And, yes, I just looked at wikipedia and found out about logical fallacies.
You know the green font is supposed to be saved for sarcasm, right?
Of course most people know that there were a handful of swings you could've plugged into that team and still won rings.
You're stating a hypothetical as if it was factual knowledge.
But he's never seperated himself as other historical "best of the era"s have.
Clearly he has for their to be such a consensus of his status as "best of the era". Players including Dirk, T-Mac and Lebron say so, coaching polls say so... He's the only perimeter player to be on both the ALL NBA first team and ALL D first team in years not to mention leading the league in scoring at the same time....
You're just turning a blind eye to that separation (hence that weak offense vs defense argument) because he hasn't taken aim at the box score as his ultimate goal. Your box score separation argument does not hold water.