Where Does Maggette Rank with Top SF's

magicfan4life05 · Post #1 » by **magicfan4life05** » Sun Apr 6, 2008 3:33 pm

Where does he rank when compared to other small forwards in the league?

Post #2 » by **dockingsched** » Sun Apr 6, 2008 3:40 pm

i think he's below these:

james, melo, howard, pierce, g. wallace, deng, granger, gay, marion, jefferson, sjax, hedo or lewis, artest, butler, prince

there are others i might put ahead of him like battier but i think magz is around top 16-20, depending on who is considered a sf.

Baller 24 · Post #3 » by **Baller 24** » Sun Apr 6, 2008 3:41 pm

Top 10 for sure, but where in the top 10 is hard to figure out because he isn't really a known "winner". But he is a really good athlete, he knows how to slash, has a nice mid range jumper, and his defense isn't bad at all. It was sort of a waste to see him the past 6-7 years in LA and not winning.

Post #4 » by **dockingsched** » Sun Apr 6, 2008 3:53 pm

in semi particular order

1. lebron james
2. carmelo anthony
3. caron butler
4. paul pierce
5. shawn marion
6. gerald wallace
7. josh howard
8. ron artest
9. richard jefferson
10. .............

corey would have to be number ten, but i personally wouldn't put him ahead of gay, prince, granger, sjax, hedo or lewis. there is no way that he is top ten FOR SURE.

Scalabrine · Post #5 » by **Scalabrine** » Sun Apr 6, 2008 4:08 pm

The SF position is the most stacked position in the league so...
1. James
2. Anthony
3. Butler
4. Pierce
5. Wallace
6. Marion
7. Howard
8. JAckson
9. Artest
10. Turk
11. RJ
12. Deng
13. Maggette
14. Granger
15. Prince

thats my top 15, he is anwhere between 12 and 15 this season.

Baller 24 · Post #6 » by **Baller 24** » Sun Apr 6, 2008 4:28 pm

dcash4 wrote:in semi particular order

1. lebron james
2. carmelo anthony
3. caron butler
4. paul pierce
5. shawn marion
6. gerald wallace
7. josh howard
8. ron artest
9. richard jefferson
10. .............

corey would have to be number ten, but i personally wouldn't put him ahead of gay, prince, granger, sjax, hedo or lewis. there is no way that he is top ten FOR SURE.

Lol I guess I may have contradicted the NBA SFs, and how good they are.

Post #7 » by **gswhoops** » Sun Apr 6, 2008 6:22 pm

Somewhere between 15-20. He's a good player, but there are soooo many good SFs in the league.

Post #8 » by **TrueLAfan** » Sun Apr 6, 2008 7:18 pm

He's a good player. He's not as good as his numbers. Right now, he's making $7.85 million. That's probably more or less what he's worth. He declined a 3 year $25.5 milion extension...and that's a pretty fair offer. Somebody may offer him more than that, and he'll leave L.A. It will be a mistake for the other team.

I'm saying all of this as a Clipper fan. Corey has a low basketball IQ. He's a hard worker and a high efficiency player. But he's not as effective as the numbers say. And he's had some injury issues...we are tlaking about a guy who has been a starter for 7 tyears, and has played over 2400 minutes three times in that period...and never over 2700 minutes in a season. In the last seven years, he's missed close to a quarter of the Clippers' games. That's a lot.

When he's healthy, he;'s probnably a slightly above average starting SF. With the injury issues, he's probably right near the league average. I figure that average starting SF salary in the league is probably around $7.5 million. He's a good player; better on paper, though.

Post #9 » by **TMACFORMVP** » Sun Apr 6, 2008 7:53 pm

I would say around the 15-20 range. Not really a hit at him either since SF is arguably the most stacked position in the league.

Tha King · Post #10 » by **Tha King** » Sun Apr 6, 2008 11:22 pm

Scalabrine wrote:The SF position is the most stacked position in the league so...
1. James
2. Anthony
3. Butler
4. Pierce
5. Wallace
6. Marion
7. Howard
8. JAckson
9. Artest
10. Turk
11. RJ
12. Deng
13. Maggette
14. Granger
15. Prince

thats my top 15, he is anwhere between 12 and 15 this season.

Is that in order? If so How is Wallace ahead of Howard? Howard scores more (as a second option), shoots better (from the line, field, and 3), and rebounds more (on a better rebounding team). Has the higher per, and higher per differential. He also plays less minutes and is on a championship level squad.

Wallace is the better weakside defender, while Howard is the better man to man defender.

youngcrev · Post #11 » by **youngcrev** » Mon Apr 7, 2008 12:11 am

Where is Iguodala on these lists?

Texas Longhorns · Post #12 » by **Texas Longhorns** » Mon Apr 7, 2008 12:26 am

^ Iguodala is considered a SG, and I think Maggette is a top 15 SF for sure.

Post #13 » by **TheOUTLAW** » Mon Apr 7, 2008 12:55 am

TrueLAfan wrote:He's a good player. He's not as good as his numbers. Right now, he's making $7.85 million. That's probably more or less what he's worth. He declined a 3 year $25.5 milion extension...and that's a pretty fair offer. Somebody may offer him more than that, and he'll leave L.A. It will be a mistake for the other team.

I'm saying all of this as a Clipper fan. Corey has a low basketball IQ. He's a hard worker and a high efficiency player. But he's not as effective as the numbers say. And he's had some injury issues...we are tlaking about a guy who has been a starter for 7 tyears, and has played over 2400 minutes three times in that period...and never over 2700 minutes in a season. In the last seven years, he's missed close to a quarter of the Clippers' games. That's a lot.

When he's healthy, he;'s probnably a slightly above average starting SF. With the injury issues, he's probably right near the league average. I figure that average starting SF salary in the league is probably around $7.5 million. He's a good player; better on paper, though.

This is one of the best analyses of his game that I've seen. He's good but not as good as his numbers say.