Post#976 » by fishercob » Thu Aug 26, 2010 2:08 pm 
            
            
            So while I couldn't sleep last night, I had the following thought:  some to much of the debate over keeping Gilbert has to do with his move to SG.
Offensively, I have no concerns about Gil at the "2".  He played in a 2-guard front in Eddie's offense and was an offensive superstar.  FLip has pointed out at that he played very well off the ball (with Boykins at PG) last year.  Plus, he's going to be playing off of pure PG who will create opportunities for him and for a smart coach who can put him in position to succeed.  Offense will not be a problem.
So the question is on D.  And it occurred to me that we keep hearing about how it's a point guard's league right now and there are all these young superstars at PG.  Wouldn't we rather Gil not be tasked with slowing these guys down?  Who is Gil better suited to guard.
Eastern SG's:  Wade, Redick, S. Jackson, Ray Allen, Morrow, Azubuike, E. Turner,  Derozan, R. Brewer, A. Parker, B. Gordon, D. Jones, Salmons
Eastern PG's: Chalmers, Jameer, Livingston, Rondo, D. Harris, Felton, Holiday, Calderon, Rose, Mo WIlliams, Stuckey, Collison, B. Jennings
In the East, there are a ton more matchup problems for Gil at PG than SG.  He gives up size (height) to a number of SG's, but only a select few have the strength and post game to take advantage of it (Stephen Jackson -- Charlotte is going to give us fits this year).   Sure, Wade will give him problems, but he gives everyone problems.  
Western SG's: Ellis, Gordon, Kobe, Richardson, EVans, Caron, Martin, Mayo, Thornton, Manu, Afflalo, C. Brewer, Sefolosha, Roy, Raja Bell
Western PG's: Curry, Baron, Blake, Nash, Udrih, Kidd, Brooks, Conley, Paul, Parker, Billups, D. Williams, Westbrook, A Miller, Flynn
Many more tough matchups at SG in the west, but more superstar PG's as well (Curry, Nash, Brooks, Paul, Parker, Westbrook and D-Will are all super tough covers for Gil).  
Overall, it remains to be seen whether Gil will do what he needs to do to be an acceptable defender.  However, I think given the rules and the personnel, he has a better shot at succeeding guarding SG's than PG's.  Most of these same SG's will have a devil of a time guarding Gil as well.
            
                                    
                                    "Some people have a way with words....some people....not have way." 
— Steve Martin