Was offered a deal for Kobe...need some opinions

Dark Star · Post #1 » by **Dark Star** » Thu Oct 23, 2008 3:26 pm

12 teams, h2h
Was offered Baron and David West for Kobe

Want to counter Baron, West, and Deng for Kobe and grant hill or something...but that most likely won't fly

so...

Here's my team

PG Jason Kidd
(Dal - PG)
PG Rajon Rondo
(Bos - PG)
SG Michael Redd
(Mil - SG,SF)
SG Kobe Bryant
(LAL - SG) INJ
G Daniel Gibson
(Cle - PG,SG)
SF Stephen Jackson
(GS - SG,SF)
SF Grant Hill
(Pho - SG,SF)
PF Carlos Boozer
(Uta - PF,C)
PF Jermaine O'Neal
(Tor - PF,C)
F Troy Murphy
(Ind - PF,C)
C Ben Wallace
(Cle - PF,C)
C Andris Biedrins
(GS - C)
Util Ryan Gomes
(Min - SF,PF)
Util Shane Battier
(Hou - SF) INJ
BN Kyle Korver
(Uta - SF)
BN Ronny Turiaf
(GS - PF,C)
BN Andres Nocioni
(Chi - SF,PF)
BN Nene Hilario
(Den - PF,C)

his team

PG Baron Davis
(LAC - PG) INJ 95% 650 .426 318 .750 173 .330 1791 385 623 191 43 232
PG Chris Duhon
(NY - PG) 14% 133 .387 65 .813 54 .348 385 116 263 48 2 71
SG Vince Carter
(NJ - SG,SF) 96% 587 .456 350 .816 98 .359 1622 453 389 93 33 181
SG Luol Deng
(Chi - SG,SF) 81% 429 .479 204 .770 8 .364 1070 394 155 57 29 120
G Earl Watson
(OKC - PG) 13% 338 .453 111 .766 49 .371 836 225 531 70 11 175
SF Caron Butler
(Was - SF) 97% 439 .466 236 .901 66 .357 1180 388 284 128 20 150
SF Michael Beasley
(Mia - SF,PF) 84% - - - - - - - - - - - -
PF David West
(NO - PF) 96% 629 .482 300 .850 6 .240 1564 675 177 62 99 165
PF Al Horford
(Atl - PF,C) 88% 333 .499 155 .731 0 .000 821 785 124 60 76 137
F Kenyon Martin
(Den - PF) 56% 376 .538 123 .580 2 .182 877 461 90 88 85 91
C Zydrunas Ilgauskas
(Cle - C) 78% 417 .474 195 .802 0 .000 1029 682 104 34 120 135
C Joakim Noah
(Chi - PF,C) 54% 177 .482 134 .691 0 .000 488 416 84 68 64 89
Util Drew Gooden
(Chi - PF) 32% 332 .449 162 .753 0 .000 826 590 81 48 53 122
Util Boris Diaw
(Pho - PF,C) 30% 308 .477 96 .744 13 .317 725 378 317 61 39 155
BN Udonis Haslem
(Mia - PF) 9% 237 .467 115 .810 0 - 589 443 68 39 18 67
BN Jerryd Bayless
(Por - PG) 6% - - - - - - - - - - - -
BN Anthony Carter
(Den - PG) 3% 218 .458 64 .753 45 .349 545 200 388 108 28 124
BN Darrell Arthur
(Mem - SF,PF)

i figure baron is due to miss at least 20 games due to last years mins and the new contract, west is solid, and deng can be great but if its just west and baron i don't know, im not jumping on it
im not opposed to moving him but its gotta be worth it
any ideas would be welcome
thanks

Hitman02 · Post #2 » by **Hitman02** » Thu Oct 23, 2008 5:00 pm

Just my opinion,

It's always hard to consider trading a megastar but, I would do it. I think West will just as good as last year if not better. And even if Baron's numbers drop like everyone thinks, he's still Baron Davis. Yes it's Kobe, but it's also a 2 for 1 deal. Especially in h2h, stack up those numbers!

DNYLkiller · Post #3 » by **DNYLkiller** » Thu Oct 23, 2008 8:56 pm

Baron/West will more than make up KObe's Pts/Assts/blks/steals/rebs/3's

Dark Star · Post #4 » by **Dark Star** » Fri Oct 24, 2008 7:20 pm

anybody else out there...let me know what you think fellas - thanks again

robertjanssen007 · Post #5 » by **robertjanssen007** » Fri Oct 24, 2008 8:50 pm

do the trade

Skai · Post #6 » by **Skai** » Fri Oct 24, 2008 9:22 pm

I personally hate 2 for 1s where I give up the best player. This deal has the potential to work out well for you, but as always -- Baron Davis needs to stay healthy.

Dark Star · Post #7 » by **Dark Star** » Fri Oct 24, 2008 9:35 pm

davis is really the hold up...i traded kobe last year for okefor and deron williams and ended up winning the league---i also traded baron in another league for prince and rip and finished like 6th so...im kind of leaning towards doing it though west is gonna have a great year and the o in la is gonna be much slower than gs - still on the fence but leaning ha