The Karma Thread (NYG Fan Edition)

[aveboogie7]

of course i was. i always thought peyton is clearly the best QB in the league.

Drew Brees would beg to differ.

drew brees has an oline, when peyton does not.

Neither guy gets sacked much, so I'm not even sure how you come to that conclusion?

[I am Ra]

^^^ Well u obviously look suspect for posting ur first post as soon as Revis got burned.

well i was there the whole time and was there even after you werent. but I guess I was just trolling. smh. drive your agenda.

U never posted anything though. U keep saying u were there. Where? It was only me and Rich Rane posting u mustve been lurking then and decided ur first post should be when Revis got burned.

i thought it was funny is all. I explained why later in the thread.

[I am Ra]

Neither guy gets sacked much, so I'm not even sure how you come to that conclusion?

watching games helps. and read what i wrote about brady. peyton is on another level. if you dont believe it then you dont know fb.

[I am Ra]

i see your point, but you made it like the jets hadnt faced a top offense / qb when in fact they have. and they beat him/them. the giants didnt when they faced one. dif teams and qbs yes, but not by much.

facing peyton is another animal. imho you can get away with not having your absolute best against the pats, but the colts is another story.

[knicks9784]

i see your point, but you made it like the jets hadnt faced a top offense / qb when in fact they have. and they beat him/them. the giants didnt when they faced one. dif teams and qbs yes, but not by much.

facing peyton is another animal. imho you can get away with not having your absolute best against the pats, but the colts is another story.

yeah and im sure if the jets beat the colts and giants lost to the pats this past sunday im sure you'd say the same thing. lol

ohh and dont tell that to the texans.

[aveboogie7]

Neither guy gets sacked much, so I'm not even sure how you come to that conclusion?

watching games helps. and read what i wrote about brady. peyton is on another level. if you dont believe it then you dont know fb.

Again....Manning was sacked 13 times in 2009, Brees 21.

New Orleans' line run blocks much better, but in pass protection, where's the perceived superiority coming from?

[richardhutnik]

yup, you knew this was comming.. giants fans taunting last week, and what happens.. the jets come out and dispose of the pats and the giants are getting theirs handed to them tonight...

Except we dont talk bs about our team. we let our play do the talking.

jets do and they deserve this.

What is this, "we let our play do the talking"? You going to end up going into the RB rotation if Jacobs is no longer with the team? Exactly what do you do personally that leads to wins and losses for the Giants?

Fandom is a weird thing. So much emotional investment in things people have so little control over.

- Rich

[NYSport]

Drew Brees vs Peyton Manning is a tough call as both are clearly 1 and 2 at the QB posistion. That's no disrespect to Tom Brady as he's a monster himself. That said, we all know Brees and Manning can get the ball almost anywhere on the field, and both are incredibly smart. If I had to choose one though I'd give the edge to Manning, with the tie breaker going to the fact that Brees' production is a combination of his skills/intelligence and Sean Payton's offense. Whereas, Manning is more so the offensive coordinator himself.