who'd you rather?

[bill russell]

i know it's only four games but why wait?

Chris Bosh (26 yrs, 7 yrs pro): 13 points, six rebounds, 1 block, 1.5 assists, eff. 15.2, 14.5 million
Andrea Bargnani (25 yrs, 4 yrs pro): 24 points, 4.5 rebounds, 2 blocks, 1.5 assists, eff. 18 (after three games), 8.5 million

[illest23]

lmao, bosh playing as a THIRD option with 2 of the top THREE players in the nba today, and andrea being our number one option on offense, great comparison. We've seen what bosh did without bargnani and vice versa. The true question would be, Bosh or Al jefferson (we could've got him for the TPE)

[5DOM]

I'd rather have Chris Bosh obviously. Better player at bargain price.
The first thing I'd do though is to trade him for picks.

[airhaj]

Yeah but we'd never have gotten Bosh at that price. If we kept him, we'd have him for the max and that's being realistic. He only took that paycut to be with Wade and James, had he stayed here, he'd be on a 20 million contract with us per season so under those realistic conditions I'd take

Bargs @ 8.5 mill + cap room > Bosh at 20 mill and no cap room

[34_fifty]

bosh is definitely the better player

but in our situation
i'd rather have bargnani plus the available cap room...

[Volcano]

I prefer defensive juggernauts over offensive. Then look for my offense from other players. Dirk is the best offensive juggernaut who's average at most on D. He was also built around the most effectively..compared to every other offensive PF and he still can't get a ring.

[plainballing]

Neither. Cousins!

[fredericklove]

Maybe you should imagine what stat line Bargs would get if he was playing w/ bron and wade in miami.

[AB_21]

Maybe you should imagine what stat line Bargs would get if he was playing w/ bron and wade in miami.

/thread

[martypython]

I prefer defensive juggernauts over offensive. Then look for my offense from other players. Dirk is the best offensive juggernaut who's average at most on D. He was also built around the most effectively..compared to every other offensive PF and he still can't get a ring.

Thanks to the referees and Wade's flopping.

[pass first]

Maybe you should imagine what stat line Bargs would get if he was playing w/ bron and wade in miami.

If Zydrunas Ilgauskas can outproduce Bosh per minute Bargnani can too.

[team edward]

Maybe you should imagine what stat line Bargs would get if he was playing w/ bron and wade in miami.

If Zydrunas Ilgauskas can outproduce Bosh per minute Bargnani can too.

Dre would do well. No double-teams, lots of open looks.

[Shevy]

Why is this even a thread??? Obviously Bosh.

[Volcano]

I prefer defensive juggernauts over offensive. Then look for my offense from other players. Dirk is the best offensive juggernaut who's average at most on D. He was also built around the most effectively..compared to every other offensive PF and he still can't get a ring.

Thanks to the referees and Wade's flopping.

wow! I thought this was the PC board..not the fantasy board

I like Andrea over Bosh. More blocks, points and three's.