Paul & West; Deron & Boozer; Nash & Amare, FIGHT

[Scatocephalus]

The best PG in the league and West.

Williams and West on different teams. This isn't an option.

[Franchise_411]

First I'd have to rank both positions:

PG: 1) Paul, 2) Nash, 3) Deron
PF: 1) Stoudemire, 2) West, 3) Boozer

So that eliminates the Jazz duo ... Paul and Nash is pretty close ... But I give the edge to Stoudemire over West, there's more of a gap between those two ... so collectively, I'd take Nash and Stoudemire ...

Just hope no Raptors fans get on this ... they'd say Calderon and Bosh

[Kobay]

AMare is beast. He has been reduced to flopper now because of Dantoni but when he wasn't flopping people would bounce off of him and he would still be standing tall.

[CBS7]

-= original quote snipped =-



Williams and West on different teams. This isn't an option.

Still not convinced Paul is better then Deron?

First I'd have to rank both positions:

PG: 1) Paul, 2) Nash, 3) Deron
PF: 1) Stoudemire, 2) West, 3) Boozer

So that eliminates the Jazz duo ... Paul and Nash is pretty close ... But I give the edge to Stoudemire over West, there's more of a gap between those two ... so collectively, I'd take Nash and Stoudemire ...

Just hope no Raptors fans get on this ... they'd say Calderon and Bosh

Boozer is easily better then West. Scores more, rebounds more, is way more efficient, has better assist numbers, all in less minutes.

[CBS7]

Anyways I take Nash/Amare for now. Nash is still a top 3 PG and Amare is the best of the bigs mentioned.

[ponder276]

First I'd have to rank both positions:

PG: 1) Paul, 2) Nash, 3) Deron
PF: 1) Stoudemire, 2) West, 3) Boozer

So that eliminates the Jazz duo ... Paul and Nash is pretty close ... But I give the edge to Stoudemire over West, there's more of a gap between those two ... so collectively, I'd take Nash and Stoudemire ...

Just hope no Raptors fans get on this ... they'd say Calderon and Bosh

West over Boozer? You either don't watch these guys play, or you just have a hate on for the Jazz.

[TheSheriff]

Billups and Sheed would be pretty good in a fight imo.

[Franchise_411]

-= original quote snipped =-


West over Boozer? You either don't watch these guys play, or you just have a hate on for the Jazz.

Jazz fan? ... To be honest I couldn't decide between the two and actually I'm not a fan of either West or Boozer ...

[ponder276]

-= original quote snipped =-



Jazz fan? ... To be honest I couldn't decide between the two and actually I'm not a fan of either West or Boozer ...

Raps fan (and no, I don't think Bosh + Calderon compares to any of these PG/PF combos ). I just don't see how you can put West ahead of Boozer. Boozer is a much better post player, a better rebounder, plays the pick and roll about as well as anyone in the league, and even though his jumper looks weird, it's just as effective as West's. Maybe West is a slightly better defender, but I haven't paid enough attention to either player on the defensive end to really have a strong opinion there - they look comparable on D from what I've seen.

[CBS7]

^Just what i said. Boozer plays less but has higher scoring, rebounding, and assist numbers.

[og15]

Boozers only problem this seasons has been fouling people line a machine lol. Yea, Boozer is better than West, West is a better defender I'd say (not that he's amazing there or anything), and a better shooter, but like mentioned, Boozer does everything else better.

I'd go with Amare and Nash. Amare is above the other two PF's more than the PG's are above Nash.