Need stats / facts to help prove this hater wrong!

[mattlanta]

This hater has been hating on the Hawks for ever now! And he's on my case right now about Josh Smith.. he says he has never improved under Woodson and says he'd take these PFs over him:

Carlos Boozer
Chris Bosh
David West
Dirk Nowitzki
Kevin Garnett
Pao Gasol
Tim Duncan
Michael Beasley

HELP!

[ATL DirtyBird]

1. IDK, probably no
2. Yes
3. No
4. Yes
5. No
6. No
7. No, hes too old
8. HELL NO

If he wants Beasley over Josh than he shouldnt talk basketball. Hes a moron. Show him a Josh Smith box score.

[dpaulh]

Agreed. At this point I would only take Dirk or Bosh. With either of those, we would be one of the favorites to win it this year. The others simply aren't as good, are too old, or have a much lower ceiling than Josh. Remember Josh is only 24.

[evildallas]

Show them the box score from Game 2 against Milwaukee.

[raleigh]

I'm a Gasol fan, but otherwise I agree with your list, Dirty Bird.