shrink wrote:Incidentally zen, I assume that if you draft 20 - 21, and you say the league is really deep, this is a 20-team league and not a 10-team one. I gave 20-team leagues a try once, and I don't recommend them because they often do not represent the skill of the owner. The problem is that fantasy production is a bell-shaped curve, and one injury to a top guy can create an unwinnable situation. You can make a whole bunch of good picks in the 200's, but these guys upside simply does not allow them to break into the top 80 players. While some of these picks will be starters for every team, you can't make up enough ground to protect you from injuries for your key players. Since injuries can at times be unpredictable, the fact that your key players are 20, 21, 60, 61, then 100 makes the structure of the game too dependent on luck. The guy you bring off your bench to replace your key player (that guy that isn't a starter among your handful of good late picks) is just too big a downgrade in that deep a league (41>>>261)
I'm not trying to be a killjoy here, and it can still be fun. I just don't want you to be so heavily invested in it after the early prep to feel bad if you don't win.
You're not a killjoy, I'm too addicted to fantasy basketball to lose my excitement

I run this 20-team league for 4 years and we're all so fired up every season. The past couple of years we even made a draft lottery and had a prize for the winner.
I know what you mean and you're right about the key injuries. But there are so many other factors that make the 20team league better or let's say more "realistic". In a 10-12 team league everyone has a good team more or less... but when you have to pick 20 teams x 13 players = 260 players... you have to have deep NBA knowledge and skills and that makes it very challenging. After the first 5-6 rounds things get very tough and picking the right sleepers makes the difference. This is the real fantasy coaching.
And of course there's the FA pool. It's a wasteland but every now and then you have to guess which players are going to break out. It's actual scouting, checking the box scores everyday, watching the stats of ALL players.
Last season we had the best final ever. The one finalist had no key injuries all year long. He had a great team with KG, Okafor, Gay, Dunleavy etc. The other team had major injuries. They lost Gasol for some time, Jermaine O'Neal and some others but he did manage to sign Chris Quinn, Spencer Hawes and a couple of other insane sleepers who averaged huge numbers in the last month and the final finished 6-6. The first team won in total points scored. So in the end.. It's more about making a good Draft and signing the right FAs than being unlucky with injuries.