moss_is_1 wrote:Beasley's defense/shot selection/turnovers/Low Iq have taken a toll on me.
Once again I don't get how people can be so high on Barnes but so low on Beasley.
Defense - I can see this. Barnes has better fundamentals than Beasley, but who knows how that will transfer from the NCAA to the NBA level? On top of that, any increase in individual defense from Beasley to Barnes will be greatly negated by Rambis' terrible system.
Shot Selection - Barnes' shot selection is every bit as bad, if not worse than Beasley's and has resulted in him having a terrible 1.17 Points Per Shot against college defenders that he almost always has a substantial physical advantage over. Compare that to Beasley's 1.11 PPS this year against NBA defenders and after battling a slew of injuries.
Turnovers- I've gone over this before. Beasley turns the ball over at a rate that's pretty consistent with other high usage wing players. Beasley - 12.3 TO%, 28.4 USG%, Durant - 10.5 TO%, 30.6 USG%, Granger - 12.6 TO%, 26.7 USG%. Compared to Barnes. Beasley has 3.1 TOs per 40 pace adjusted, Barnes has 2.4 TOs per 40 pace adjusted (again against much inferior defenders).
BBIQ - I'm not going to talk much on this because it can't be objectively measured, but even if Barnes does have high BBIQ than Beasley, does it even matter if it hasn't lead to better production against inferior competition?
I'll say, though, that I wouldn't mind Barnes if, and only if, he's the definite BPA where we're picking, but we shouldn't take him with the intention of using him to replace Beasley in the starting lineup (at least not right away), and we absolutely (!) shouldn't dump Beasley to make room for him. With that said, if we can move Beasley for an equal or better player at a position of more need (C, specifically) then we should absolutely do it and take Barnes to fill his spot, but that won't happen. Beasley's value has risen since this summer but not that much, so it's really not worth talking about.
Edit:
horaceworthy wrote:His game reminds me more of Ray Allen than Pierce.
His game reminds me more of OJ Mayo than either of those guys (and it doesn't remind me of Paul Pierce at all. I have no idea where that comes from).