Marshall or Bowe?

[treiz]

Apparently we are interested in both as are many other clubs, the question is who would you prefer and what do you reckon it would take to get them?

I'd prefer Bowe, he's not a headcase like Marshall even though I like Marshall and view him a better WR. But I think Bowe is not far from that elite status and quietly gets 1000 yard.

For the trade I think we can get Bowe for a pick(2nd/3rd) and someone like B.Thomas and Eric Smith. I actually also think maybe we can do TJ plus a pick.

What's your opinion?

[BowlingChick]

I definitely take Bowe. No baggage and a guy who will work hard to become the number 1 receiver on the Jets.

[BarryB1124]

I want no part of Marshall after that stupid practice escapade. The guy isn't worth the headache. He's a suspension waiting to happen at anytime during or outside of the season. Who needs that?

I would welcome Bowe, but would prefer not to give up a #1 pick to do it. If a #1 pick is required, I'd sooner go with what we've got. Figuring that a rookie QB will exhibit growing pains, I think we're looking at 7-9, 8-8 or 9-7 even with Bowe. In the scenario of trading a first, I'd keep it and take my chances next season and beyond...when this team really has a chance to do something.