HeatSince88 wrote:So we should emulate a team that finished 40-42 in the Leastern Conference? Not actual contenders and title-winners? Wow.
Besides, that's still a better shooting team than Rose/Wade/Marion/Haslem.
Not that that was meant to be my point but:
Rose will shoot better 8.8%
Wade shot 0.1% better than Willie Green
Marion shot 1% better than Igoudala
Reggie Evans was actually the starter most of the season and has no shot whatsoever
So they aren't a better shooting team. My point was 3 point shooting is not as big a PG factor as you are making it. Philly, who has a far less capable star in Igoudala than we have in Wade, and no outside shooters of any note, got to the playoffs with possibly the worst three point shooting PG in the entire history of the NBA.
The end game is obviously not a 40 win record, but being a playoff team next season would be amazing progress from being the worst team in the league.
HeatSince88 wrote:What people are saying is you have to have BALANCE. A Wade/Rose backcourt, especially with Marion at SF, is in no way balanced. No shooting, no post presence. Just drive-and-kick guys who have no one to kick to.
Again, nobody's saying "be like Toronto and just launch jumpers all day." We're saying be like the ...
- LAKERS who have a post presence (Gasol), a penetrator (Kobe), and shooters surrounding them to spread the floor (Fisher, Vujacic, Farmar, Vlad, Walton)
- HORNETS who have a penetrator (Paul), a post presence (West), and shooters surrounding them spread the floor (Peja, Mo Pete, Pargo, Mike James)
- SPURS who have a post presence (Duncan), a penetrator (Parker, Ginobli), and shooters surrounding them to sperad the floor (each other, Bowen, Finley, Udoka, Barry, Horry)
- SUNS who have a post presence (Stoudamire), a penetrator (Nash), and shooters around them to spread the floor (Bell, Barbosa, Giricek)
- JAZZ who have a post presence (Boozer), a penetrator (Williams), and shooters around them to spread the floor (Korver, Okur, Kirilenko, Miles)
- CELTICS who have a post presence (Garnett), a penetrator (Rondo or sometimes Pierce/Allen), and shooters around them to spread the floor (Allen, Pierce, Posey, House, Cassell)
- PISTONS who have a post presence (Rasheed/Tayshaun), a penetrator (Billups), and shooters around them to spread the floor (Billups/Hamilton/Tayshaun/Sheed all top notch shooters)
I could go on and on obviously. The point is, no one is saying "let's build the Toronto Raptors" ... LOL. We're saying let's build the Lakers, Spurs, Jazz, Hornets, etc. To me, that makes much more sense than mimicking the 76ers.
We have our supreme penetrator. Now he needs his post presence and his defenders/shooters to spread the floor, just like all the contenders have.
You're making it sound like we can build a contending team in one draft move or one season. Clearly we need a post presence, clearly we need shooters. I wasn't as sold on Beasley as being a bonafide PF that can dominate in the post as I think Rose can be a top notch PG who can dominate other PG's. It's all well and good to say 'let's build to be like the Lakers/Spurs/Jazz/Suns/Celtics/Pistons/Hornets' (note that all the teams listed have an All-Star scoring PG except the ones that absolutely butt raped another team in a ridiculous franchise player purge to have 3 all-stars on their roster - something we can't rely on) but if you say "We need a dominant post player" and you get a guy that turns out to be a tweener or a guy that was abusing smaller players in college and can't do the same in the NBA, then you end up with Joe Smiths Golden State Warriors or Shareef's Grizzlies. Toronto tried to emulate Phoenix's offense so got themselves T.J Ford to be their Nash. Problem is - Ford is no Nash, and the Raptors are therefore, no Suns.
HeatSince88 wrote:You can find a lockdown defender at PG with your MLE. One who has a 3-point shot defenses have to respect so Wade has room to do his thing.
You cannot find a post presence with your MLE.
Again, I'm not looking for a PF with the MLE, I'm looking at next season to get a legitimate PF when we have max cap space, or even during this offseason or this trade deadline when Haslems contract or Marion's expiring deal is a great trade chip.
I don't know what guy you are planning to get at PG for the MLE, but if I remember correctly there was Beno Udrih, who I think gets re-signed by Sac, and then there was a whole lot of junk.
HeatSince88 wrote:Incidentally, it's nice Rose is "touted" as a lockdown defender, but if you watched him against decent perimeter players (not Conference USA!) he gets blown by very often. Mayo abused him, he got blown by in the title game on many occasions (and had his pocket picked easily a couple other times). He reminds me a lot fo Wade defensively ... he'll get in position and pull up his shorts like he's about to lock someone down, then the guy blows by him and he's left reaching from behind. Unless it's a guy who can't blow by him in the first place (Conference USA) ...
Well if Rose is a crap defender then obviously I don't want him. Thats up to Riley and the coaching staff to evaluate. All I have heard is positive, and the games I saw I had no reason to doubt it.
HeatSince88 wrote:Look, Rose will be a good-to-great pro. But the fundamentals of basketball -- as well as NBA standings and the history of NBA champions -- tell us you need a post presence and shooters to go along with your penetrator.
I've said all along that at the end of the day I 'trust in Riley', but I think you are severely underrating Rose's outside shot (I consider it average you consider it a liability it would seem). Especially coming from a guy who is only 19, showed amazing progress in the course of 30 college games from start to end, and would be working under Spoelstra who is supposedly a magic man in improving jumpshots.
It would seem that the difference in our opinion is that you are more ready to declare Beasley a post dominating NBA player and the PG's in the NBA FA that will sign for the MLE to be satisfactory starting PG's, while I'm more ready to assume Rose can be a dynamic starting PG with a decent 3 point shot and that there are far more sure post presences available through trades or next years FA.

















Famous 
