I NEED HELP! SHOULD I DO THIS TRADE!

[Frye-Fan-7]

im in a 8 team league with standard yahoo settings but with 2 QBS and 6 points per passing touchdowns. This is my current team

QB-Kitna
QB-Leinart/Alex Smith
WR-Holt
WR-Javon Walker
WR-Galloway/Hines Ward
RB-Shaun Alexander
RB-Rudi Johnson
W/R- Travis Henry/Julius Jones

So should I make this trade-

Matt Leinart
Javon Walker
Rudi Johnson
for
McNabb
Mark Clayton
Brandon Jacobs

I need help!

[lpsevier]

Well...

McNabb > Leinart
Clayton < Walker
Jacobs < Johnson

Given McNabb's injuries and the fact that you start two QB's I'd say no. In fact I wouldn't touch this deal. Maybe if a top flight receiver was thrown in (Chad Johnson, Steve Smith, etc) instead of Clayton I may reconsider.

[vincecarter4pres]

I would like this trade if it was Mcnabb and Jacobs for Rudi and Leinharrt straight up.

Leave Walker out of it and I think its great.

If Mcnabb is healthy I think He is a big upgrade over Leinhart and I feel Jacobs will be top 6 RB this year.