Build a Team Discussion

[lilfishi22]

I know we are judging the team, but are the judges going to stay anonymous? I don't want complaining if someone thinks I score them too low or whatever.

[Miklo]

I know we are judging the team, but are the judges going to stay anonymous? I don't want complaining if someone thinks I score them too low or whatever.

Yep judging will be anonymous.

[lilfishi22]

lol and you can't judge your own team right?

[Miklo]

lol and you can't judge your own team right?

Correct, forgot to mention that in the PMs but yeah I just won't count it if people do

[lilfishi22]

Because I'm pretty sure my team is a 98 give or take 1 or 2 lol.

[lilfishi22]

Also, since some teams haven't haven't been real thorough (or didn't put down anything) for cap management/salary related stuff and I don't want to waste my time going to check on each player's salary, length of their deal and add up their salary, I'm just going to make an estimate and give them a mark based on my rough estimate.

[DRK]

Because I'm pretty sure my team is a 98 give or take 1 or 2 lol.

Also, since some teams haven't haven't been real thorough (or didn't put down anything) for cap management/salary related stuff and I don't want to waste my time going to check on each player's salary, length of their deal and add up their salary, I'm just going to make an estimate and give them a mark based on my rough estimate.

I did pretty much the same thing. I just looked at their payroll, their ability to contend, and the amount of expirings; and gave them a score based on that.

MIklo, is it okay if I dont remain anonymous?

[JasonDaPsycho]

Download link for spreadsheet:
http://www.mediafire.com/?vyc3gudr31b8agq
It includes all team names and the formula to calculate the total score for each team.
It doesn't look nice, but well, can't complain.

[JasonDaPsycho]

Missed a couple of teams on the sheet I believe.
I've done mine. Mostly harsh scores. Highest score given is 82, lowest being under 50.

[DRK]

Mine was quite harsh too. Highest was 84.5, and lowest was under 50 as well.

[lilfishi22]

lol the Russian Judges. I was pretty easy with my judging.

[DRK]

lol the Asian Judges. I was pretty easy with my judging.

Fixed....

Did you add comments for your's?

[Calvin Klein]

hopefully i'll have this done today.

[nevetsov]

Sounds about right, I think my highest was around 84, most were 70ish, with a selected few being under 50. I think the league average was around 67.

[Miklo]

DRK I'm moving your post to the scorecard thread. Judges, please see the most recent post in the scorecard thread for an amendment to DRK's original post.

[DRK]

Thanks Miklo. Much appreciated.

[Miklo]

Alright, well we've gotten some judging scores in so that's great. We do still have a few judges I haven't heard from so could you all let me know if you still want to judge and when you think you can do it, or if you won't be able to do it anymore? I just wanna know for sure so I can figure out when we'll wrap this baby up.

[whambamslam]

Are things about wrapped up yet?

[lilfishi22]

I'll email my scores tonight when I get home from work. Sorry for the delay.