Build a Team Discussion

[Moochiefried]

I would be a judge, if you don't mind my relatively low post count. I'd understand if you wanted one of the forum veterans to do it instead though.

[Miklo]

No I don't think we need to worry about post count, heck it doesn't even matter how you score it as long as you're consistent so I think the more the merrier

[Gorilla Warfare]

Obama is my assistant coach.

I win.

[Miklo]

Alright I edited the thread title, once a couple more GM's volunteer to judge we'll get this thing kicked off. I'm getting something together as we speak to use as a "scorecard".

[JasonDaPsycho]

I don't mind doing some judging.

[lilfishi22]

If we don't have enough judges why don't the GM's of the teams judge? As long as you aren't allowed to judge your own team, I don't have any problems with the GM's judging.

[DRK]

Have you asked if some of your Moderator buddies want to be judges Miklo?

[TASTIC]

He doesn't have any

[Miklo]

If we don't have enough judges why don't the GM's of the teams judge? As long as you aren't allowed to judge your own team, I don't have any problems with the GM's judging.

Yeah that's what I'm hoping now is that we can get GM's to sign up. Does that mean you volunteer?

Have you asked if some of your Moderator buddies want to be judges Miklo?

My only friend just responded

He doesn't have any

Haha no, TASTIC and I can see about pulling in some favors from other mods, but if we can get a few more GM's to volunteer we may be set to go.

I'm designing the online survey right now, where judges will simply be able to select a rating in each category for every team so judging will be easy...anyone else??

[lilfishi22]

If we don't have enough judges why don't the GM's of the teams judge? As long as you aren't allowed to judge your own team, I don't have any problems with the GM's judging.

Yeah that's what I'm hoping now is that we can get GM's to sign up. Does that mean you volunteer?

lol I wouldn't have brought it up if I wasn't up for it.

[DRK]

Pretty sure a couple of the Knicks mod's wouldn't mind judging. The Knicks board are hardcore players of the BAT's.

[Calvin Klein]

If we don't have enough judges why don't the GM's of the teams judge? As long as you aren't allowed to judge your own team, I don't have any problems with the GM's judging.

Yeah that's what I'm hoping now is that we can get GM's to sign up. Does that mean you volunteer?

Have you asked if some of your Moderator buddies want to be judges Miklo?

My only friend just responded

He doesn't have any

Haha no, TASTIC and I can see about pulling in some favors from other mods, but if we can get a few more GM's to volunteer we may be set to go.

I'm designing the online survey right now, where judges will simply be able to select a rating in each category for every team so judging will be easy...anyone else??

I would be able to do it if it doesn't require too much explanation because I wouldn't be very good with words.

[nevetsov]

When do you need judges? I might be able to help out from about the 14th to the 21st November if that is not too late. Looks like it might take a few days to get through it all.

[Miklo]

Yeah CK, you don't need to write at all - it'll be an online survey where you just pick 1, 2 3 4 or 5 in each category.

nevetsov, that sounds fine - we can even have other judges start before then so that definitely works. Thanks!

[Calvin Klein]

Im in then.

[DRK]

I'll volunteer as I am a pretty frequent poster. Although when is the dealine for all the judging? Unfortunatly I won't have enough time to do any judging before Novermber 15th, as I have exams. Anytime after November 15th and I'll free.

[Miklo]

Alright now that we're after the 15th a couple people who posted may be available to judge by now. I'll finally get the ballot ready for this weekend to get it rolling.

[Miklo]

Update: teams that don't have a post will not be judged - I realized that all those teams would get terrible grades anyway since they didn't pick coaches, don't have anything about the logic or gameplan etc. It's not fair to make the judges spend time on those that ultimately don't matter, I'd rather compare the people who really fought hard to the end.

The one exception I can think of is Qwigglez since he was away, we'll see if he can make a post for his Hawks.

[DRK]

Yep. Lets get the judging started. Do you want to allocate teams to each judge to be judged Miklo? (If that made sense )

[Miklo]

I was hoping to get every judge to do all the teams that made posts - if you don't have much time you can skim the posts for each team, as long as you pay each one the same amount of attention.