In my mind Deron and Paul are disqualified based on turnovers. 5 or more turnovers per game is ridiculous, especially for someone like Paul who doesn't handle the ball that often. He's just a bad passer.
I'm going with CJ, only one turnover and a classic AK-like stat sheet. He had some good defense and did a lot of little things to help, I think he was the x-factor.