Fair Trade?

[JDP]

A week ago two guys in my league swung a deal with the guy who I want deal with sending Rivers the other way and him getting McCoy other pieces were included but aren't really relevant. Anyways I think he was banking on his pick up of Stafford to hold down his QB position. With Stafford suffering an Injury again on his shoulder I promptly sent him this trade:

He'd Get: Kyle Orton, Michael Turner

I'd Get: Adrian Peterson

Anyways I just wanted to know what you guys think about this trade proposal.

[Maritimer]

It's fair to me. Assuming you have a QB you're comfortable starting instead of Orton, I'd be pretty happy if he accepts.

[ZedgetRedd]

If I were him, I would probably do it if his qb's aren't that good, and if yours are.

As for me, I proposed

LT and Troy Smith for Flacco.

(he has Shonn Greene)

Is that fair for both of us? I would still have Steven Jackson, Peyton Hillis, Knowshon Moreno, and Danny Woodhead as running backs, and my current qb's (other than Smith) are Aaron Rodgers and Shuan Hill.

[Maritimer]

Don't know why you need Flacco with Rodgers on board, unless you're in a 2 QB league. You've got two solid top RBs, but I don't love Moreno or Woodhead from a consistency standpoint.... I'd rather have LT. If you're worried about LT's potentially diminishing workload, I'd either try to acquire Greene or package LT+Woodhead for a better RB from him (I'm not sold on Woodhead long term with Taylor soon coming back and the degree to which the ball gets spread around in NE).

[ZedgetRedd]

Yeah, it is a 2 qb league.