Brodeur vs. Luongo

[Crowned]

Who would you take? I'd go with Brodeur anyday of the week personally. I know there are a ton of Luongo supporters on the board, so it should be an interesting debate.

[moose man]

I'd also go with Brodeur. He's proven to be a clutch goalie when it counts. Luongo has never seen a playoff series. Set the defence aside.

[ajaX82]

First off this depends on the context:

Choose a goalie for one game, or choose a goalie to be on your team right now.

If its one game, its hard to go against Brodeur (im a huge Luongo fan so i would still choose him)

If its for your team from now on, its easily Luongo, the age factor is huge.

[Andrea>Dirk]

In the playoffs, you just can't go against Brodeur IMO, until Luongo proves something there. I want to say Roberto because he is the new generation Brodeur, but not as of now.

[RoyceDa59]

To put it simply, Brodeur is a 3 time Stanley cup champion and Luongo has yet to play in a playoff game (although that will change this season). I'll go with the goalie who can make a cast as the GOAT goalie of all time.

[Snayr]

First off this depends on the context:

Choose a goalie for one game, or choose a goalie to be on your team right now.

If its one game, its hard to go against Brodeur (im a huge Luongo fan so i would still choose him)

If its for your team from now on, its easily Luongo, the age factor is huge.

Exactly. If you're talking about building your franchise around a certain guy, i'd have to go with Luongo due to the age factor. If it was for one game, or even the next couple years i'd bank on Brodeur.

[MAS]

are they both the same age hypatetically

cause if Luongo is younger then i'm gonna take him

but over the course of his career and his clutchness, i take Brodeur

[The_Child_Prodigy]

Well right now its Brodeur. But if you want a goaie fr the future you have the future second best goalie in the league in \loungo.

[Rhyno]

Brodeur, without question. Talk about a guy who's been there and done that. While Luongo is a great goaltender, for all we know he could be another Marty Turco in the post-season and only time will tell how truly great he is. But this one is a no brainer, Brodeur is the best in the business.

[Southward1]

Brodeur...no doubt

[Mike Hunt]

I think Luongo is the better goalie right now but if I could only pick one guy to play game 7 of the finals for me, it'd be Brodeur. I have to reluctantly admit that Brodeur will go down as GOAT at his position (Patrick Roy is my all-time favorite player).