2 trade offers

[Carlton Banksy]

1)
Allen Iverson
Jermaine O'Neal
for
Mike Dunleavy
Elton Brand

2)
Vince Carter
Pau Gasol
Jerryd Bayless
Joe Smith
for
Brandon Roy
David West
Thaddeus Young
Marc Gasol


Thoughts?

[McFurious1]

2)
Vince Carter
Pau Gasol
Jerryd Bayless
Joe Smith
for
Brandon Roy
David West
Thaddeus Young
Marc Gasol

Winner is the Brandon Roy trade... not a fan of the 1st trade

[AlciG]

1)
Allen Iverson
Jermaine O'Neal
for
Mike Dunleavy
Elton Brand

2)
Vince Carter
Pau Gasol
Jerryd Bayless
Joe Smith
for
Brandon Roy
David West
Thaddeus Young
Marc Gasol


Thoughts?

Trade 1: Whoever gets the Dunleavy side wins
Trade 2: Whoever gets the Carter side wins

[Curtis Lemansky]

Trade 1: I agree that Dun and Brand side wins it by a wide margin.

Trade 2:I think the side that gets Roy-West wins it here.IMO West and Gasol are about equal;VC is about 15 spots better than Roy but questionmarks about how he will handle a tanking season in Jersey makes his value a bit iffy.Young is easily the best of the rest;I expect Bayless and Gasol to have similar fantasy seasons in terms of final rank and the difference between Young and Joe Smith is more substantial than the difference between VC and Roy.