Post#9 » by Bulltalk » Tue Jul 28, 2009 9:48 pm
The thing about Balentien for me is that he's reached the point where you have to patiently commit to giving him his shot at sticking in the majors, much like Clement in this way. Nonetheless, it's "iffy" as to whether or not such a commitment will pay good dividends for having taken the gamble, again much like it is with Clement.
IMO, being somewhat similar to each other in what you hope from them as hitters, and not exactly being strong defensive players (although Balentien surprised me a few times this year), I think the M's would be best served by picking one of the two in making such a commitment towards, and using the other one in some such package to acquire a player playing a position of need for the team.
If you follow and agree with my logic (perhaps you don't), then the question is which of these two players do you keep, and which of the two do you use in some such trade package? Obviously, keeping Clement would be the hands down choice if we had faith in him defensively as a catcher. But we don't.
With our outfield better set for the immediate future, however, and two aging vets now holding down the DH position, Balentien does seem the logical choice between the two to send off.
That's my thinking at the moment about such things.
"I'm a truth teller. All I do is tell the truth."
(Donald Trump - 8/11/16)