JJ or Bogans?

[magicianman]

i would rather keep jj. bogans is overrated and jj has a higher ceiling.

[theTHIEF]

Bogans is overrated? by whom?

[Scottg247]

JJ every time. I think people underestimate him bigtime. Everytime he has played he has produced.

[G-Heel]

I rather keep JJ, we don't need Bogans to eat up Lee's minutes. Beside, Bogans seem to reach his peak and he wasn't very valuable when we needed him (playoff). I still think JJ can become a decent player that can come in and make shots.

[magicfanatic23]

Just trade JJ. He deserves a chance to play somewhere else and I think Bogans will be better off of our bench this season than JJ will be.

[trebone]

jj but i actually see both being gone especially if dooling resigns for the 1.9mil offer.

[MMFla]

I would rather keep JJ but I think we should trade both.

76ers need a shooter now, JJ opens up the floor for Brand plus they have AMiller who can get him the ball. I like Reggie Evans from them, we could play him with Dwight and we have the scrappy rebounder we are looking for.

Bogans to a team looking for an expiring next year, he can start or come off the bench or not even be used at all their choice.

[mhectorgato]

I would rather keep JJ but I think we should trade both.

76ers need a shooter now, JJ opens up the floor for Brand plus they have AMiller who can get him the ball. I like Reggie Evans from them, we could play him with Dwight and we have the scrappy rebounder we are looking for.

Bogans to a team looking for an expiring next year, he can start or come off the bench or not even be used at all their choice.

Not unless we get a guard back.

We'd go from:
MP, Lee, Bogans, JJ
to
MP & Lee

At this point who knows if KeDo is coming back ...

[LBPTarHeel27]

Trade whoever has higher value on the market. I think that it depends on the team we are attempting to trade them to. JJ provides a better opportunity to retain him long term, while Bogans is currently the better player.

Personally, I would rather keep JJ because I think that Bogans has more value on the market.

[Nemesis21]

JJ

[sportsrock37]

I'm with everyone else, trade whoever we can get more back from.

Now if both had equal value then I'd agree with SpaceCoastGator.

Keep Bogans cause he can play two positions and his expiring contract could help in resigning Hedo next summer or be packaged with Battie's (and/or Hedo's, I hope not) for a potential bigger trade at the deadline.

[drsd]

Given that Bogans has a larger contract number and expires this year, he would be a better asset for Memphis over Redick.