Lane1974 wrote:Other than block shots like it's going out of style and playing great defense, what can Alonzo Mourning do that Shavlik Randolph can't?

Horrendous analogy. Chalmers is a good young player with a lot of potential, was captain of a National Champion, and was our second leading scorer in the playoffs. Derek Fisher is among the worst PGs in the league defensively whose locker room presence is mostly propped up by his history with the Lakers franchise and his relationship with Kobe Bryant and Phil Jackson. There's no way to guarantee that these qualities translate being a team leader in Miami. And I don't even believe there will be conflicts in the locker room to defuse so long as we fill out the roster with guys who know their place. (and don't bring in some imbecile like Shaq)
Wade, Bron, and Bosh all chose to be together. They are all close personal friends. This is not Kobe and Shaq. It's not even remotely similar. The idea that there will be ego clashes is a fabrication due to wishful thinking by the national media. If we need someone to step up and get people in line during the playoffs who has a championship pedigree, we have a guard named Dwyane Wade that can do that. Derek Fisher will do nothing but slow down this team offensively and weaken our perimeter defense.
To compare a sub-par college player who's never played a meaningful minute in the NBA to a borderline hall of famer. And then say that's similar to my comparison of one of the stars of a national championship team with a promising NBA career to a guy Fisher who at the same stage in his career was not nearly as accomplished.... Well that's just disingenuous at best.
Derek Fisher became Derek Fisher because he was put in that situation time and time again due to his supporting cast. Can you dispute my position that he will slow down our offense and weaken our perimeter defense? That Mario Chalmers is superior both offensively and defensively to Fisher at this stage in their career and in similar stages of their career?
Personally, I feel that Chalmers blossoms into a better version of Derek Fisher on this team. And the likelihood of that happening is far greater than Derek Fisher saving us from a Wade vs. LeBron meltdown, or whatever unsubtantiated scenario the national media is projecting. Nothing in Wade, Bosh, or LeBron's career suggests that they're not strong leaders who get along with their teammates. So by signing Fisher we'd be fighting and imaginary ghost.