1. Gilbert Arenas
2. Tracy McGrady
3. Paul Pierce
4. Elton Brand
5. Carlos Boozer
6. Allen Iverson
7. Amare Stoudemire
8. Chris Bosh
9. Baron Davis
10. Manu Ginobili
11. Deron Williams
12. Carmelo Anthony

[WesWesley]

Carlos Boozer
Chris Bosh
Amare Stoudamire
Paul Pierce
Carmelo Anthony
Tracy McGrady
Deron Williams
Elton Brand
Manu Ginobli
Allen Iverson
Baron Davis
Gilbert Arenas

In terms of importance to their respective teams.

Sorry Kosta, this list is flawed.

Firstly, TMAC would have to be at the top of the list. He's proven his value to the Rockets this season, I think that's safe to say.

Secondly, Manu is the 6th man on the Spurs. That would have to put him at the bottom of the list, in terms of importance to their respective teams.

This is not taking anything away from Manu as a player, but he's not as important to the Spurs as Baron Davis is to the Warriors.

[GreenMachine 22]

1. Baron Davis
2. Deron Williams
3. Amare Stoudemire
4. Tracy McGrady
5. Gilbert Arenas
6. Paul Pierce
7. Carmelo Anthony
8. Allen Iverson
9. Carlos Boozer
10. Chris Bosh
11. Elton Brand
12. Manu Ginobli

[Scalabrine]

1. Carmello Anthony
2. Tracy McGrady (when healthy hes deadly)
3. Baron Davis
4. Paul Pierce
5. Gilbert Arenas
6. Elton Brand
7. Allen Iverson
8. Amare Stoudamire
9. Manu Ginobli
10. Carlos Boozer
11. Chris Bosh
12. Deron Williams

[positivetension]

I forgot good list thanks for the correction.

Clearly Zori the dart is number one.

[The_Believer]

I think that Baron and TMac when healthy and motivated are a step above all others here. Then AI is next, and the worst here is clearly Amare.

And just b/c he made the ASG this year over many of the guys here, I will say that Roy is much worse than any of these players.