I suggest you rersearch Tony Douglas and Walker's 3pt shooting . Check out Wilson Chandlers fg percentage as well. A 2nd Star BIG, shooting and huge growth potential (in terms of young talent) trumps a ball dominant PG with no 3pt range and defensive center with little offensive punch. It goes without saying that NY as city takes precedence over Chicago.
Im not even sure how to respond to this. I never said anything about Chicago in my OP. However I think you and many other NY fans arnt giving Chicago enough credit for what they already have. Deng, Hinrich, and Gibson are all NBA starters, and the team has a draft pick this year. Why do people from NY act like Rose and Noah are scrubs?
Anyways the point I was making was the the 08 Boston team had more 3pt shooting and they had a bunch of vets with playoff experince. Even a team that has LBJ, Bosh, Gallo, Douglas, and Chandler doesnt have anyone over the age of 25. If they were to win it all, im sure that would be by far the youngest team to ever do it.
Hmm..
Rondo > Douglas
Allen = Gallinari
Pierce < Lebron
Garnett > Chandler
Perkins < Bosh
Seems fairly equal to me.
Why would you not compare Bosh to Garnett?
And im sorry, but Gallo is not = with Ray Allen.
You can just look at it like this and say that it looks about equal, there is more to it. That Boston team is stacked with vets and they were a defence first team. Not to mention the there line up has 3-4 allstars in the starting lineup, and Posey and PJ brown coming off of the bench.
None of the players for NY have even reached their prime yet. Im not sayin that they wouldnt be one hell of a team, but I think 08 celtics is a bad comparison. Boston has 3, maybe 4 HOF on the roster.
IMO, d-fence and vetern players are very very importiant parts in winning a championship and that NY roster doesnt have much of either.