ATL/ DET

[FCNATL85]

Would you do this?

Bibby- Evans and ATL 1st for Stuckey- Maxiell as it seems that both have become indesiable in DET?
ATl release Collins & signs Hayes or elies on Sy and JJ as back ups

Stuckey- Teague
JJ- JC1- JC2
Marv- Hayes- JJ
Smoothe- Powell- Maxiell
Horford-Zaza- Thomas

[HoopsGuru25]

The Hawks couldn't afford it unless Stuckey was a one year rental.

[theatlfan]

IF DET was willing to ditch Stuckey for this package, then this could offer us some interesting options. I'd think our focus would be seeing if we could involve a 3rd team that would send back better fit for us though. Some team might like to take on Stuckey as a combo guard scorer who's only an RFA after this season. Teams like NYK or ORL would have to think hard about Stuckey, since both would like a young wing scorer to pair with a superstar big.

I don't see DET doing this though. Stuckey may have fallen out of favor, but I still think he'd be worth more than a mid to late 1st and knocking a year off Maxiell's deal. They do get a couple of parts that match up well, but I'd think that want a little more. Maybe a 1st from the 3rd team?

[Spider156]

Detroit won't do this trade. Dumars is high on Stuckey and I personally wouldn't even consider it. Change Stuckey with Rip and you got a deal!

[theatlfan]

Detroit won't do this trade. Dumars is high on Stuckey and I personally wouldn't even consider it. Change Stuckey with Rip and you got a deal!

What would you say if there was a 2nd 1st from another team? If we shipped Stuckey to a 3rd team who also gave a 1st to you on top of this deal, what would y'all think?

[Spider156]

Detroit won't do this trade. Dumars is high on Stuckey and I personally wouldn't even consider it. Change Stuckey with Rip and you got a deal!

What would you say if there was a 2nd 1st from another team? If we shipped Stuckey to a 3rd team who also gave a 1st to you on top of this deal, what would y'all think?

So we get two or three first rounds? Which one? If it's three, I would do it.

[theatlfan]

Detroit won't do this trade. Dumars is high on Stuckey and I personally wouldn't even consider it. Change Stuckey with Rip and you got a deal!

What would you say if there was a 2nd 1st from another team? If we shipped Stuckey to a 3rd team who also gave a 1st to you on top of this deal, what would y'all think?

So we get two or three first rounds? Which one? If it's three, I would do it.

No, it's a total of 2: 1 from us, 1 from a 3rd team in the deal. Basically, the trade mentioned above, but add in a 3rd team who you'd ship Stuckey and Maxiell to. The 3rd team would ship us some assets and you another 1st.

For example:
ATL gets: Pietrus + Orton; ORL gets: Stuckey + Maxiell; DET gets: Bibby + Mo Evans + '11 1st from ATL + '11 1st from ORL

Not saying this is a deal I'd do (we'd be going with Teague and the JC's as our PGs; not to mention the fact that we'd be helping ORL), but it's more to give the structure of the deal. Would 2 late(ish) 1sts + the ability to shave a year off Maxiell's deal be enough?

[Spider156]

Then it depends on the team. If it's the Raptors, Clippers, Kings, or Timberwolves, I would do it. I wouldn't do it if it was Orlando. That's a contender. The first round pick would have to be a lottery one- bottom 15 teams.